iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
The Harvard Crimson

GET UPDATES FROM The Harvard Crimson
 

Romney on the Charles: Anti-Intellectualism Should Have No Place in Politics

Posted: 04/16/2012 11:02 am

By The Crimson Staff

On April 5, Republican presidential hopeful Mitt Romney attributed President Barack Obama's alleged ineptitude to his having "spent too much time at Harvard, perhaps." If learning at this university has the potential to dull one's faculties, Romney must be speaking from experience. Not only has he earned more degrees than Barack Obama from Harvard, but, if he becomes president, he would be the most crimson commander in chief since Franklin Delano Roosevelt, class of 1902. Romney has not one, but two advanced degrees from this institution. He graduated from the joint J.D./M.B.A. program in 1975, and from there entered the business world. While President Obama spent three years here, Romney spent a total of four.

If Romney has indeed become aware of the deleterious effects of a Harvard education, it must have been a recent epiphany. Three of his sons attended Harvard for their MBAs, suggesting either that their presence on this campus was an act of rebellion against their reluctant father, or that Romney has only caught on to the crippling effects of a Harvard education in the past few years. Then again, even this scenario seems doubtful. After all, Romney counts economics Professor N. Gregory Mankiw and Kennedy School Fellow Meghan O'Sullivan among his top advisers.

Most likely, Romney's apparent change of heart toward his alma mater is an attempt to tap into anti-intellectual sentiment in order to rile the Republican base. Since he has a hard time impressing the far-right wing of the Republican Party with his pedigree, maybe Mr. Romney thinks he can fool them into only scrutinizing his opponent's. But seriously, he'd have more luck trying to convince them that he's always been "severely conservative."

Although Romney's recent conversion to anti-intellectualism may seem humorous, what it says about his candidacy is troubling. Although the Republican Party styles itself as the party of meritocracy, its appreciation for individual achievement seems to be rather limited. Academic and intellectual merit are regularly disparaged by Republican party leaders, even as they routinely exalt the value of hard work. Experience in academia -- a field in which so many conservative luminaries have served -- is mocked as not being "a real job." It is no wonder that there is a dearth of Republicans in our nation's top universities.

In the same breath that Republicans undermine the value of academic and intellectual accomplishment, they bristle when anyone speaks against the interest of those whose accomplishments have been financial. For example, any suggestion that those whose "real jobs" have brought them immense wealth ought to pay a more in taxes is decried as "punishing success."

It speaks to the power of the extreme right in today's Republican party that trash-talking academic achievement is de rigeur even for candidates who hail from Massachusetts, received two Harvard degrees, and are supposedly members of the Republican establishment. This is not simply anti-elitism, but anti-intellectualism. In an age when the nation's problems are increasingly complex, requiring the kind of expertise that a good education provides, we cannot afford to mock those who pursue one.

 
By The Crimson Staff On April 5, Republican presidential hopeful Mitt Romney attributed President Barack Obama's alleged ineptitude to his having "spent too much time at Harvard, perhaps." If learnin...
By The Crimson Staff On April 5, Republican presidential hopeful Mitt Romney attributed President Barack Obama's alleged ineptitude to his having "spent too much time at Harvard, perhaps." If learnin...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 21
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:41 AM on 04/18/2012
Harvard graduates have been single handily the most destructive people to the US.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:39 AM on 04/18/2012
Close Harvard down. Harvard graduates have single handily been the most destructive people to the United States.
09:14 AM on 04/17/2012
It is absurd for Romney to attack his alma mater when we know that the small corrupt clique that governs America comes predominantly from Harvard and Yale.
11:46 PM on 04/16/2012
Well at least Romney was there to learn something.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
methodman
10:27 PM on 04/16/2012
There is nothing convenient about the republican mentality or fantasy land. Convenience means before inserting pre-made anything something had to be thought about by someone but it sure wouldn't be me. Or if it is, it's by that well used cookie cutter. This party represents unoriginal fixation to a movable stump. That is their most Creative Idea. Forget about the living tree. If I love stumps I need to be voting republican. I agree. I hate seeing stumps so that eliminates me.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Stephen the Grate
There is grandeur in this view of life ...
05:28 PM on 04/16/2012
So Romney believes that making the rich pay the same taxes as working people is punishing them for their success? Apparently, someone who spends their days sitting around the pool sipping cocktails and waiting for their million dollar dividend check deserves to keep more of their money than people who actually work for a living! And you righties are buying this garbage?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
NielsH
my micro-bio is less empty than my cranium
04:07 PM on 04/16/2012
Mitt Romney is the first quantum-nominee, as such, he both attended Harvard for four years and didn't attend Harvard at all. In similar vein he holds all positions one can have about a singular issue at the same time.

As quantum-president, Mitt Romney when pressed to action, will randomly select one of his positions, though due to the uncertainty principle, we can never simultaneously know what his position will be and the speed with which his decision will be executed. The better we know one, the worse we will know the other. So Romney may unequivocally start a war against Iran, but may delay military action with a few decades, or he may quickly start a war, without having a well described position.

If elected, Mitt Romney will in 2016 base his campaign on the superposition of having both been president for four years and having been a regular citizen with a clean slate.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DailyAlice
Christian, liberal, mean as a snake
04:29 PM on 04/16/2012
This is brilliant. We can only hope that Schroedinger's cat scratches him up good.
11:59 PM on 04/22/2012
Can you please rephrase that using an allusion to Jersey Shore instead?
photo
judgeholden79
You, Never? Did the Kenosha Kid?
04:31 PM on 04/16/2012
Outstanding.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carl Caroli
I just don't understand people
03:19 PM on 04/16/2012
Amen. But it's not just mittens. It's the entire party. They are building a candidacy and platform on a foundation that is not connected and solid, but a disparate group of policies and attitudes that contradict one another, in order to appease their party leaders and corporate sponsors. Each of the hopefuls has ignored inconvenient facts to excite different demographic groups, disregarding the lack of unity and cohesiveness as convenient, hoping that no one notices. It's time to make people notice.
photo
HoustonWeHaveAProblem
It always seems impossible, until it's done.
01:16 PM on 04/16/2012
Of course the republican base identifies with anti-intellectualism. Knowledge leads to curiosity and change. Or is it the other way around. Educated people are so confusing.

However, even Romney has admitted he must broaden his appeal beyond the Fox viewership. Does he suppose that independents and conservative democrats will be persuaded by this argument? I'd venture to guess most have a four year degree.

Seems like yet another case of misidentifying his target audience, and as he's merely a creation of his campaign, he forgot both he and three of his sons are exactly the same as Obama, in this instance. So, not only does he ridicule himself and his family, he boldly invites the obvious conclusion, he's a complete phoney.

This is the best republican for POTUS? Good grief, the least articulate member of a high school debate team would rip him to pieces by merely parroting everything Mitt has said.
Dad24
The Right is Wrong
11:27 PM on 04/16/2012
He probably truly is the best they have. I can't think of a single Republican who can inspire moderates and independent voters because they have all adopted such extreme positions. There isn't a one among them who hasn't attacked unions, women, gays and lesbians, judges who disagree with them, intellectuals, education, etc.

I am hoping that, as they become more and more marginalized, they wake up and move back towards the center. While I have always voted for more Democrats than I have Republicans, I'd hate to see us lurch to an extreme left position, almost as much as I'd hate to see an extreme right government. 50 years ago, the majority of the House of Representatives fell between the most conservative Democrat and the most liberal Republican. Today, there isn't a single representative in what has become no-man's land.
photo
HoustonWeHaveAProblem
It always seems impossible, until it's done.
08:22 AM on 04/17/2012
I, too, remember when bipartisan cooperation moved the AMERICAN agenda forward and the constant score-keeping didn't exist.

A centrist path would insure the country's needs were met and the citizens of this country were served in a professional manner, but it's all about ideology and winner-take-all now. History is clear about what happens when egos supersede practical accomplishments. It's not a happy ending.
photo
SpinDizzy
This Space for Rent
12:47 PM on 04/16/2012
Sorry, folks, you just don't get it. Romney doesn't exist in the real world. He inhabits an alternate universe where his past isn't prologue, it's fog. He never supported gays or a woman's right to choose, he never created universal health care for the Commonwealth, he never said or did any of the things he said or did, and that includes going to Harvard. I'm surprised smart guys like you never noticed that.
photo
busterggi
I'm a Sally Randian
12:32 PM on 04/16/2012
Romney is such a fraud when it comes to anti-intellectualism that he makes me miss Dubya who was really anti-intellectual by mere virtue of breathing.
photo
matt gordon
One nation, under Canada and over Mexico...
11:21 AM on 04/16/2012
Romney criticizes his own alma mater to score a fraction of a point with the "true believers,", a/k/a the Fox Noise low-information folks.

Ve Ri Tas.
12:28 PM on 04/16/2012
O'Reilly has a Harvard degree
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carl Caroli
I just don't understand people
03:23 PM on 04/16/2012
There are two parts to the republican party. The users and the used. The users are well educated, and especially effective at manipulating the ones that are not.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DailyAlice
Christian, liberal, mean as a snake
04:31 PM on 04/16/2012
Then what was that "sun goes up, sun comes down" tapioca? Oh, yeah, I forgot the living-a-lie thing for just a minute...