Scranton Catholics, Defying Bishop, Put Economy Before Religion.
**By Luis Andres Henao**
Last Saturday, Gerri Williams and Audrey Williams sat inside the food court at Steamtown mall escaping the rain that poured over the abandoned steam trains at the railroad yard in downtown Scranton, Pennsylvania. The Williams sisters -- who are in their fifties -- are Catholic but pro-choice and next week they will vote for Barack Obama over their Bishop's objections.
Just two Sundays ago, the homily in every Catholic church here moved from the parables of the Bible to a lesson in electoral politics. Bishop Joseph Martino, the top Roman Catholic Church official overseeing the diocese which includes Scranton and other cities in 11 counties in Northeastern Pennsylvania ordered all priests in the diocese to read a letter telling parishioners that voting for a pro-choice candidate would be like endorsing "homicide."
Greg Sparaney, 25, a finance manager for a car dealer
outside of Scranton took three pay cuts to keep
his job. He will be voting Obama.
"We're Roman Catholics but he was out of line," Gerri Williams said. "Nobody has the right to tell you who to vote for or about your body."
During this election cycle, Scranton, best known as "The Electric City" because it was the home of the first electrical streetcar, has turned into the new symbol of the blue-collar America. It represents a swing town in the state that has become the ultimate battleground for both presidential candidates. Its electorate is made up of 90 percent white voters of European descent, who are largely Catholic and who have tended to vote Democratic 2-to-1. The last Republican presidential candidate to win here was Ronald Reagan in 1984.
But the city's residents also lean to the conservative side on social issues, presenting a potential problem for the Democratic nominee.
And while many voters here will heed Bishop Martino's call during this election and will not vote for Obama based on his stance on abortion, others feel that the economy and financial crisis will be foremost in everyone's minds when they reach the ballots.
"People will vote pocketbook before social issues," Chris Doherty, the town's mayor said. "People are concerned about pension funds, they can't make their mortgage payments, and they can't put away money for their children's college fund. Seven months ago it was an issue between two individuals, now I think the economy has changed the election in Scranton."
Gerri Williams and Audrey Williams will vote for
Obama against their Bishop's objections.
In the early 20th century the coal industry brought Scranton one of the highest per capita incomes in the U.S., Doherty said. But with the arrival of the automobile, oil took over as the most important industry and people started moving out. The mass exodus affected the economy of a town that deteriorated over the years.
In the past decade, Scranton has seen a resurgence, Doherty says. The French multimillion dollar pharmaceutical Sanofi Pasteur, moved a subsidiary to the city five years ago creating about 150 jobs. After a $400 million investment, downtown has cleaned up and has given way to development. A new Radisson Hotel was built in the grounds of old tracks, 22 recreational parks have opened, and many other jobs have been filled by Scrantonians who lived in larger cities and are lured by cheaper price homes and its proximity to cities like New York and Philadelphia. The city has even turned hip as the home of the NBC show "The Office."
A poster in Scranton's Steamtown Mall of Dwight Schrute,
the fictional character of NBC's the office.
The show is set in Scranton.
But the per capita income of $16,000 is still below the national average and the unemployment rate of six percent is higher than the national average, according to the last Census.
Greg Sparaney, a 25-year-old finance manager for Northeast Auto Credit car dealer took three pay cuts to avoid being laid off from the company before he was demoted to a position as a service writer two months ago. He will be voting for Obama. "I took so many pay cuts that I lost my job so it does come down to the economy," Scraney said. " I think as far as values, Obama has more values that John McCain, because even though [McCain] was a POW he is not in touch with Joe the plumber. His wife makes million of dollars, he owns seven homes; he has no touch with the middle class whatsoever."
To Joe O'Brien, a Scranton lawyer and former secretary of the Democratic Party, Obama will win the county but not by the large margins predicted. "The biggest issue that will move Republicans to vote will be abortion," O'Brien said. "But you also see white protestant families that feel different than Catholics and are voting Democratic."
Two blocks from the mall walking through a street of boarded businesses is Whistles Sports Bar. At 3 p.m. on Saturday three men sat on stools drinking beer and watching college football highlights on TV.
One of them is Tony Poseno, owner of Phoenix Cuts and Bishop Martino's personal stylist. He said he respects the Bishop and called him one of the most intelligent men he has met but argued that Martino should have refrained from his comments based on a separation of church and state.
"About 80 percent in this town are Catholic but they're still voting for Obama," Poseno said. "The state is very conservative but everybody pays attention to politics and the issue here like anywhere else is a town that needs jobs. The economy is going to win it out. Just because we are Catholics doesn't mean we are going to stay with our church."
Loading comments…
Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to
BTW folks OBAMA/BIDEN took Lackawanna County by 62.2% !!!!
Scranton's been extremely hot in the political world. Truly.
First off, I'm a practicing Catholic in the Scranton Diocese, and I was there when the Bishops comments were made. Second, I'm no fan of the bishop, but he is my bishop (kinda like being a patriotic American, but no fan of George Bush, he's still my president). In fairness, I don't remember hearing a mention to vote for McCain or anyone else. It was definitely implied, but not voiced. There are just many things that most people don't seem to be taking into account Abortion did not start with Roe V Wade, and won't go away if it is repealed. Pro-life should involve more than not allowing abortions. People die from all sorts of things - Pro-life involves Healthcare, It involves decisions about war, it involves people having job opportunities and being able to support themselves and their families. It involves people having clean air to breath and clean water to drink, it involves bigotry that leads to hate crimes and fear among minorities.
Yes, I am a practicing Catholic and I feel I will be voting my conscience and my Faith when I vote for Obama tomorrow
I am also a practicing Catholic from the Scranton area, and I agree. Our pastor was not happy about having to read the letter the Bishop mandated. He was afraid that since the Bishop required the churches to print the letter and distribute it, it would endanger the parish's tax exempt status because it pretty much amounts to a campaign letter for McCain. The local priests all read the letter, but with disdain in their voices and made no effort to encourage people either way. I want abortion to end, but John McCain's not going to do it. The Republican party's not going to do it. So I'm voting Obama.
I am a catholic, and do not support abortion, nor do I support capital punishment.
I wonder if the bishop's views are the same as mine?
Was this ordered by the Pope? I don't think so.
I wonder if this bishop lived a life of poverty or did he live a reasonably comfortable life?
Religion and politics do not mix.
As far as this brother is concerned, this bishop's opinion are just words which could and should be disregarded. There are a lot of people in powerfull positions, who don't belong there. I believe this bishop is a perfect example of this being a fact.
Why doesn't he go to Africa and feed the starving children who die each day, if life is truly important to him? Why doesn't he at least ensure the citizens of his diocese don't die from malnutrition or other problems the poor are afflicted with? Someone should tell him, God works in mysterious ways.
Priest's, bishops etc. have no place in politics. Like me, he has the right to choose who he votes for, but not to try to influence others. We wonder why people are leaving this religion..
I will choose to vote for Obama for reasons he can't begin to fathom. Let him vote for McCain.
I wonder if he will go to heaven? I don't believe he will.
Scranton and Northeast Pa. - all of Pennsylvania - is struggling. And a lot of attention is paid to us and our problems every four years.
Religion and representatives of such, have no business telling people how to vote or involving themselves in politics. And we all know the Bishops in this country have a lot more messes to clean up of their own, and should busy themselves doing so, never mind telling parishioners worshipping on a Sunday morning who they should or shouldn't vote for. Nobody, including a Bishop's mouthpiece, can call me a murderer because i voted for a particular candidate.
Scranton and all of northeast pa. is hurting economically. It has been for years. We're still losing jobs, businesses don't invest here, our homes are worth much less than they were worth ten years ago. We can't afford to stay and we can't afford to sell because foreclosures glut the market, too.
Our kids leave as fast as they can right after college because there are no jobs to keep them here once they are educated. Businesses won't invest here if we don't have the educated workforce to make it worth it. At $16,000 per capita income, and a 6 percent plus unemployment rate - the city of scranton is still squeezing over 3 percent local employment tax out of what's left of the salaries of our working class. Scranton can become more than just a hyped-up t.v. sitcom. And it ain't the Bishop's call.
I am Roman Catholic and when I was growing up, my family went to church every Sunday, but I seldom go to church now but still deeply believe in Catholicism. Our church priests, in the hundreds of masses I've attended many years ago, sermoned about helping your fellow man in need and deeply believed in the golden rule, "do not do unto others what you do not want others do unto you." I can't recall a time when these kindly, intelligent priests injected politics to influence churchgoers on their voting practice.
Our priests deeply believed in the 5th Commandment, "Thou shalt not kill" but there was a sense of pragmatism in their approach in life as they encounter incest and rape in families in the small community. These priests were most concerned with what the future holds for the victims and how can these families move forward from a traumatic experience.
I think that religious organizations nowadays have become more stringently religious rather than emphathic. And it's sad to think that they use the power of the church to move their own personal agendas.
How about the babies dying in Iraq? I don't hear too many pulpits denouncing that.
Well that would have pissed me off enough to walk out of church (but I am a recovering catholic anyway)
people have to eat!
All religions need to stay out of all politics, no exceptions.
Google Bush Faith-Based Initiative and feel the cold chills ....
Politicians should stay out of religions. They turn to the churches for votes! I am still appalled that pastors appear with them politically .......One using the other.
So much for he separation of Church and State. By the way, I guess any of the parishes that make this endorsement will lose their tax-free status right????
As soon as a church tells its parishoners who to vote for, they lose their tax exempt status.
Yeah, and the likelihood of seeing that actually be enforced against the Catholic Church: 0.00%
Get real. ;-)
I agree with imfedup. Any church should have the right to state, we are pro-whatever. But to direct every priest to read a statement that voting for someone is akin to murder - that's endorsing the other candidates in a slightly oblique way and they should have their tax-exempt status taken away.
Bombing Iraqui civilians is akin to murder, this bishop and his priests are pretty selective about who they're willing to kill.
These same people supported bush in 04 after seeing the slaughter in Iraq and said nothing about it. Hypocrites!!
One Love.
i am catholic and how wrong is it to vote for someone who is a pro-war (unjust) how can a catholic vote for some war-hound who will kill at the drop of a hat, all the hundreds of thousands that would be killed, and then meet them on the other side......
People are finally realising that being anti-abortion, supporting mandatory school prayer, and creationism don't really mean that much if you've lost your home and job.
You must be logged in to comment. Log in or connect with
