iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app

: TED Prize 2013: A Wish To Inspire The World

We Need Schools... Not Factories

  • Posted: 02/27/2013 2:47 PM
  • Updated: 03/15/2013

Winner Of the TED Prize 2013

In a special edition of TEDWeekends, TED and The Huffington Post are partnering to co-premiere a talk by this year's TED Prize winner. The TEDTalk by the winner is accompanied by an original blog post, along with new op-eds, thoughts and responses from the HuffPost and TED communities. Watch the talk above, read the blog post and tell us your thoughts below. Become part of the conversation!

The Sole Of A Student

From Plato to Aurobindo, from Vygotsky to Montessori, centuries of educational thinking have vigorously debated a central pedagogical question: How do we spark creativity, curiosity, and wonder in children? But those who philosophized pre-Google were prevented from wondering just how the Internet might influence the contemporary answer to this age-old question. Today, we can and must; a generation that has not known a world without vast global and online connectivity demands it of us.

But first, a bit of history: to keep the world's military-industrial machine running at the zenith of the British Empire, Victorians assembled an education system to mass-produce workers with identical skills. Plucked from the classroom and plugged instantly into the system, citizens were churned through an educational factory engineered for maximum productivity.

Like most things designed by the Victorians, it was a robust system. It worked. Schools, in a sense, manufactured generations of workers for an industrial age.

But what got us here, won't get us there. Schools today are the product of an expired age; standardized curricula, outdated pedagogy, and cookie cutter assessments are relics of an earlier time. Schools still operate as if all knowledge is contained in books, and as if the salient points in books must be stored in each human brain -- to be used when needed. The political and financial powers controlling schools decide what these salient points are. Schools ensure their storage and retrieval. Students are rewarded for memorization, not imagination or resourcefulness.

We need a pedagogy free from fear and focused on the magic of children's innate quest for information and understanding. -- Sugata Mitra

Today we're seeing institutions -- banking, the stock exchange, entertainment, newspapers, even health care -- capture and share knowledge through strings of zeros and ones inside the evolving Internet... "the cloud." While some fields are already far advanced in understanding how the Internet age is transforming their structure and substance, we're just beginning to understand the breadth and depth of its implications on the future of education.

Unlocking the power of new technologies for self-guided education is one of the 21st century superhighways that need to be paved. Profound changes to how children access vast information is yielding new forms of peer-to-peer and individual-guided learning. The cloud is already omnipresent and indestructible, democratizing and ever changing; now we need to use it to spark the imaginations and build the mental muscles of children worldwide.

This journey, for me, began back in 1999, when I conducted an experiment called the "hole in the wall." By installing Internet-equipped computers in poor Indian villages and then watching how children interacted with them, unmediated, I first glimpsed the power of the cloud. Groups of street children learned to use computers and the Internet by themselves, with little or no knowledge of English and never having seen a computer before. Then they started instinctually teaching one another. In the next five years, through many experiments, I learned just how powerful adults can be when they give small groups of children the tools and the agency to guide their own learning and then get out of the way.

It's not just poor kids that can benefit from access to the Internet and the space and time to wonder and wander. Today, teachers around the world are using what I call "SOLEs," "self organized learning environments," where children group around Internet-equipped computers to discuss big questions. The teacher merges into the background and observe as learning happens.

I once asked a group of 10-year-olds in the little town of Villa Mercedes in Argentina: Why do we have five fingers and toes on each limb? What's so special about five? Their answer may surprise you.

The children arrived at their answer by investigating both theology and evolution, discovering the five bones holding the web on the first amphibians' fins, and studying geometry. Their investigation resulted in this final answer: The strongest web that can be stretched the widest must have five supports.

Today, I launch my SOLE toolkit -- designed to empower teacher and parents to create their own spaces for sparking children's curiosity and agency. My team and I are excited to see more educators trying this future-oriented pedagogical tool on for size and then sharing their learnings are insights so we can all benefit from the hive mind.

Meanwhile, with my newly bestowed TED Prize, my team and I will build The School in the Cloud, a learning lab in India where children can embark on intellectual adventures by engaging and connecting with information and mentoring online. Technology, architecture, creative, and educational partners will help us design and build it. Kids will help us explore a range of cloud-based, scalable approaches to self-directed learning. A global network of educators and retired teachers will support and engage the children through the web.

We need a curriculum of big questions, examinations where children can talk, share and use the Internet, and new, peer assessment systems. We need children from a range of economic and geographic backgrounds and an army of visionary educators. We need a pedagogy free from fear and focused on the magic of children's innate quest for information and understanding.

In the networked age, we need schools, not structured like factories, but like clouds. Join us up there.

Watch Sugata Mitra's interview with HuffPost Live here.

TED and The Huffington Post invite you to take the SOLE Challenge, a unique contest in which we're asking teachers and parents to create child-centered learning labs in their homes and schools. Write an 800 to 1,000 word blog post on your experiences and send it to tedweekends@huffingtonpost.com. Three winning submissions will get to attend TED Youth 2013.

Ideas are not set in stone. When exposed to thoughtful people, they morph and adapt into their most potent form. TEDWeekends will highlight some of today's most intriguing ideas and allow them to develop in real time through your voice! Tweet #TEDWeekends to share your perspective or email tedweekends@huffingtonpost.com to learn about future weekend's ideas to contribute as a writer.

This story appears in Issue 39 of our weekly iPad magazine, Huffington, in the iTunes App store, available Friday, March 8.

 
Winner Of the TED Prize 2013 In a special edition of TEDWeekends, TED and The Huffington Post are partnering to co-premiere a talk by this year's TED Prize winner. The TEDTalk by the winner is acco...
Winner Of the TED Prize 2013 In a special edition of TEDWeekends, TED and The Huffington Post are partnering to co-premiere a talk by this year's TED Prize winner. The TEDTalk by the winner is acco...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,253
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (33 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chris Hussein Finnie
03:40 PM on 04/09/2013
The best thing I learned in school was how to learn. Components of this for me included how to find information, read it, and evaluate it. Other people may have had different ways to learn. One of my ex-husbands, for example, is badly dyslexic. But that man can remember just about anything he hears.

However a person learns best, I've found my own learning skills have been useful throughout my life--even when other, more specific information I learned was not.

For example, my grasp of the multiplication table was always shaky. Still is. But I've managed to survive for 63 years and to manage more than a few businesses without knowing them all. I'm sure that wouldn't be true if I'd wanted to be an engineer. But, clearly that wasn't where my talents were. I think it was important that I learned the concept of multiplication--that I was exposed to it, even if I wasn't any good at it. And I'm glad my school wasn't judged on my math proficiency.

Not all students are good at all subjects. But I think that, with the flexibility to accommodate different strengths and learning styles, anybody can learn how to learn.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fredhstclr
06:59 PM on 04/08/2013
Sure do, Need to raise the education level in our unemployment lines
02:31 PM on 04/08/2013
There is nothing new in this concept - except the point of genesis for the children gathering. Whenever children find something interesting and are usually five years or older, they will invite someone else to take a look. When they are younger, they invite their important other (their primary care provider). While a computer linked to the knowledge banks and taxonomies of knowledge of the Internet are vast, these resources are largely useless to children who are not yet reading. To support and extend "shared learning" from earliest years/Pre-School Years is far more powerful than waiting until children are 9-12. Supporting even the youngest child in the process of questioning, exploring and seeking/imagining answers is the first step, This is followed by using the internet as a tool and then as a machine for making tools second. This three-step process is the most valuable in empowering any human in the internet/WWW/interweb era. Also, adults are not needed to pose questions - once again this means an outside authority introduces a cultural imperative creating the reality of indoctrination. Adults need to guide, but not direct once children are 6 or so and can manage their emotions and have a sense of empathy.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
omegapoint
Why don't you just make 10 the loudest number?
01:26 PM on 04/05/2013
In the NFL theres no alternative for some coach or coaches losing and getting fired at years end. Thats the primitive outdated organization we have for our citizenry. Grading on a curve musical chairs is no way to run a People. The resources have been siphoned to the top as a result of it. On a Global basis it gets even more absurd, gold plated bathroom fixtures while children starve. If it were a lifeboat and in a sense it is there would be multitudes of people left in the sinking ship. And the winnners insist that we live in a Meritocracy. Teach your children to Network, its more important than education.
10:27 PM on 03/31/2013
Sorry. Elementary schools need to be givers of information. When one gets to high school it is plenty of time for individual study and exploration. Children younger than say, 15 need the CONTENT that is taught so that society can stay together by there being having a basic knowledge that all have. E.D.Hirsch wrote a fantastic book in the '90s called Cultural Literacy that is still pertinent today. As a teacher, I have had kids in my 6,7,8th grade classes who have come from "exploratory" backgrounds. Some do just fine having gathered a lot of background info...but these are the extra-ordinarily motivated students. The "average" kid just tries to drift through and comes out even LESS educated that the kid in the "factory schools" which is so abhorred by the author.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
laner717
The Buck stops here
02:58 PM on 03/30/2013
No, we need schools and factories, fewer tanks.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:47 PM on 03/25/2013
Sadly, in America, schools are no longer places to educate, to teach kids how to think critically, to inspire a thirst for knowledge. They have become holding cells that offer, not education, but indoctrination. American schools sold out their integrity to the unions and the feel good politics of the Left a long time ago.

Despite our high minded cries that teachers should be paid more, I feel that, based on the abysmal results they produce, that they are egregiously OVERPAID.

When schools -- and teachers -- get back to doing the job they are paid to do, THEN we can talk abut how valuable our "educators" are. Until then, all I see is climbing drop out rates and "graduates" who can't put a cogent sentence together.
10:30 PM on 03/31/2013
I agree. See my post above. Charter schools and or vouchers are going to be only thing to save American education. THAT's where we will see ingenuity (and competition )
10:08 AM on 03/24/2013
To be most kind....this is utter crap. It is so full of historical misreadings, logical errors and fallacious arguments. What Mitra says about health and banking industries is so risible, so utterly wrong that the rest of his wind and straw arguments collapse. The wired-in Banking industry is ethically and often financially bankrupt. The wired-in Health Industry has become a cookie-cutter, wasteful, thoughtless system. Only anecdotal, like his entire argument, but my former MD was a laptop-hybrid; she did not look up or pay attention, and prescribed bad medicines -- 'having it all electronic' somehow cut off her capacity to "remember" and think. People learn to think by engaging individually with challenging people who have learned to think. The cloud can only fill our tabula rasa with mere and often cloudy information. Self-directed learning? Empty rhetoric.

It is so sadly typical for an industrially-produced Pseudo-intellectual like Mitra gratuitously to cite great thinkers and then, shilling for the high tech industry, exhibit utter ignorance of thinking. Some of the 'problems' he cites in US education are caused by politicians interfering in education and the rich not wanting to pay for education. Many studies show that taking personal Technology AWAY from American students and having well-educated teachers FREE of political influence improves both students' basic yes/no knowledge and their independent and critical thinking skills.
09:06 AM on 03/23/2013
Check this out

At Sudbury Valley School, students from preschool through high school age explore the world freely, at their own pace and in their own unique ways. They learn to think for themselves, and learn to use Information Age tools to unearth the knowledge they need from multiple sources. They develop the ability to make clear logical arguments, and deal with complex ethical issues. Through self-initiated activities, they pick up the basics; as they direct their lives, they take responsibility for outcomes, set priorities, allocate resources, and work with others in a vibrant community.

Trust and respect are the keys to the school’s success. Students enjoy total intellectual freedom, and unfettered interaction with other students and adults. Through being responsible for themselves and for the school’s operation, they gain the internal resources needed to lead effective lives.

Sudbury Valley School was founded in 1968.

More at http://www.sudval.org/
10:38 PM on 03/31/2013
Gag. This sounds like the Waldorf school in England. And what happens when a kid doesn't want to learn a particular body of knowledge that is an essential foundation for further learning?
04:44 PM on 03/22/2013
No, The kids need schools, which are Not run like factories, and state tests are not the be all and end all. The perfect school values creativity . It allows students to follow a passion through to its completion. It gives students the tools to find their own resources and answers for learning. And finally, the family and country values education............
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Debbie L Garrison
07:09 AM on 03/22/2013
with all due respects i find that we need BOTH...w/o an education one wouldntt be able to perform any job. those of us who have had an education need jobs to support our needs therefor YES WE NEED FACTORIES!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:34 PM on 03/18/2013
A School in a cloud this doesn't make sense to me for some reason. I m not understanding this guys reasoning.
02:05 PM on 03/18/2013
Schools today teach standardization, as if that is the only model to follow. We teach students to regurgitate lessons learned, and repeat back, what we learn. Those best at regurgitation, receive the best grades. If we wish to improve schools, to teach people how to think, we have to find ways to teach lessons using experience. A good education will teach how to get a good job. A good education will not teach how to create a job. Most of the job creators quit school. Bill Gates, Sam Walton, and many others who created great products, were bored with the process of school.They learned how to organize information but they did not learn how to develop new information. That is a different way of seeing the world, then, what is taught in schools. School teaches how to manage in the box. It does not teach how to think outside of the box. Nobody knows how to grade that!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
indiecratublican
I am what I am.
04:54 PM on 03/11/2013
I only agree with Mitra to a limited degree. We do need teachers to encourage our kids, and we do need collaboration, and technological integration in our schools. However, school buildings are very important. Teachers with high qualifications still need to be in place to provide discipline and correct children's understanding of those right/wrong or yes/know questions. Kids do need to know how to write well and do their multiplication tables in their head. Why? Because what happens when the power goes off or there is no broadband? Kids need to learn social skills and how to survive and be independent GOOD citizens- By that I mean, they need to be the type of citizens that would make their country a prosperous, intelligent, humanitarian one that practices the Golden Rule and knows how to defend itself as well as keep itself sustainable and rational. This can't happen if we isolate our kids from their peers and put the burden of learning on them alone. Two months to partially answer one question is TOO long in the scope of a short lifespan. There is an effective way to teach and learn, but it does involve keeping in place some "Victorian" principles.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
An0n0m0ou5
Tu Ne Cede Malis sed contra audentior ito
02:13 PM on 03/17/2013
I like the approach that Salman Khan is taking in conjunction with some school districts in California. Where the youtube tutorials are assigned as homework and then the teacher can focus on those children that had difficulty with the assigned material while the rest of the class either works individually or collaboratively.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
indiecratublican
I am what I am.
03:04 PM on 03/17/2013
Exactly!
02:56 PM on 03/18/2013
Get rid of the teachers and buy big screen tv's.
02:17 PM on 03/11/2013
Over the past 5 years Woogi Academy has been developing a software platform that integrates the philosophy and pedagogy of Sugata Mitra. They have integrated gaming methodology, peer networking and an immersive virtual community where motivation is untethered and personal learning pathways are realized. They have created "spaced rehearsal" permanent memory technology-see John Medina's Brain Rules.

The first 3 courses released are English for Newcomers, Music Theory and Cyber Safety. Connect doug@woogiacademy.com to explore collaborations with this first-to-market platform.