Next Toyota Prius to Be Built in US, But "Karoshi," or Death By Overwork," Tempers the Company' s Announcement

Big news about Toyota, both good and bad.

The company is well-known for taking years to make decisions which would take others months or even weeks. Now in a bit of a very fast two-step for that company, often called the "GM of Japan" for its culture of conservatism in all things, the company has announced that a new $1 billion factory, under construction in Blue Spring, Mississippi, near Tupelo (birthplace of the King!) and originally slated to build new versions of the Highlander, will make instead, when opened in late 2010, the latest version of the company's popular gas/electric hybrid Prius. (From 2007's Tokyo Motor Show, the front-end of a gas/electric hybrid sports car to be produced by both Toyota and Subaru).

Prius will become the second gas/electric hybrid Toyota is building in the US; the Camry hybrid is already being made at one of their Kentucky plants. Toyota has also announced plans to install solar panels on the roof of the next-generation Prius, and the electricity produced will run the car's air conditioning system. Kyocera, a large Japanese engineering firm, will supply the photovoltaic cells for the solar panels, and will probably need to build a plant near Toyota's Mississippi plant, along with other suppliers from Japan already building facilities on the plant's campus.

As an aside, Japanese company Sharp has run a full-page, four-color advertisement in the main section of the Los Angeles Times every day of this week, proclaiming their belief that "the 21st century is the age of photovoltaic." The ads inform readers that the company has been responsible of fully 1/4 of all the photovoltaic cells yet produced worldwide.

Toyota's change of direction is an incredibly fast reaction to a US marketplace which almost overnight has stopped buying trucks and started buying cars, though even fewer of those, too. The US market for car and light truck sales is normally over 16 million annually, but it could lose as many as 1 million or more sales this year. (This iQ concept from Toyota at the Tokyo Motor Show might see production as early as next year with sales in Japan and Europe).

Toyota says Highlander production will be added to Toyota's underutilized truck plant in Princeton, IN. In even more rapid-fire moves, Toyota will suspend production of their full-size poor-selling Tundra pickups and Sequoia SUVs from August through November, and then, next spring, all Tundra output will be from the recently-opened San Antonio, TX plant.

But there was other news concerning Toyota, too, and not the kind which will have their corporate PR staff shaking hands and handing out cigars. This news is not the kind of thing which companies want to be known for.

For the second time in a year, a Japanese government agency has found that an employee of Toyota was killed by "karoshi," a relatively new term to the Japanese lexicon which means "death by overwork." (Sleeping on the train is a sport in every major city, though Japan's workers seem especially adept ... Maybe they're just more tired, too).

This most-recent finding, which enables the surviving family members to receive compensation from the government and collect benefits from the victim's "work insurance," concerned the death of a 45-year old worker, a lead engineer for the Toyota Camry hybrid.

This employee, who worked in Toyota City, the company's huge headquarters near Nagoya, a few hundred miles south of Tokyo, had worked more than 80 overtime hours in at least each of the last two months before he collapsed at his home, where he was determined to have died from ischemic heart disease, now officially said to be a result of karoshi.

The man was found dead at home by his daughter, and had been scheduled to leave Japan the next day for the US. The project on which he was working was to be exhibited at the 2006 North American International Auto Show, known popularly as the Detroit Auto Show.

The engineer's widow was awarded the finding by a labor bureau. In 2007, another widow was ruled by a court to be eligible for the same kind of government and company benefits, but only after her 30-year old husband collapsed and died at work in 2002. In that case, the Toyota employee died of overwork after logging more than 106 hours of overtime in a month, a judge ruled in November, 2007, reversing a government ministry's earlier decision not to pay compensation to his widow. The employee, who was working at a Toyota factory in central Japan, died of an "irregular heart beat" in February, 2002 after passing out in the factory around 4am.

In a statement, Toyota Motor Corp. offered its condolences and said it would work to improve monitoring of the health of its workers.

The Japanese Ministry of Health made news around the world in 1987, when they adopted and clarified the concept of karoshi as law; Japan is thought to be the only industrialized country which accepts death by overwork as a legal cause of death and can implicate both the company involved and the government in paying benefits to the person's survivors. Some might call these payments blood money.

In Japan, the average worker uses less than 50 percent of paid holidays, according to government data. Before any of us in America start to "tsk, tsk" those hard-working Japanese, try the following on for size, from a United Nations 2007 report: "US workers put in the longest hours on the job in industrialized nations, clocking up nearly 2,000 hours per capita in 1997, the equivalent of almost two working weeks more than their counterparts in Japan, where annual hours worked have been gradually declining since 1980, according to a statistical study of global labor trends. Americans also work the longest hours among industrialized countries, Japanese second longest. Europeans work less time, but register faster productivity gains."

This is not the kind of contest where being "#1" means you're a winner. Trying to make death by overwork acceptable to any society, because survivors are able to get some monetary benefit is ridiculous, repulsive and outrageous.

Toyota remains a huge company which nonetheless can, at times, seemingly perform magic in the way they've been able to anticipate future technologies and then spend the money and hire the people to invent them, if no one else will or can. Competitor Honda is building robots to replace human workers on their assembly lines. Perhaps Toyota will find it in their corporate selves to do something more than "offer its condolences and work to improve monitoring of the health of its workers" if they're dropping dead on the assembly lines.

Follow Steve Parker on Twitter: www.twitter.com/autojourno

Comments

[MomAnon]

Hmm. "People are our most important asset." That's the smarmy lip service many CEO's pay to the efforts of their employees. Yet people are actually dying and suffering adverse health effects from too many overtime hours, so much so that there's a new word for it. WTF?

It's a face. Creativity suffers when people are tired. Accuracy suffers when people are tired. Safety suffers when people are tired. Innovation? Dives under exhaustion.

It's time for the decision-makers to recognize that if people are your most important asset and they're dying from the amount of work they're saddled with, YOU ARE UNDERCAPITALIZED. You're broke, and selling yourselves into a hole. No product is worth that. No company is worth that. No amount of material "success" is worth that.

[SteveParker]

Hi MomAnon! Thanks very much for your comment. Tell your friends about us! We're here all day ...
I think you hit it on the head ... but somehow in this case that's probably not the best phrase to use. There are many reasons the quality of the Asian-made cars and trucks has dropped in the JD Power surveys and others. When your company has the luxury, and it is a luxury, of having to constantly make more vehicles because of demand, quality always suffers. An increasing work load without enough employees is no way to run any business, much less an automotive assembly line where injuries are common. It's no secret that young Japanese do not want to work in those kinds of environments. Honda is building robots (Google 'Asimo') to replace their assembly line workers. That's one answer for the problem.
That work is killing people, and a company and country acknowledge it, and their answer is not to examine why this is happening but to pay-off the surviving family members, is just disgusting. It's like Chrysler's current attempts to con people into buying one of their cars or trucks with a guaranteed price for gas for three years ... They should be building cars people actually want to buy, but instead they have to use some sort of financial sleight of hand.
Companies and countries which allow this situation are morally bankrupt in many ways.

[Visceral]

In the days of chattel slavery, working slaves to death was far more profitable than keeping them well-fed and well-rested in an attempt to make them more productive.

[SteveParker]

Thanks very much for your comment! Please tell your friends we're here all day ...

You've made me think of Japan and whether or not it's engaged in some modern form of slavery ... Sure, the people live in a fairly free society with great benefits like universal health care, safe, cheap and efficient public transportation everywhere and an amazingly low rate of violent crimes of all kinds. And they have a wonderful over-1,000 year recorded history. All things of which they can be proud.

But their education system relies on rote memorization amid a high level of pressure and fierce competition, and we know their history books aren't truthful when it comes to Japan's militarism in the 20th century.

It's common for the Japanese to work for one company throughout their lives; leaving a company for any reason is looked down upon and that person will find it difficult, if not impossible, to get a new job with the same level of pay and prestige the last one offered. Company loyalty is as or even more important than their relationship with their own family. One can leave a family, but leaving a job is another thing entirely.

I think this is maybe a new, modern form of slavery, an economic slavery, more of the mental variety than physical. My many Japanese friends who have come to the US absolutely love it, feeling a sense of personal freedom and wide-open opportunity they never had at home.

[larry278]

Karoshi or whatever may be found to be as comman among Japanese salarymen & other workers as black lung is among coal miners who work in under ground mines. No, I don't know if coal miners who work in strip or open cast mines also black lung. Americans will know if the USA has fully adopted to Japenese work practices if Americans start dying in bunches from karoshi.

[DragonMama]

It'll never be labeled as such in the US. Too "anti-business".

[larry278]

Where have you been DragonMama? People using MSM will think karoshi is a Polish dish, not a medical condition. The writers for traditional MSM won't know that it's a Japanese term. Where have you been?

[SteveParker]

We should have a contest (sponsored by the US Chamber of Commerce) to come up with a word or phrase describing the American version of 'death by overwork.' Our celebrity judge could be Chief Justice John Roberts.