iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Steven Weber

GET UPDATES FROM Steven Weber
 

Failed Fantasies

Posted: 07/22/2012 8:56 pm

Every day, another right wing GOP theory is tested and fails miserably.

Because in the real world, fantasy-based theories simply cannot work.

In Colorado, once again, the idea that guns should be easy to obtain and that everyone should be carrying them has been dispelled in a hail of easy to obtain bullets and destroyed lives. Why, it's right out of "The Oklahoma Kid."

In congress, GOP representatives and senators traffic in ideas culled from Ma and Pa Kettle movies and folktales describing days when men hunted and women stayed in their hand-hewn cabins clutching their aprons and baking pies. Why, it's right out of "Shane."

In the corporate-owned media, men dressed like Ronald Reagan and women dressed like Rita Hayworth disseminate grotesque exaggerations and gossip in authoritative tones.

And our kids ingest a steady diet of "games" teeming with violent imagery that propagates the fantasy that war is a noble and glorious endeavor.

It's a culture losing touch with reality. Like the distracted and deluged minds it seeks to profit from, the business model utilized by the corporate GOP to great effect is one that is drenched in unreality as well: the fantasy-within-a-fantasy that is Pottersville from "It's a Wonderful Life." It is simple and effective: the world is garish and tawdry, violence is everywhere, low pursuits consume the depressed denizens of this once proud, now corrupt town. The people who work to keep food on their tables and roofs over their heads are rabble, sometimes they're "garlic eaters." And as such they are beneath the oligarchs who know better, who live better, who are better.

There is so much fantasy taking the place of reality in this country that you cannot see a company logo that doesn't in some way have an otherworldly motif, imagery redolent of "Star Wars" with comet trails, laser beams and whirling planets; imagery that fetishizes money with gleaming gold and glittering silver; sunbeams streaming through mountainous meringue clouds denoting heaven and an afterlife. You'd think the last thing people want to do would be to live down here on earth.

But can you blame them? Down here there is the reality that people get sick and need help; people get old and need care; soldiers return from battle and need attention and rehabilitation; children need education.

Down here, men and women in positions of power are seeking to create a fantasyland where such things are masked and only spoken of in harsh, cartoonish terms. It's because they haven't the courage to confront their fantastical terrors with actual real-world wisdom.

It's like watching a movie.

 

Follow Steven Weber on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TheStevenWeber

FOLLOW POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 35
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
eaarth2
“An era ends when its illusions are exhausted
05:52 AM on 07/25/2012
Stopping warming at 2 degrees C above the Pre- Industrial is possible if we peak our emissions overs the next few years, and then begin a decline of 5% every year. The longer we wait- like in 2020 the decline will be 9%, obviously from the way things stand now- this may not be possible. Unless the climate really begins to disintegrate. If we wait till 2030- we will not be able to avoid 2 degrees unless we make draconian reductions of 15-20% a year in use of fossil fuels. If wait till 2035 reductions will need to be 25-30% - the problems just become larger.

By 2017 we will have in place the infrastructure for 450ppm C02 in the atmosphere. And that level means out of control climatic outcomes. At the rate we are going we would actually see those levels around 2032..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cindy Callas
Keep calm and Obama on.
11:56 AM on 07/23/2012
This weekend I heard the NRA described as white supremacists armed to the teeth for insurrection. I haven't seen many insurrections in my time, but I've seen too many shootings such as this one. When do they stop holding our country hostage? It is absolute cryptonite for anyone to take them on, apparently.
10:59 AM on 07/23/2012
I was watching "Pale Rider" with Clint Eastwood yesterday and I was struck again by how much we have romanticized men who carry guns. In the movie, the men who had the guns were depicted as handsome, sexy, and super-manly, The men who had no guns were depicted as weak and helpless, beaten and humiliated at will by the gunslingers. It occurred to me that maybe people who advocate for the right to carry any kind of gun, any time, any place, see themselves as characters like the gunslingers in the movie: manly, sexy, and always in control of any situation. In reality, I think gun advocates are incredibly cowardly and fearful. I was listening to C-Span yesterday and a woman called in to say that she vehemently opposed any gun control, and that she SLEEPS WITH A GUN UNDER HER PILLOW. I thought: where does she think she lives, in Syria? Even the moderator looked shocked. This country needs to wake up and see that more guns make you less safe, not more. I agree with the poster that said we need to fund an organization that will stand up to the NRA. Since the name of the game is money, then those of us who are sick of hearing about little kids getting shot need to put our money where are mouths are and massively fund such an organization. It's time for the sane people to retake control of the asylum.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MichaelMyth
It's not who's right it's what's right
10:00 AM on 07/23/2012
In discussions I have had with a gun enthusiast I say tracking guns and prosecuting illegal sales - those not recorded. Fighting straw sales and states with lax gun laws is good. He thinks I want to ban guns and I say I want law enforcement to have laws that punish bad deals and straw buys. He says government will take away guns be cause they know who have them. I think I may need to buy some guns because this guy is a crazy person who will not listen and he has guns.

2 amendment brought to you by Thomas Jefferson needs modernisation to the 21st century.
photo
Medicine13ear
Joy cometh in the morning.
06:24 AM on 07/23/2012
Time for the asteroid.
photo
AndKoolaidForAll
'Change' is the nature of OUR Universe
01:25 PM on 07/23/2012
Time is the key to that inevitability, but Yellowstone may have the greater certainty sooner.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
The Smartest Monkees
Planet of the Apes? We're on it, baby!
06:23 AM on 07/23/2012
For anyone interested, my 2 comments below concerning climate change starting with "Part 2 of this Sci-Fi channel special," should be read second comment first for fullest effect.

Ugh! I forgot that part 2 would appear above part 1. :-(
photo
Medicine13ear
Joy cometh in the morning.
06:07 AM on 07/23/2012
A couple things . . .

I have a friend who has a concealed carry permit (to defend against the nuts with guns) and he said, expectedly, "If someone in that audience was packing, the guy could have been put down before killing so many." A few minutes later he said, "But you'd wanna shoot at center mass [in the chest], and he was wearing a bulletproof vest -- he would have seen the flare of the shot and shot the shooter. There would be no opportunity for a second [head] shot."

The point? You can't defend against the crazies. They'll always get more and bigger guns. What we need to do is make some first steps of reasonable change. Yes, maintain the right to bear arms (for hunting, target shooting, or protection against nuts with guns, etc.), but REINSTATE THE BAN AGAINST ASSAULT WEAPONS. Make certain weapons ILLEGAL -- LIKE TEAR GAS CANNISTERS. LIMIT THE SIZE OF BULLET CLIPS TO 7 ROUNDS OR LESS. Can't we all agree on these basic steps?

The second thing . . .

Who pays for the injured's hospital expenses if they have no health insurance? You think the guy with the money for an arsenal of 6000 rounds will foot the bills? Or are some people going to lose their homes because of medical expenses?

What has happened to our country that every American has the right to unlimited GUNS & AMMO but every American doesn't have the right to Universal Healthcare?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
momosity
Liberal Since In-Utero
02:09 PM on 07/23/2012
Right on! I was just having that thought earlier today, except is was: who pays for the funerals? I think the NRA and the gun manufacturers should be held financially responsible when they sell assault weapons to anyone, and especially to mentally deranged persons.
photo
Medicine13ear
Joy cometh in the morning.
08:06 PM on 07/23/2012
Amen! F&F
03:36 PM on 07/23/2012
For one thing, the guy didn't have an assault rifle, that is a lie that hasn't seemed to go away. An assault rifle is select fire for both full auto and semi auto and only police and the military can have them other then the $20k legal ones that req. a 4 month background check. Second, what are you going to do about all the Mags that people own now that are over 7 rounds? Do you think people are going to quietly give them up? Third what you didn't mention and know one wants to say is the theater was a "GUN FREE ZONE" so anybody that could CCW could not there so everyone was unarmed.

About the Vest, if you shoot someone wearing a bulletproof vest with a 9mm, .40s&w, .45acp you are going to break or bruise ribs. Also, if you CCW you know not to shoot once but until the threat is neutralized like the 71 year old man in the Florida Internet cafe. If he was shot 5-17 times with a 9mm in the chest, he would be dead from shock or in to much pain to continue.

Your CCW friend needs practice more as I can put 6 rounds center mass in quick order with my pistol and that would have put him down long enough for me to relocate. The common thing with these shootings is they taking place where law abiding people are disarmed and easy pray for killers.
photo
freedom is right
Turn Right for Freedom!
02:54 PM on 07/24/2012
Yes, I found problems with Medicine's comment too. " You can't defend against the crazies."? If that's true, we are all doomed. It was hilarious watching those two thugs in the internet cafe in FL. trip over themselves in trying to get away, they couldn't run fast enough. Clearly people like the psycho in Co. will think twice before walking into a crowd with a gun if laws are more lenient and allow people the ability to be able to protect themselves in public places.
05:11 AM on 07/23/2012
Steven, reading your piece I flashed on an idea to illustrate your point.

I'd like to see a savvy video someone choose a scene from "It's a Wonderful Life" to manipulate so that the decent Jimmy Stewart character gets shot - along with a few family members or other good guys.

Then splice in some of the recent yahoos whining as to what a shame it is that other fine citizens of Pottersville weren't packing so one of them could shoot the shooter.

Then rewind and redo the shooting of Jimmy and other innocents - but adding visages of Jimmy's sweet neighbors firing away, guns a-blazing.

In other words, SHOW this beloved, benign town - as it would look - if the NRA-lovers had created it. Could be powerful.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
The Smartest Monkees
Planet of the Apes? We're on it, baby!
05:06 AM on 07/23/2012
Part 2 of this "Sci-Fi channel" special.

Fatih Birol, the International Energy Agency's chief economist states: "When I look at this data (estimates of worldwide increases in Co2 emissions each year), the trend is perfectly in line with a temperature increase of about 6 degrees (almost 11 degrees Fahrenheit).

A temperature, as the author of the Rolling Stone article I'm referencing, "The Reckoning," Bill McKibben, notes, "...would create a planet straight out of science fiction."

I love sci-fi films! Pass me the popcorn...and the sunscreen, SPF rating 1000.

And for you righties saying, "Oh yeah, liberal rag Rolling Stone!" National Geographic Magazine recently had an article reporting a similar scenario for our planet's future. No "liberal rag" they.

But can we prevent it?

Germany is the one of the only countries seriously trying. They are now nearly 50% solar powered within their borders.

The sad thing any surviving future historians writing from within their underground shelters will sadly point out, is that the technology to prevent climate catastrophe was already available.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
The Smartest Monkees
Planet of the Apes? We're on it, baby!
04:55 AM on 07/23/2012
And speaking of movies...

2 degrees Celsius (about 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit):

The global temperature increase agreed to at the mostly failed Copenhagen climate conference in 2009, that Earth's climate should remain below. We are currently at a 0.8 Celsius increase, and things are starting to get a little scary. What will 2 degrees Celsius look like?

565 Gigatons:

The amount of Co2 scientists agree we can poor into the atmosphere by mid-century, and still stay below 2 degrees Celsius. But models now show that if we stopped pouring Co2 into the sky immediately, the temp would still rise from previous outpourings to 1.6 degrees Celsius. We're already 3/4 of the way to 2 degrees.

2,795 Gigatons:

The number proven to be in known coal, oil and gas reserves, waiting to be burned. 5 times the amount scientist agree we might survive releasing. This means we have to keep 80% of those resources locked away.

But here's the rub: Fossil fuel industries (and nations) use those resource figures like equity to borrow, base share prices on and to plan their future budgets from the expected return.

27 TRILLION dollars is the estimated worth! When you ask them to cut by 80% to keep the temp below 2 degrees, you're asking them to erase 20 TRILLION dollars from their portfolios.

So burn we will. And what will the outcome ultimately be?

Word limit means you'll have to read part 2 below to find out...
photo
AndKoolaidForAll
'Change' is the nature of OUR Universe
03:20 AM on 07/23/2012
Your aim is true, Steven. Those clinging to fantasy are often terrified of being confronted by reality. Fear alone even drives some to never allow their minds and spirits to truly rest or heal. One such person very close to me once told me she thought if she ever slowed down she'd go crazy. Without telling any buzz-kill stories here, let's just say the memory of a depression-era childhood never left her despite becoming a successful university professor.

Since reading Dune as a teenager I've done my best to confront most of my fears, even dying. Frank Herbert had Paul Atreides repeat a Bene Gesserit litany against fear that went:
Fear is the mind-killer.
Fear is the little-death that brings total obliteration.
I will face my fear.
I will permit it to pass over me and through me.
And when it has gone past I will turn the inner eye to see its path.

Some near misses in younger Xtreme years taught me to always be ready to accept that 'look back' at my life, if not how to avoid still making stupid human mistakes. But they also taught me to breathe deep of this existence and find something about it to enjoy without fear - whenever possible.

Fantasyland creators need to keep folks afraid but also provide them with plenty of new fears frequently, lest the grip on their golden goose believers fail. Those embracing fear without question make their job so very easy.
photo
DivergentMary
Yin-Yang Kitties
11:09 AM on 07/23/2012
You are right about the way that people are manipulated by fear. I have been friends with my surgeon's wife for the past 30 years. In all other ways she appears to be an intelligent woman. But the Tea Party emails that she now sends me are laced with such crazy fear ~~~ not fear of the folks who want to "take their country back" by using the "Second Amendment Solution" ~~~ but fear of the ordinary people who are "ready to riot" against the 1% (of which she is part of, living in a huge house in a country club community.)

So these emails are full of advice about "how to survive" when the riots happen and their wealthy gated communities are invaded and sacked by the rest of us. For some reason, she thinks that I ~~~ a retired elementary teacher who had to work for 33 years to finally hit the $50,000 mark, is in the same boat that she is in and will sympathize with her plight and understand her fear.

The fear-mongering in the Tea Party emails is palpable, divisive, and mighty scary. And yes, it is all fantasy as far as I can see.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
skwan91607
Favor to Internationalism
12:27 AM on 07/23/2012
Failed Fantasy is a LIGHT SENTENCE to accuse the IGNORANCE of GUN POLICY. Guns don't kill is a TWIST from GUNS MAKE IT EASY TO KILL A LOT IN LITTLE TIME. Americans should have an organization rallied all the gun victims to sue the NRA who spent millions in LOBBY and the congress members who take side with NRA asking for compensations of every violence by GUNS if a strict GUN LAW could not pass the congress.
IT IS ANOTHER CRIME GOP AND TEA BAGGERS COMMIT BY TAKING SIDE WITH NRA. At the time constitution allowed to bear arm it was single shot. A meditated murder equipment himself with a number of assault rifles with 6000 bullets. How in the world to justify this is what the constotution permitted. WHAT KIND OF STUPIDITY TO READ THE CONSTITUTION. SUE ITS PANTS DOWN FOR SUCH IGNORANCES.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kidrooms
Kansas Mom
11:47 PM on 07/22/2012
I used to worry when my son first was interested in video games that he would become one of the characters in the show. I did see evidence of it, when he was allowed too much time with Runescape and other fantasy games that took a great deal of time. But he also had two parents who loved him, taught him other things, showed him humanity and kindness for his fellow man, characteristics of people that cared not only about themselves but others less fortunate. When his tastes for games became more violent and included some of the games many of us cringe at when spoken of, I worried more...but, he also has his music and his friends and his family and balance. I don't know anything about this kid, his family or his problems, and his family may have done everything right, but when people who are mentally ill, have unfettered access to ammunition and guns without the means to determine if they are a threat, then we all will be at the mercy of the disturbed who can get these weapons of mass destruction. If his name were Muhammed, would someone have noticed? We monitor Ambien and Claritin D...but not assault weapons or 6000 rounds of ammunition? How is it that gun lobbyists believe this is right or just or safe? I hope for a champion in these circumstances who won't to shut up, compromise, and can get things done. Oprah, Warren???
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cindy Callas
Keep calm and Obama on.
11:57 AM on 07/23/2012
Barney or Bernie?
11:24 PM on 07/22/2012
I have this feeling that,the more fantasy is created, the more their(politicians) power is sustainable, and it's a terrible chain reaction where people in general are so tired that they go through the easy - and wrong - way, just to keep sleeping. They just want to be iluded and ruled. But then some of us, who don't want to be iluded, feel powerless against the number of people who just don't have this awareness that simple things could actually change their/our world, like voting right, and demanding people basic rights.

I guess this amount of fantasy is also falling on the gap left of many years of the old belief that America is "the promise land". I compare it to a child who was spoiled and grows up to find out that life in general is not that easy. And instead of getting up and facing it, this "new adult" decides to keep on living in that fake reality.

And then you could ask me: what does a brazilian woman know about that? We live the same thing here. Samba and football have been closing the eyes of brazilians for too long. Panis et circenses. And no education, with no education, no critical sense, and we have the growing snowball effect all over again. It happens ALL OVER THE WORLD, if you want, you will see it.

But that's just me thinking loud. I might be wrong.
11:22 PM on 07/22/2012
Over and over, the reports in the media indicate that the only group of people who saw anything disturbing about this idiot was the gun club management (to which) he wanted to attach himself. And as to the semi auto rifle, it was reported to have jammed immediately, causing him to switch to his pump shotgun (and pistol?). So much for the evil assault rifle and the killer magazines.

Isn't it sad when a good story fails miserably?
photo
Medicine13ear
Joy cometh in the morning.
06:20 AM on 07/23/2012
Assault rifle. ASSAULT rifle. ASSAULT RIFLE. It's in the name of the frig gin weapon! It's only purpose is for ASSAULT!!! And yes, that's EVIL. And so are the KILLER magazines that KILLED!
12:10 AM on 07/24/2012
Nope, wrong on that. An "assault gun" by military definition is a full auto "selective fire" weapon. Those kinds of weapons are highly regulated in the US. In other words, a "real" assualt rifle (be it an M-16 or AK -47), cannot be purchased in the US unless you posses a "class 3" license provided by the ATF. It is an incredibly lengthy process and only a fraction of applicants ever see a full auto weapon. So much for the hype about walking into a gun store and walking out with a machine gun.

What you and the other anti - gun people are mixing up is the concept of a semi-auto rifle that cosmetically resemble their military counterparts. AR-15's, are a pleasant gun for men and especially women to use, and they are accurate. My family has used the AR-15 type for hunting antelope and deer for decades. The US Olympic shooting team uses the AR-15 as do other organized gun teams all over the US. They are inanimate objects are most assuredly not evil.

Don't allow yourself to get confused with the nomenclature. I recommend you visit you closest certified gun range and fire a few target rounds with either platform (AR or AK).

I challenge you to take that action. My guess is you will actually have some fun, and learn not to fear what you don't now understand.

Petres