The Fifth Step Against Terror: Enlightenment

Most of us prefer friendship to war. But America hasn't always found peaceful alternatives to stop aggression. Since 9//11 we've taken four steps along the path to end terrorism, but haven't yet taken step 5 -- the one with perhaps the greatest potential to de-claw terrorism, and to do it peacefully.

So far we've tried:

Step #1 VIOLENCE: My first thought upon seeing the twin towers struck was, "Oh please, not a war!" But our leaders of the time reflexed to violent retribution. Stunned as we were to be hated and under attack, most Americans supported the move.

Step #2 DISCUSSION: Immediately we started talking. There were events rehash, biographies, expert opinions and predictions. And there were two kinds of talking aimed at producing peace: official explanations from Islamic leaders and interfaith dialogues on campuses and in public settings such as places of worship.

Step #3 INVESTMENT: Added to the on-going cost of buying peace between nations such as Egypt and Israel, we now need to pour out millions to rebuild economies, buildings and infrastructure in Afghanistan and Iraq .

Step #4 VIGILENCE: Annoying airport screening and increased surveillance have thwarted an impressive number of terrorist plots. Like cancer screening, dangerous cells have been detected, but have not been prevented from starting up.

Despite all the time and money spent on steps one through four, we have made little progress in stopping the forces feeding the terror machine. The problem, as I see it, is that we have been clipping the branches when we ought to rout the root.

There is one step left which could make a real difference, if we were reasonable enough to take it.

Step # 5 ENLIGHTEN: Surprising as it may seem, there is a largely overlooked obsession that drives militant Islam. The cornerstone in promoting radical Islam is the widespread Muslim belief that the Qur'an has never changed and the extreme reactions this false belief engenders. In believing that Allah has protected only the Qur'an from change, extremists find proof that their faith is the only true one, and believe it must be propagated over the entire globe by whatever means necessary, including violence.

As taught by both al-Zawahiri, Osama bin Laden's successor in al Qaeda and Muslim Brotherhood founder Hasan al-Banna, the terrorist must be obsessed with making the Qur'an uppermost. Hasan al-Banna, who is considered the father of modern extremism, references sura 9:40 of the Koran in his Letter of Jihad where he states:

"God ordained jihad for the Muslims... a means of implementing the supreme Message... The Muslim would go forth to fight, one concern within his soul - to strive to his utmost until 'God's Word is the most exalted'."

Just as the West has taken on its own founding documents, such as Homer and the Bible, it now needs to take on the origin and preservation of the Qur'an. Why? Not only for our own protection, but because it is impossible for the Muslim World to do this itself. Although many in their block might like to they just can't, in their law anything said which casts doubt or disfavor on Islam is an "enormity" -- a major sin.

So non-Muslims have to do it or it won't be done, and generation after generation will go on killing for a magnificent, but unfounded obsession. Accordingly, to promote peace the West must diligently make known the truth -- the flawed origin and poor preservation of the Qur'an.

How do we know the Qur'an has changed? Details are beyond the scope of this article, but in summary we know by three sound means: First, the early Islamic writings themselves (both Sunni and Shiite) which describe private collections, variant readings and the great Qur'an-burning of rival versions by the third caliph. Western scholars have researched and documented the changes as well as other evidence of textual development. Finally there are differences in currently existing Qur'ans.*

Good news: in the information age, millions of Muslims have access to information previously beyond their reach; but we still need more open dialogue and general awareness on this topic. The Topkapi Secret, works by scholars such as Ibn Warraq and Michael Cook, the internet, and open discussion can go a long way toward helping Muslims make this discovery: although there may be much in their book to respect, the Koran is not so perfect as to merit suicidal - or homicidal - zeal.

*For more more information, please visit: http://thetopkapisecret.com/

 

Comments

[DeWain]

10:21 PM on 09/29/2011

quote: "The cornerstone in promoting radical Islam is the widespread Muslim belief that the Qur'an has never changed and the extreme reactions this false belief engenders."

Ok, if you insist, it's the cornerstone, BUT, the keystone is the belief that the world is against Islam and it is up to serious Muslims to counter the threat and gain control. They believe that Allah really needs the help of mere humans to make it all better.

[Terry Kelhawk]

04:57 PM on 09/29/2011

Goutham -
You are right. An all-powerful God would be able to keep the Koran - indeed any of "his" books - from corruption. Since the Koran has undergone many well-documented changes (according to both Sunni and Shia' sources as well as Western academics), one must confront the inescapable options, either:
* God is not capable of preserving any of his messages
* God may have kept some book from corruption, but it is not the Koran
* God doesn't care about corruption
* There is no God, so it does not matter

[Goutham Vishy]

02:52 PM on 09/27/2011

"Step # 5 ENLIGHTEN: Surprising as it may seem, there is a largely overlooked obsession that drives militant Islam. The cornerstone in promoting radical Islam is the widespread Muslim belief that the Qur'an has never changed and the extreme reactions this false belief engenders. In believing that Allah has protected only the Qur'an from change, extremists find proof that their faith is the only true one, and believe it must be propagated over the entire globe by whatever means necessary, including violence."--
Why is it so difficult to believe this?? Since it is already known that God personally dictated the Koran to Muhammad through the angel Gabriel, why can he not keep it 'unaltered'??

[Inannawhimsey]

10:53 PM on 09/28/2011

Because all perception, all seeing, hearing, tasting, etc etc is an active process that involves taking whatever it is 'out there' and then changing it, editing it, adding to it, subtracting from it...so what is 'in our minds' is not what 'is' out there. Naive realism, the philosophical notion that what we see is what there is has been disproven a long while ago...but people in developed countries still can act as if Naive Realism is true. Take a look at English -- sunset. Sunrise. Those 2 words don't reflect what actually happens -- the sun does not actually set, the sun does not actually rise and so forth :3

[Goutham Vishy]

10:32 AM on 09/29/2011

With all respect, What are you trying to say??

[DeWain]

10:39 PM on 09/29/2011

Goutham Vishy
Step 5 doesnt sound right to me. What are your own answers to your two questions? Dictating THROUGH doesnt sound all that personal to me.