More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Stinson Carter

GET UPDATES FROM Stinson Carter
 

Living on Eggshells: Lessons From The Depression

Posted: 03/24/09 09:36 AM ET

My grandmother made the best lemon meringue pie you ever had. And when she cracked her eggs, she'd always dip her finger in the shells to get out every last drop of white. She was a child of The Depression, her mother died giving birth to her ninth child and my grandmother -- the eldest of the nine -- had to take her mother's place at sixteen. Whatever food my great-grandfather could buy on his country mailman's wages had to be stretched to feed a house full of hungry, squalling mouths.

We're all picking up our own versions of the eggshell ritual these days. Maybe you circle past the valet until you find a spot on the street, maybe you just don't go out to eat much anymore, or maybe you go to a matinee instead of Macy's on Sunday afternoons. Even if you're doing fine, you've probably started making your coffee at home, and you've finally found the courage to say, "tap" when the waiter asks, "sparkling or flat?"

True, we will always be the creators of the Hail Mary pass, and this is still the Republic of Risk and Reward. But when did we begin to cripple ourselves with the idea that "rich" is a stage of life as inevitable as adolescence or old age, and with the attitude that no amount of debt or deception can keep us from getting our due? When were we consumed by our own consumption? We've always heard that rich and happy aren't the same thing, but its been a while since we've been forced to prove it.

The last lemon meringue pie my grandmother made was in the cramped kitchen of her assisted living apartment. When she got into that scraping out the eggshells business, I gave her a typically impatient 20-year-old's glance and offered her an extra egg. "No, this is the best part!" she said. But she also said the best part of a chicken is the bony back and the best part of being old was getting to work till she was 75.

I'm beginning to see that using every drop of egg white because every drop counts makes the best pie; eating the bony back so your kids can have the rest makes that the best piece; and being proud of your job makes working till 75 better than a cushy retirement. I may not ever be so frugal with eggs, and I wouldn't dare eat a chicken back, but I do hope she's right about that last thing.

We're all in this together, and the choices we'll have to make won't end at tap water and street parking. But in every new choice is a chance to make sure that it won't be the scope of our problems that our grandchildren remember us by, but the wisdom of our solutions.

 
My grandmother made the best lemon meringue pie you ever had. And when she cracked her eggs, she'd always dip her finger in the shells to get out every last drop of white. She was a child of The Depre...
My grandmother made the best lemon meringue pie you ever had. And when she cracked her eggs, she'd always dip her finger in the shells to get out every last drop of white. She was a child of The Depre...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 34
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
CompashCat
Urban Homesteaders are Realists
11:08 AM on 03/29/2009
I "retired" from a career with a comfortable income 5 years ago. I've been embracing "voluntary simplicity" way before this crisis ... and I'm so happy that I did!

Vacations involving airfare, hotels and car rentals have been replaced with long car camping trips where I spend only $20 a day.

A nice work wardrobe is no longer necessary, and now I only wear comfy clothes from the thrift store.

Hair cuts at salons has given way to hair cuts by friends.

Going out to eat is few and far between (except burrito stands, and an occasional drive-through fast food!), but appreciate it so much more. It is a "special event" that I share with friends.

I grow my own vegetables now, and interact with a greater community of "urban farmers."

I have time for yoga, meditation, long walks, bike rides, visits with friends, cooking wholesome foods, etc. Life with without "riches" can be quite an excellent life!

Just get out of debt first!
photo
Flavor
Change Is Now
03:22 AM on 03/27/2009
You know every American is rich, compared to other countries our homeless live better. There was a survey done a few years ago and they found out in this survey that the panhandlers made about 40,000 a year begging. Go on the streets of Africa and see if a panhandler will make that. Also, whenever you take away the jobs that are essential to the economy such as steelfactories, automobileindustry, clothingfactories etc..... you have taken away the real deal working class people we have to bring these jobs back. Also we need to curb some unecassary spending. Why ! Why! do you have to have 150 pair of shoes for one person. I had to take a good look at my own life and I found out that I could live better if I cut some spending. Buy when it's necassary, I can't spend if I don't have a job.
09:06 AM on 03/25/2009
The key to economic recovery is consumer spending. So, when you don't buy that latte, or you drive past the valet, you are putting people out of work. Also, you are not then paying local and related taxes on the purchase, thereby decreasing local government revenues. The gov of NY laid off close to 9000 state workers yesterday. Overall, there is no logic to scraping the last bit from every egg or skipping the latte - the immigrant egg factory workers and the barristas of the US are hoping that you drop an egg or two every day, and buy the viente latte.
12:24 AM on 03/25/2009
good thoughts, I enjoyed reading your post
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
impatient
07:23 PM on 03/24/2009
This was lovely.

I think something else you forgot to mention. It's not just self-sacrifice to get the last drop out of the egg, or to eat the bony back, or even to work as long as possible. It's just the right thing to do. For yourself! Getting that last drop out of the egg reminds oyu of how precious an egg is. Eating the bony back makes you work for the meat and lets you eat more slowly and maybe cut back on the meat. And really, it's jsut healthier to keep busy.

You do things just because they are the right thing to do. That was something the depression era had a feel for we've lost.

By the way, my Aunt Tony would come to visit me in graduate school and I would make homemade noodles for her and my uncle, and she used to cut the amount of eggs we'd need by filling half an egg shell with water. That got every last drop out of the egg and also ensured we could cut the number of eggs we needed. And I couldn't even tell---homemade noodles were just as good!
04:21 PM on 03/24/2009
Great commentary. We at (shameless plug) http://planetcheapskate.com aim for quality of life, which doesn't mean a big pile of stuff--or working towards having a big pile of stuff.

In fact, piles of stuff (or even money) don't necessarily make you happy, especially in the long run. This fact has become a hard lesson--didn't--and doesn't--need to be! Live within your means, and look out beyond that pile of stuff.
photo
brooklyncitizen
Quaerite primum regnum dei
02:10 PM on 03/24/2009
Interesting post.

People fall into one of two categories- they either get their self-worth from externals such as cars, beautiful homes, the right mate, right job, and many other externals that signal to the world that they are a Success.

Or people get their values from internals (Artists fall into this category) such as -relationships, right livelihood-creating the book of poems, finishing that series of Paintings or sculptures, gardening , volunteer work or any other service, and belonging and thriving within community .

Wealth is not "bad" or "wrong" but over-consumption is.However IMHO, even if we are thriving financially it is egregious to over-spend simply because we "can" especially now.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
indy100
02:00 PM on 03/24/2009
"in every new choice is a chance to make sure that it won't be the scope of our problems that our grandchildren remember us by, but the wisdom of our solutions." Amen to that!

This generation, the generation of Barack Obama, must begin to make the harder choices, the less self-centered choices, if we hope to leave our children and grandchildren with a semblance of the world we grew up in. And teaching succeeding generations the value of sacrifice and hard work isn't a bad thing either.
photo
PatA
Pink is a 4 letter word
12:41 PM on 03/24/2009
If only it was as easy as you wrote..........
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OtayPanky
You're welcome
01:32 PM on 03/24/2009
It's not easy. But it is simple.

But you've got to pick up your own little shovel and dig deep to find what you really seek.
11:33 AM on 03/24/2009
Interesting post and I know my parents were happier in the depression than a lot of us are now.
They pulled their resources together and had a closer knit community of neighbours than we have now.

I am using the challenge of recession to see what I can cut down on and yet still enjoy. Now when I have the latte from the coffee shop I really appreciate it as its only once a day. I also treat myself once a week to eating out and its still a cheaper restaurant than I used to go to. I have learned how rich I am without all the things that I thought I wanted but in fact do not need.

Every situation can be turned into a silver lining.
11:45 AM on 03/24/2009
That hardly sounds like cutting down. Cutting down is when you can't afford coffee at home and you didn't eat out for a year. I mean really, what have you actually done without? I don't think you have a clue.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kittyarmy
02:45 PM on 03/24/2009
Hey, she has to start somewhere. She's learning to curb her consumption - maybe not as much as you'd like to see...
06:27 PM on 03/24/2009
The fact that you're still able to eat out at all, let alone once a week, is a sign that you're doing ok to begin with. I, and many people I know, haven't seen the inside of a restaurant in months. We're pooling our resources and having pot lucks with the same group of friends each weekend to get through this. It really works! And we all eat much better than if we were cooking everything every night at home. Can't wait for bbq season.
10:30 PM on 03/25/2009
Maybe it's a sign that he/she didn't get into a pool of debt and still budgets and appreciates coffee and food. It is not a sin. Bet the person potlucks too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OtayPanky
You're welcome
10:01 AM on 03/24/2009
Thank you.

This column, borne out of real people coping courageously in tough times, is a welcome antidote to the happiness crap HuffPo has been pushing for some time now.

Yes, there are those who are chronically unhappy because they are truly mentally ill. They deserve both our compassion and our support.

But the rest of us - the "worried well" as Freud put it - don't need parasites disguised as helpers shilling their coaching services, books, seminars and therapy in order for us to find happiness.

It's right there in front of our nose...same as it ever was.
photo
ramal
One's only real life is the life one never leads.
08:29 AM on 03/24/2009
I could tell the same tales about my Grandparents. They were far happier and more satisfied with life than I (or most Americans) will ever be and they did it all without Prozac, support groups or therapists with never a complaint.
11:04 PM on 03/23/2009
"But when did we begin to cripple ourselves with the idea that "rich" is a stage of life as inevitable as adolescence or old age[...]When were we consumed by our own consumption?"

I have been waiting for a long time for someone to make this observation--I agree whole-heartedly.

In the past couple years, I find something as simple as shopping for clothes has become overwhelming. These days, a shop's entire January layout is crunched into a back sale corner to make way for all of February's *NEW* things. The emphasis is on hyper-consumption and new, newer, newest. Many times I think to myself, "When does it end?"

When I entered college in 2003, all of a sudden, everywhere I looked, people had iPods. It seems quaint now, but I wondered, what's so wrong with a CD player? Today, though, I still get mad that Apple comes out with a new-and-improved iPod every year. Throw away the old version, get the new one. It's not good for sustainability. But I digress.

I wish I could experience my twenties in the time before "rich" became a stage of life like my parents did in the '70s, heading to a park with friends, popping open beers and having laughs. Now it seems a lot of people in my generation don't understand that happiness doesn't have to be purchased. Life isn't all about Blackberrys and plasma TVs and fancy restaurants.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vim876
10:01 AM on 03/24/2009
There is the problem, however, of it being illegal in most places to drink beer in public parks. In any case, I think you may be hanging out with the wrong people. I'm 24, and while most of my friends have iPods, none of them buy a new one every year, and most don't even have TVs. We have each other over for homemade dinner and bottles of cheap wine and Scrabble games. I don't know what generation you are in, but I wouldn't generalize about mine.
DJBrunner
Question authority & hold them accountable.
10:09 AM on 03/24/2009
How refreshing it is to hear that from someone of your age (24?). You'll most likely be the exception rather than the rule of your generation but I'll give you this much - you'll have a deeper appreciation of what really matters in this life and along with that most likely be happier to-boot.
12:26 PM on 03/23/2009
Some of us always drink water at restaurants, and we eat at places where they don't have valet parking or even waiters. We're not all in this together, sorry.
09:29 AM on 03/24/2009
Same here. We always just get water at restaurants. You can save quite a bit if you go out with the whole family by not getting drinks.
06:30 PM on 03/24/2009
Yeah, I thought the valet comment was funny. Wow - parking on the street. What a sacrifice. This person doesn't even live in the same universe that I do.
09:36 AM on 03/23/2009
Rich and happy aren't related to one another, but it's good to be rich.