iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Tamika D. Mallory
 
GET UPDATES FROM Marvin Bing
 

Why 'Stop and Frisk' Must Be Stopped Immediately

Posted: 06/04/2012 11:50 am

We are in a crisis. Urban areas like New York City have reached a tipping point when hundreds of thousands of innocent people are stopped, interrogated, searched and humiliated by the NYPD for doing nothing more than walking to the subway, going to school or leaving work. The situation is so severe that for the first time I am co-writing my blog with someone who feels as strongly as I do about an injustice of epic proportions. In a city like ours -- regarded as the virtual epicenter of the world -- it is reprehensible that 87% of the over 685,000 people stopped by police in 2011 were Black or Latino, according to the latest figures. To us, that isn't coincidence; it's overt racism and profiling. As young people of color, we demand answers, and more importantly, we demand immediate reform.

This Father's Day, June 17th, National Action Network and the NAACP will be joined by activists, members of the clergy, unions, community leaders, students, professionals and more as we march down 5th Avenue in Manhattan to demand an end to 'stop & frisk.' We call on NY Police Commissioner Ray Kelly to denounce this policy and implement change without delay, for it is modern-day racial profiling that blatantly targets minority youth in this city. According to a WNYC analysis, one in five people stopped in 2011 was a teenager between the ages of 14 and 18; of these, 86% were Black or Latino. The data further shows that a young boy of color will almost certainly get stopped by the NYPD before he even graduates from high school.

Commissioner Kelly, Mayor Bloomberg and the NYPD attempt to convey the message that stopping and searching minority youth somehow thwarts crime -- nothing could be further from the truth. As the NYCLU recently highlighted, even the police department's own reports prove that the policy of 'stop & frisk' yields absolutely nothing a majority of the time. In 2011, out of the 685, 724 people stopped by police, 88% were innocent, and in 2012 so far, 89% of those stopped have been found to be completely innocent. If the stated goal of this blatantly racist policy is to 'deter crime,' hasn't the NYPD failed miserably and confirmed that continuing 'stop & frisk' is nothing but a waste of tax dollars and an insult to people of color?

It criminalizes our youth, creates further distrust between the community and police, and doesn't do a thing to keep us safer. It used to be that we feared driving while Black; well in New York and around the nation, we now fear simply walking down the street while Black or Latino.

The injustice of 'stop & frisk' policies and their effect on racial minorities isn't something that the two of us observe from a distance; it's a reality that we cope with on a very personal level.

As parents of young children who -- according to statistics -- are virtually guaranteed to be stopped by police -- we grapple with the idea of how to teach them that cops aren't the enemy. How will we explain to them that being profiled, searched and harassed on the basis of your skin color is somehow still accepted in 2012? Learning of travesties such as the shooting deaths of unarmed Black/Latino men like Amadou Diallo, Sean Bell, DJ Danroy Henry, Ramarley Graham and more, how do we begin to ease our children's fears?

As two young people who work for large national civil rights organizations, it's critical that we speak with one voice, in unity, on an issue that affects the communities and people we see everyday. The cries, fears and desperation of folks who are simply tired of the intimidation tactics of those sworn to serve and protect us. This is why we work in the cause of justice, and why we ask all of you -- especially the young people out here -- to join us on Father's Day. While we push daily to invoke hope, education, success, positive thinking and civic participation, practices like 'stop & frisk' seek to undermine us at every turn.

The day after the horrific NYPD killing of Sean Bell, an unarmed 23-year-old Black man shot 50+ times the night before his wedding, Marvin was stopped himself. Walking home from a basketball game on 145th St., he was profiled because police claimed he looked 'suspicious,' though there was no suspicion of any sort of actual crime. The unfortunate reality is that any one of us, whether we're a straight A student at Columbia University, or a Wall Street banker, or a small business entrepreneur, or a multi-million dollar rapper/athlete, or a nurse working three shifts, or an attorney leaving court, you may be considered a criminal in New York City by Mayor Bloomberg and Commissioner Kelly simply because you are a darker hue than others.

The elders of the civil rights movement taught us countless lessons, not the least of which is to use the power of our voices to raise awareness on social justice issues and strive to bring about change. As young people in this city who are directly targeted and impacted by 'stop & frisk,' it is our duty to take to the streets on Father's Day and call for an end to this outrageous police tactic. The bottom line is, whether you're on 125th St. or Wall St., you need to stand with us because you are in fact a target, period.

All too often, we think these sorts of issues won't impact us -- until it's too late. Why is it that so many of us are unfairly searched, found to be law-abiding citizens, and yet our information is kept on file for 'future use'? Why do so many of us walk around in fear when we pass police? And why do the officers who patrol our neighborhoods not reside in our communities? If they do not know us, then they cannot distinguish between real trouble and what they perceive to be trouble.

No one is against the NYPD or the idea of stopping crime. But what we are emphatically against is biased practices that judge, profile, harass and criminalize based on ingrained prejudice. If we truly wish to decrease crime and improve relations with the police, we must demand an end to 'stop & frisk.' Every young person should join us -- along with his/her parents, grandparents, elder siblings, whomever, because the entire community is under siege.

Join us on the 17th to march down 5th Ave., and remember to work daily to combat injustice by contacting your local representatives/police departments to push for change at once.

As the city designed to lead by example, NY is sending a terrible message to the rest of the nation (and the world for that matter) by openly profiling Blacks and Latinos. We should be ashamed.

Tamika D. Mallory, National Executive Director of National Action Network

Marvin Bing, Northeast Regional Director for the National NAACP

 
FOLLOW BLACK VOICES
We are in a crisis. Urban areas like New York City have reached a tipping point when hundreds of thousands of innocent people are stopped, interrogated, searched and humiliated by the NYPD for doing ...
We are in a crisis. Urban areas like New York City have reached a tipping point when hundreds of thousands of innocent people are stopped, interrogated, searched and humiliated by the NYPD for doing ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 176
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
libluv235
"conventionality is not morality"-Bronte
12:56 PM on 06/16/2012
Boycott NYC! The National Medical Association should not hold conferences in NYC until this garbage ends.
02:51 PM on 06/12/2012
If you dont do your job as parents someone has to
11:23 PM on 06/11/2012
We are not going to stop these illegal police stops until we stop cooperating by calling them by non-legal terms like "racial profiling" and "stop and frisk." Most citizens don't have a clear idea of these terms because none exists.

The proper legal term we should use is "general warrant." These stops and others like them around the nation are DeFacto general warrants. They are "DeFacto" because they exist in fact, even though there is no legal basis for them to exist. General warrants have been used for a 1,000 years to punish, intimidate, harrass and control a specific group by making membership in that particular group the offense, rather than a particular act individuals might commit. The nazis issued a (legal) general warrant against jews in Germany. For years, the British army and protestant police forces had a de facto general warrant against catholics in Northern Ireland. Under these warrants, it was a crime to be jewish in Nazi Germany or catholic in Northern Ireland.

The difference between New York City and those other places is one of degree , not of kind. Black and Hispanic males are stopped, not for a crime they're committing, but because they're black and/or Hispanic.

That is a general warrant.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:52 PM on 06/09/2012
The Brown Skin Side Effect: 4side.blogspot.com
01:48 AM on 06/07/2012
I do not feel sorry for NYC. It is only going to get worst. NYC supports and pass laws supporting sin. God will not bless that city. They are reaping what they sow. The innocent will suffer along with the bad. The WTC came down and just about took the whole city down. Wasn't that warning enough. NYC are you wondering why these things are happening? It is just the beginning of the end.
01:36 AM on 06/07/2012
Where is the NAACP??? Where is President Obama? Oh yeah sitting over there supporting sin.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
markspence
09:05 PM on 06/06/2012
"In 2011, out of the 685, 724 people stopped by police, 88% were innocent, and in 2012 so far, 89% of those stopped have been found to be completely innocent. "

Innocent? Are all these 685,000 of these people being placed on trial?
11:06 PM on 06/11/2012
They're innocent because the cops let them continue on their way,without arresting them, because they had no reason to stop them in the first place.

That's what makes this so awful - you're walking down the street, minding your own business - when suddenly you're approached by police officers, who ask you for ID, maybe to empty your pockets and run an ID check on you for possible outstanding warrants. They just randomly stopped YOU in the hopes of making an arrest so they can meet their monthly arrest quota and remain in good standing with their bosses.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cam2112
05:18 AM on 06/06/2012
I agree. nypd and the mayor are in fact violating the peoples civil rights.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hjo4
Don't make your problems mine
04:19 AM on 06/06/2012
Mayor Bloomberg admits stop-and-frisk policy hasn't lessened shootings

Mayor Bloomberg admitted Tuesday he’s concerned that the city’s controversial stop-and-frisk operation has not cut down on shootings.

ā€œIt’s worrisome,ā€ the mayor said, adding that Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly is ā€œworking on it.ā€

ā€œThere are still too many guns,ā€ he added. ā€œThis is not a panacea for everything.ā€

Still, he reiterated that he believes the city’s falling murder rate is rooted in the citizen stops, which have been criticized by civil libertarians and others as racially lopsided.

ā€œWhat is clear is that the number of murders have come down dramatically,ā€ Bloomberg said.

As the Daily News reported two weeks ago, shootings are up 6% this year, with a quarter of them in just five neighborhoods, while homicides are down 21%.

Read more: http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/mayor-bloomberg-admits-stop-and-frisk-policy-lessened-shootings-article-1.1090652#ixzz1x00uudn2

It would be interesting to know the unemployment rate in those communities.
mothergrace
If they knock you down, bite 'em on the ankle.
04:44 PM on 06/05/2012
Write letters. NYC is very dependent on a certain cosmopolitan image. Let them know that we, from every state see and vehemently disagree. Refuse to plan business events there. Refuse to visit as a tourist. Let them know this is how you feel.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
privategirl
01:57 PM on 06/05/2012
What else is new. They figure if they arrest minorities it would help feel the perceptiont that minorities are out of control. Which will then make it okay for cops to arrest them.

Our system is nothing more than systematic racism out of control.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
charleyvldm9
He thinks outside the box.
08:44 AM on 06/05/2012
Frisking a minority,one is more likely to find a weapon,drugs or an outstanding warrant,if you are innocent ,you simply go on your merry way with an apology,hey its police training.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
privategirl
01:58 PM on 06/05/2012
And you gain that viewpoint based on What?

Frisk a white person and you will find everthing you just said but he'll be protected by the law.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Donnerskinde
I used to be a people person,till people ruined it
05:43 PM on 06/05/2012
You need to have cause to search a person to do otherwise is in violation of the persons rights against illegal search and siezure. Searching people because you feel like it is and always should be a civil rights violation.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
maildarter
07:46 AM on 06/05/2012
NYC is becoming a police state. Funny, because it's a very liberal place. I guess safety at any cost is what its about.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bobolini
Really fast!
03:21 AM on 06/05/2012
The reason for the earliest prohibitions against marijuana was to bypass the prohibition of slavery! During the reconstruction black people, poorer than whites, could not afford alcohol, so they did like they did in Africa, they picked and smoked weed. Severe laws were passed for possession and or sale and the institution of slavery was reborn as "the chain gang".

The oldest most severe laws against pot are in the deep South. It is no accident that this was also the seat of the deepest racism and violence against black people.
10:33 AM on 06/05/2012
Okay, so the common sense solution is not to smoke weed. There you have it---problem solved... and solved for FREE!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Natives Mom
helping to keep you honest
11:54 AM on 06/05/2012
TRUTH!
photo
lightist
light as a photon, heavy as tungsten.
02:32 AM on 06/05/2012
Set up a national hotline data base, an app that is free. And this would be a hour by hour, zip code by zip code or town by town across America so we can all see the daily numbers on who has been "stopped and frisked."

We must cut this disease out of America by exposing it relentlessly. Names of officers or presincts. I want to see this every day because you know and I know that there are those who fully plan to make slaves of us slaves.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Natives Mom
helping to keep you honest
11:55 AM on 06/05/2012
Excellent idea!!! Whats done in the dark....