Read More: New-York-Times-Wine-Club, Tony Grenberg, Williams Sonoma, New York TImes Wine Club, Trust Your Tongue, Zagat, Wine Club, Doug Frost, Worldwide Wine Club, Food News
What's wrong with wine clubs? Nothing, if you want to buy your wine based on a generic branding exercise designed to move a lot of random juice to a moneyed class of not-very-discriminating consumers.
All the "Booze Crit Lit" resources measure the preferences and idiosyncrasies of a bunch of people who don't necessarily share your preferences and idiosyncrasies. Their palate is not your palate.