More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Thomas Alter

Thomas Alter

GET UPDATES FROM Thomas Alter

Why The Heat Won't Win

Posted: 07/28/10 10:30 AM ET

Three weeks later, it's still hard to believe what Pat Riley pulled off. This summer has been straight out of a NBA2K franchise. Get rid of everybody, convince three of the most talented guys in the Eastern Conference to team up together for less than market value. The title of this piece is a bit misleading. The Heat will win often this year, maybe upwards of 65 games. They won't win a title though.

The NBA playoffs are a different beast. The MLB postseason is about who gets hot at the right time. In the NFL, it usually comes down to strategic maneuvers from the coaches. Neither of these things really matter in basketball. What matters in June, is leadership.

When I say leadership, I don't mean the rah-rah Hoosiers pre-game speech. It's the opposite really. Every championship team MUST have a tenacious, bulldog. In laymans terms, a motherf*cker. Of course this guy hates to lose, but more importantly, he'll get on his team if they're not cutting it. He doesn't have to be the most talented but certainly the most respected/feared. Look back to the 90's. Every championship team has had one of these guys. I'll refresh your memory.

09/10 Lakers - Kobe Bryant: He'll ream out his teammates when they make mistakes, but they have the utmost confidence in him in late game situations. Kobe is the ultimate closer in the NBA today.

08 Celtics - Kevin Garnett: The king of talking trash has made multiple teammates cry with his criticism. Yet he's anchored the Celtics D for the past three years and turned them into champions.

99/03/05/07 Spurs - Gregg Poppovich: He's not a player and he's not nice, but "Coach Pop" has earned respect throughout the league. He has arguably the top power forward in NBA history in Tim Duncan, yet there's never been a question who the leader of the Spurs is.

06 Heat - Shaquille O'Neal: First off, this was the weakest final of the past 25 years. Miami or Dallas wouldn't have made the semifinals of last year's playoff with their rosters. Still, "Big Diesel" played a vital role in getting South Beach a champion. Dwayne Wade was the most talented but Shaq led the Heat into battle.

04 Pistons - Rasheed Wallace: The king of technical fouls scared the crap out of teammates, opponents and referees alike. This was a deep and talented Piston team who shocked the Lakers, but it's no surprise that a midseason trade for the supposed malcontent Wallace, put them over the hump.

00/01/02 Lakers - Shaq and Kobe: Are you sensing a pattern here? These two may have hated each other, but their burning desire to win trumped this animosity, leading to three championships. Both feared that the other would be considered the team's best player, leading to feisty practices and eventually ring-fitting ceremonies.

90's Bulls - Michael Jordan: The ultimate alpha male. Jordan was adored by the fans and isolated from his teammates. Revered and feared by everybody around the league. No matter the talent Jordan had around him, there was no question as to whose team it was. If another Bull messed up, they were getting embarrassed publicly by MJ. Call it cruel if you'd like, but no one can argue with the results.

So this brings us to the Heat. When you break down their roster, they have two superstars (Wade and LeBron), one very good forward (Bosh), and a bunch of yes men. When I say yes men, that doesn't mean the supporting cast isn't talented. They will however, always defer to James and Wade. Mike Miller, Udonis Haslem, Zydrunas Illgauskas are playing in Miami because Wade and LeBron asked them too. It seems the entire Heat roster are just best friends who were just really love each other's company.

While this cohesiveness should make for an enjoyable team Thanksgiving meal, it won't lead to success in June. Undoubtedly they will face some playoff adversity and what then? Who takes over, LeBron or Wade? Who lights into the team for playing soft? The fact is you need at least one mean sonofabitch to win in the playoffs. Say what you want about the big three, none are particularly cantankerous.

The only way to inject some nastiness into this team is to get rid of another nice guy. Goodbye Erik Spolestra. Pat Riley is the ruthless assassin the Heat need to spice things up. Forget LeBron, Dwayne and Chris. When a guys with five rings sits on the bench, he's in charge.

I can't tell you who will win the title. Maybe the Lakers, or possibly my dark horse, Portland. What I can tell you is, until the three amigos get some anger and toughness in them, the Larry O'Brien trophy won't rest in Miami.

 

Follow Thomas Alter on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Talt1

 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
planetmondo
Christian, Musician, Scientist, Citizen
01:08 AM on 09/09/2010
Lakers are the greatest team in the NBA they are the champs and W/ Kobe, Pau, Ron Ron Fish Odom and Andrew they are in a great position to three-peat especially with Phil Jackson the greatest coach in NBA history who has transformed working with head cases ( M J, Pippen, Rodman,Kobe,Shaq,Odom, Ron Artest) into a zen-like artform. That said NEVER count out a team with the MDE at center Shaq has always made those who play alongside him better. I hate the Celts but give the devil his due along with Rondo,Pierce,K.G.and Ray Allen and a very good and classy coach Doc Rivers they are the team in the east to contend with.As for the three *ahem* EGOS in Miami -not so much.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Doctor Nick
Hi, everybody!
11:08 PM on 08/01/2010
You don't think all the hate is going to motivate the big-3 this year? I think you're going to see angry LeBron come playoff time, and Bosh who has lacked motivation in Toronto will take it up a notch too.
I don't know that you really need to have one guy come crunch time - I seem to recall Fisher, Artest, and Pau all making big buckets for Lakers in crunch time this time around. Wade will probably have the ball in his hands at the beginning of the possession but it might also depend on the match-up. "Who takes the last shot" is overrated anyway - the question is who puts in the game-winning offensive putback? The truth is that statistically James and Wade are both as clutch as Kobe. Kobe put up a stinker in game 7 this year and was fortunate to have great rebounding team-mates.

As long as Wade and LeBron are really friends and click on the court this team has got to be a favorite to make it to the finals with LA, from there it's a toss-up (or rather, too early to tell).
01:35 PM on 07/30/2010
I think this article would make sense if Lebron wanted to compete with Wade instead of complement. Wade is the leader. He's the best 2-guard (Kobe is old, pump fakes a lot more, relies on his still excellent jump shot instead of speed) in the game, and also the best competitor. Watching him single-handedly defeat teams last season, including the one win against Boston, shows you the man is fearless, and dogs his teammates. Lebron is the student, Wade the master. Lebron is going to play a special brand of point-forward when going big, commanding the entry passes then moving inward to gain post positions and rebound opps. He'll play the 4 when going small, with Wade becoming super-swingman and miller complementing them both at the 3 and 2 respectively. Lebron could very well triple-double in this system while Wade being the scoring machine. Neither of these two teammates has never not been double-teamed, and doing so against either will open up the floor for one of them, which is dangerous. Playing zone means giving room to Miller and Wade (and now, House), which is just bad. People think Lebron is not a team player. This is false. The man is TOO giving. He's just not a Cavaliers team player. Every championship team has one killer and one workhorse (kobe/shaq, wade/shaq, MJ/pippen, PP/KG), and lebron is a workhorse. wade will murder you. watch for it.
12:49 PM on 07/30/2010
Lol the reason lebron left cleveland is because he needed a team he could play for that if he had a bad game he knew they still had a chance to win. You need big time talent to win against teams like boston or orlando. You have to have enough guns to match up with these teams in a seven game series. Obviously the cavs didnt have that and it showed down the stretch. Anyone looking to beat the lakers, which is the most stacked team in the league cant do it with one star. Anyone could win the championship this coming season. The lakers are the favorites but there will be plenty of teams pushing back. Would love to see a big three in NY.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Seafarer61
Chillin' with the corpsemen from all 57 states
05:58 AM on 07/29/2010
Pure speculation. Nobody knows what's going to happen and that is the magic behind the move. You're wrong about Wade though. He wants to win about as much as anyone in the league and definitely has the attitude required of a winner. You're wrong about who led Miami to that championship...it was Wade who carried O'Neal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
planetmondo
Christian, Musician, Scientist, Citizen
01:11 AM on 09/09/2010
Shaq took them to the playoffs Wade was brilliant from there.It was both plus Riley
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:52 PM on 07/28/2010
Portland as a darkhorse? Really? Miami is at best a darkhorse right now. Without having played a single game, some are annointing them as the champs. The Lakers have little to no opposition in the west, while Miami will be fortunate to come out of the East. Boston or Orlando are both superior teams right now - without a doubt. That type of super concentrated talent in the absence of good role players does not, has not, and likely will not work. Sure, the Lakers have Mamba and Gasol, but look at their roster, all the way down to the 12 man! Moreover, the Lakers are now easily the best defensive team in the NBA by a mile. Not even close.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:19 PM on 07/28/2010
Haslem and Miller will be more than adequate role palyers at the 3 and 5. This Cektuc fanatic for the past 48 years is telling you straight that Boston is done,,,Garnett got dominated by Gasol and is well past his prime. he waq going for rebounds he didnt get ( a wjhole lot)in the playoff almost delicately with one hand and his versatile offensive arsenal of 10 years ago is shrunken., Increasoingly one-dimensional Allen shot HORRIBLY in the last 5 games vs LA and Pierce- always 1/2 step slow -is now 1 and a half steps slow. Rondo is great but still untamed and at center they get zero offense from Perkins who is basiclaly a limited, glorifed banger. orlabndo simply lacks premier overall talent despite some fine individual performances this season band a good record. Under Pat Riley's discerning eye,Miami will gel eventually and whether they are 65-17 going into the playoffs or 54-28, they will be Beasts having played a full season together.
08:54 PM on 07/28/2010
I agree, Miami will more than likely be playing a tough team in round 2 (Boston, Chiago or Orlando) while the Lakers will probably play a weaker team in round 2. The Lakers could only play 10 or 11 games in the Conf. Semis and Finals while Miami may need 13 or 14. Plus the Lakers have more depth. If you rank the top 10 from both teams (one of the best ways to get a peak at depth, you can't always look at stars)
1-Kobe-LA
2-Lebron-Mia
3-Wade-Mia
4-Gasol-LA
5-Bynum-LA (if healty if not switch with Bosh)
6-Bosh-Miami
7-Artest-LA
8-Odom-LA
9-Haslem-Miami
10-Blake/Miller (both are even Miller scores a little more, Blake is a better assist man)

The Lakers have 5 of the top 8 and 3 of the top 5.

With the East, Miami can't forget Paul still may get traded (looking less likely) and Orlando is top on his list, and Melo wants out of Denver and they made trade him in order to get something and he would like to go to NY. So Melo and Amare make them a better team.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:47 AM on 07/29/2010
Bynum, with vast potential, seems fragile. His potential is still there of course but it may never be reached due to injury proneness a la' antonio mcdyess. you can't undetrestimate the role of a top shelf shooter like mike miller- a brilliant pick-up for the Heat. With Miller roaming the perimeter, the offensive floor gets bigger and opens up space for wade and lebron off the dribble-drive and reduces the ;likelihood of double teams.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Murphdogg
This micro-bio is literally a nano-bio on steroids
05:47 PM on 07/28/2010
Not only do I think they will win the title, I think they will sweep everyone but the Lakers (4-1) setting the post season winning percentage mark.
photo
Mag7
Smarter than the Average Dog
08:15 PM on 07/28/2010
That's what they said about the Titanic.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ivatsol
12:08 AM on 07/29/2010
Meet me at the bar page drinks on me! Fanned!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:41 PM on 07/28/2010
seems a little premature to make that negative judgement about this latest version of "the Big 3". At its best, basketball is a team game dependent upon on-the-floor chemistry. And that is the unknown as wqe approach next season for Miami. the first effort to construct a "Big 3' was when LA.. imported Wilt forming a SUPPOSEDLY unbeatable force of him, west and baylor in 1969. Yet- Russell and Co. beat them in Russell's swan song and L.A. did not win a title until several years later when Baylor was gone. does the current Big 3 have the potential to gel QUICJKLY like Boston's did in '08? i think assuredly the addition of shooter-supreme mike miller is the beginning of that. Wade has enough"alpha" in him to ignite the chemsitry and James can now be more like Magic than having the pressure of being a "Jordanesque" one man show. This "big 3' IS certainly gonna be better than the Miami team that won it previously and with Boston rapidly aging in the East and Orlando really not title team caliber desite a very fine recent regular season, its hard not to think these 3 guys are going to cruise into the Finals----at least...
04:19 PM on 07/28/2010
I think Bostons big 3 is different, that Pierce and Garnett were always "team players" Garnett put up with a lot more in Minnesota than he should have same with Pierce, Allen, is happy as long as he gets shots, and with 2 great players like Pierce and Garnett those shots will come. In Miami, Bosh I think will be fine as long as he gets paid can party (he doesn't appear to care as much about winning) the key is can Lebron an Wade co-exist, it is easy ot do it during the olympics for a few weeks, or even for a season, but in years 2 or 3 or 4 especially if it takes a year or 2 to win. We will have to wait and see. Shaq and Kobe couldn't co-exist and they won 3 in a row, but as soon as they lost once things started going down hill fast. If they lose this year, 2011-12 will be interesting.
12:48 PM on 07/28/2010
This is a good article but I just have to say I think Wade will be the mean one. He seems to have the chip on his shoulder and will be the leader when they need to, he was all these years anyway.