More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Thomas P. Connelly, D.D.S.

GET UPDATES FROM Thomas P. Connelly, D.D.S.

Think Dentures Can Replace Your Teeth? Think Again.

Posted: 10/06/11 03:30 PM ET

I want to talk today about dentures, but probably not in the way you expect. I want to talk about dentures as opposed to your regular teeth, and how they are not nearly the same.

The reason I decided on this topic was because I hear -- quite often -- patients saying things like "oh, I wish you could just pull my teeth and give me dentures," or something similar. Usually the people saying this need extensive (and expensive) dental work, and they figure that dentures are an easy fix. After all, dentures seem like a no-brainer, right? No cavities, no root canals, no bridges, etc. No expense of going to the dentist every six months, no insurance worries when your dentist tells you that a root canal and crown are needed, etc.

Essentially, the people thinking the above are looking for a "tooth do-over." They want the reset button hit, and to start over again with teeth that do not need dental work. Well, I don't mean to disappoint, but as an NYC cosmetic dentist, I can tell you firsthand that it really doesn't work that way.

I know you hear this all the time, but I will reiterate it -- there is no perfect substitute for your natural teeth. Bridges and implants come the closest (by a wide margin, really). But given a choice, a mouthful of healthy natural teeth is preferable to even implants. And your natural, healthy teeth are far (and I mean really far) superior to dentures. Dentures, in my opinion, should be seen as a last resort.

Let me tell you the biggest thing about natural teeth and your dentures. As a professional dentist, I can attest that for most adults, your bite force with your natural teeth is somewhere around 200-250 pounds of force. Some a little less, some a little more, but that's the sweet spot. With dentures, your bite force is about 50 pounds of force. That's a significant drop off. That's the difference between eating a steak, and eating oatmeal. Do you like oatmeal? For dinner?

The reason for this disparity is your natural teeth are set solidly in your jawbone. Rigid and strong, they handle chewing food with astonishing efficiency. Dentures, on the other hand, rest against your gums. They can be "fixed" all you want with gels and the like, but the fact is, it's not a strong base. There's just "nothing" behind your bite, so to say. Especially on your bottom teeth, where the denture is largely held in place by gravity and your mouth muscles.

Upper dentures can be fixed with a plate that uses suction on your upper palate to stay in place. Yes, I know, it doesn't sound all that strong. Trust me, it's not. More often than not, denture wearers report to me that their dentures end up "flopping around a lot" (I had a patient tell me exactly that a few days ago). Again, dentures are a last resort.

I've seen television commercials advertising adhesives that hold dentures in place, and they show deliriously happy people eating corn on the cob and the like. What they don't show is the 10 to 15 minutes it takes to eat that ear of corn. Yes, the adhesives work to a degree. But you still only bite with about one-fourth of the pressure you could have with real teeth. And that steak we mentioned earlier? Well, I hope you don't mind still eating it while everyone else is on dessert.

I mentioned the plate for upper dentures. I'd like to return to that for a second. If you've read my blog in the past, then you know there are taste buds on your upper palate (the roof of your mouth). Well, if you use upper dentures, these will get covered. That means your sense of taste is going to be markedly diminished. Add in the adhesive, and well, eating starts to lose its luster.

Okay, I've told you all the bad things about dentures. However, I would be remiss if I didn't state that for some people, there really is no other choice. Dentures are associated with older people, and in my mind, that's really the only people who should be using them. Today's longer lifespans sometimes mean that even the best cared for teeth can be lost. Dentures can be a life-enhancing asset in that case. But replacing a mouthful of healthy teeth with dentures? No way, no how.

Given the above, in my mind, the drawbacks of dentures are not worth avoiding root canals and the like. I realize dental work can be a pain (ha, a pun!) and can be expensive at times. However, that should not deter you. Many dentists have payment plans, they take credit cards, there is secondary insurance, etc. I'm not advocating getting into debt -- I am advocating that there are few things as important as your natural teeth. They are worth the investment.

Until next time, keep smiling (with your natural teeth!)

 

Follow Thomas P. Connelly, D.D.S. on Twitter: www.twitter.com/dr_connelly

 
 
  • Comments
  • 100
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
05:45 AM on 10/12/2011
Good article, AOL/HuffPo.

Thank you, Dr. Connelly!!!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
4me2knw
Oh what tangled webs we weave.
03:02 PM on 10/10/2011
In most states the law reads "only a licensed dentist can take an impression of the mouth". This is the law they use to stop the lab technician from becoming Denturists, who actually makes your denture but never sees you so doesn't know how to make them match you because the law makes you go through the dentist. Who is the one who sees you. Most dentists never even tell the lab if your a man or a woman, and we need much more info than that to make them match! Gender, age, personality type, skin tone, race, and some labs like the face shape. Dentists usually leave it blank. So you get a "nutered" denture. One that will work for man or woman and usually a nice younger looking smile, straight, white. Most people think they're ok because the denture always looks better than what they had. Then they charge you $2,000. per denture (going rate here). I see these dentures coming from a mile away!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:13 PM on 10/10/2011
Teeth people, listen up! This is right down my alley. You name it, it's been DONE to my mouth. Gums were bad from the time I was first pregnant. Have had silver flllings, gold fillings, partical bridges, fixes bridges. Stainless steel across the top of my mouth anchoring teeth, then caps three times because they kept cracking. Lost lower teeth due to shingles in my mouth. Got conned into implants which were not a small fortune but a HUGE fortune. The denturist never did get the implants to "snap" correctly and had to be re-ringed constantly. Finally two posts fell out. Had cadaver bone in lower to stabalize implants. That didn't take. I opted for dentures and after thousands and thousands of dollars, believe me, a tiny bit of stick-um goo doesn't bother me one bit. Dentures, false teeth, choppers, whatever you call them.....get a GOOD denturist and you will have a good looking mouth and no one will know they are false. Yet, I eat corn on the cob!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
4me2knw
Oh what tangled webs we weave.
03:25 PM on 10/10/2011
Hum..sounds like the Dentist you saw was working for the Denturist. This is where it can get tricky. Who's responsible for what? (sorry you had to go that far. Had you of seen me, I would had your bone measured (simple x-ray) and if too much loss, I would have said get dentures now! The longer they leave the bad teeth, the more bone loss you have, making wearing dentures even more difficult.) The dentist set the implants into your bone, right? Then he set the posts or whatever he may have called them, different terms. The most likely reason they wouldn't snap in is because the DENTIST didn't set them paralell. That's on him. The Denturist is only responsible for the appliance itself. Everything from the posts up or down depending top or bottom. ;-) The Dentist's license supersedes the Denturist's license (more years of school and in depth training in all aspects, so the dentist has the final say and thus takes on more of the responsibility.) Contact your local board of "Dental Examiners" and tell them what happened to you. You might just get a lot of your money back and this practice may be investigated. Under the government pages in your phone book. If you get no satifaction then contact the American Dental Association. National, over sees the states. Again look in the government pages.
01:41 PM on 10/10/2011
As a retired dentist I can approach this subject with much appreciation for both sides of the contoversy. Dentistry is a very expensive service to deliver and therein is the reason for the high cost to the consumer. A typical 3 or 4 chair office wiill require at least $500K to set up, a staff that will consume 30 % of gross revenues, other overhead expenses of materials, utilities, maintainence of high tech equipment, space rent/lease, insurance, continuing education, and, hopefully, some left over to take home. Add to that the cost of the education. So of that $1,000 fee there will be $100 to $200 for the dentist to put in his /her pocket to take home to pay personal expenses and to buy a retirement program. Now a patient who wants a "discount" is likely to be dissappointed since that would mean the dentist would be working for zero or less. Dentistry is a high stress occupation requiring complex, precise, fast manipulations in a confined area, inflicting pain and trying to control patient reactions and an "unfriendly" environment. Expectaions of the patient are high, wanting longlasting results that look good, are quickly delivered with little pain and, "by the way Dr., please keep the cost down". For some of my services I was overpaid. Other times I was underpaid. There is no way to always be precisely fair every time.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
4me2knw
Oh what tangled webs we weave.
02:15 PM on 10/10/2011
Same old song and dance. High overhead.
01:23 PM on 10/10/2011
had upper dentures for about 4 months now, not use to them yet,
but their are times i dont even realize they are their.. eating is somewhat different..
food to me taste a little differrent, maybe not as flavorable..
i have read it takes about a year or long to really get use to dentures...
well got a few months to go..
so far they are just so so... no problems really in eating. steak, chicken, whatever.
one thing for sure, my looks imporve with the big old white smillies, instead of the
two front ones i were missing... ..
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lunnette
01:21 PM on 10/10/2011
you sprak of older people needing dentures and say some dentst have payment plans and accept credit cards, but what you don't say is that most people still can't afford treatment. older people tend to be in the lower income brackets and therefore have a harder time paying for the treatments. medicare which shoud help gives scant help for dentures , hearing aid or glasses. most older people need some or all of these at one time in their life.I have ss income of $1000 per month. a new set of dentures for me is a minimum of $2000 -two months of my ss. income .you try and live on this and then buy dentures or hearing aids.(need them too) and today they use plastic instead of porcelin for teeth. and that gives you about 3years worth of bite. then another $2000. I'm not asking for free I'm only saying help
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
4me2knw
Oh what tangled webs we weave.
02:29 PM on 10/10/2011
About porcelin teeth. What we have found is that the porcelin are so hard without any "give" they put a lot of force againt the bone and the bone shrinks away, causing more bone loss which means even less bone to fit a denture to. So, yes most providers have moved away from the porcelin. If you only get 3 years out of your teeth then your dentist used the cheapest teeth out there. Yes, there are high quality (more dense, vaccum fired) and then cheap quailty. Plastic can be sharpened. I used to do this for many of my patients giving them a couple more years. Dentists won't talk about this because then they don't get to sell you new ones.
01:17 PM on 10/10/2011
Yeah right-----Keep putting all that money in the dentists pocket. I have both an upper and a lower partial that I have had for years. My teeth are soft (genetic I think) so I had 17 fillings by the time I was 21 years old due to erosion and partials before I was 30. I just went in for a cleaning and 2 fillings----the bill $750.00. I have 1 tooth that the dentist has been saying for 5 years needs to have a root canal and a crown----cost about $3000.00-------been there done that and it will last about 2 years and then have to be pulled and the tooth added to my partial. I will just wait for it to go bad and have it pulled at the oral surgeons office which will be paid for by by medical insurance since it is considered surgery and then have a friend at the lab add the tooth to the partial-------cost less than $200.00. I eat anything I want and have never regretted having partials. Eventually I will have full dentures upper and lower and to tell you the truth I can't wait! I shudder to think about the thousands of dollars my parents spent on my teeth and the thousands I have spent on my teeth none of which will prevent the inevitable loss.
01:16 PM on 10/10/2011
I was born in appalacia in 1936, never had proper teeth hygene and developed gum disease. I had a lot of cavities and toothaches as a teenager and finally at age 21, my dentist told me that I needed to have my top teeth pulled and dentures. After the teeth were pulled, the bottom teeth cleared up and got strong. Since I had no other choice, I adapted. Two years ago, I had my bottom teeth whitened and got a new top denture to match. Now I have beautiful (white) teeth, and since my bottoms are real, and the top were made to look real I am well pleased. As far as taste I think that when you cover up the roof tastebuds, the tongue and other parts of you mouth compensate. I get a lot of compliments on my teeth, and it makes me "smile".Since the new dentures are "sharp" I can eat any thing and chew the toughest steak and have no trouble with corn on the cob and apples are no problem either. I made sure that my two sons had proper teeth care and they both have beautiful teeth.
01:06 PM on 10/10/2011
The dentist would be better served in joining together with his fellow practitioners to lobby DC until full dental care is passed as mandatory coverage with parity in charges with other medical issues. The federal government currently classifies dental care as optional coverage. A person's teeth are part of them and should not be considered optional or less serious toward a person's total health.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
4me2knw
Oh what tangled webs we weave.
02:38 PM on 10/10/2011
If a person can't chew up their food small enough then the stomach has to produce more acid to break it down and eventually most people end up with stomach problems, poor neutrition etc. The government doesn't recognize these medical problems because then they'd have to start paying for that too. They don't care about our oral health or digestive tracts, just the dollar. I agree the dentists would serve themselves to lobby for better coverage. They make enough money now, really so they probably won't. With dental insurance most will only cover $1,500. a YEAR! That hardly pays for one tooth these days. The insurance has been at this yearly level for about the past 20 years. They've never raised it.
12:56 PM on 10/10/2011
What this dentist says is a lot of bull! It could be true for some people, but those are the one's who have poorly fitting dentures in the first place. If your dentures fit properly they become a part of you, as I can attest to. I have had dentures for over 40 years and except for one time in which the dentures were poorly fitted they are a part of me and I even forget that I am wearing them. If you go to a very good dentist who will not stop untill your dentures fit properly and look natural, you will not have any problems. Just make sure you do your research just as you would and should do if you were looking for a plastic surgeon. I promise you can have great results just like me.
12:56 PM on 10/10/2011
I have read several of these blogs pertaining to Dentures and heres my 2 cents worth. I am a lab technician for the past 35 years and Dentures is what i do ! I tell everyone that i talk to about dentures that i can help mother nature but i cannot replace her. My best description of dentures is when you buy a pair of shoes and they fit great, you don't want to take them off but then another pair may hurt like hell, not fit properly and u just want to throw them away. that's the best i can define to anyone about wearing dentures. A lot of what Dr. Dentist stated is very true and a lot of what you bloggers stated is also true. It's very expensive to get dentures. Yes, the lab fabricates them and makes the patients look great but the doctors get most of the monies.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:53 PM on 10/10/2011
I also have found that many dentists will tell you that you need a filling, dental crown or root canal just to make money. This happens alot. I went to one dentist, got a second opinion with another and none of the dental work that the first dentist stated I needed was necessary. Also, the first dentist did unnecessary x-rays and said I had TMJ - I did not. It's all a scam.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
4me2knw
Oh what tangled webs we weave.
03:37 PM on 10/10/2011
When fighting to get Denturists licensed I was the patient "plant". I already knew what dental work I needed and went into several dentist office's, let them do the exam. Everyone of them said I needed something more than what I did. This one guy! He had me needing 3 or 4 root canals, a bridge, 5 other crowns, just out of line! We printed our results in the local paper. Exposed them for the coniving, greedy people most of them are. LOL
12:31 PM on 10/10/2011
Dentures can be fine if they are made right. Lower dentures can be secured by two anchors . Uppers
sometimes need adhesive.
12:29 PM on 10/10/2011
I get ripped off every time I go. And still to this day I have not seen a thyroid collar at any of them. The best part is when you get in the chair and the alternate dentist is treating you and asking the dental assistant questions on the procedure is and they do not know the answer and you do. So how do you keep your mouth shut ...lol
12:15 PM on 10/10/2011
Well where to start, I know this dentist is protecting his practice and i dont blame him but........ dentures is the only way to go. I have poor genetics for teeth both parents and siblings have dentures.
I spent close to $10,000 on my 2 kids teeth to have braces, my daughter only had 1 set of braces, my son had to have 2 sets because the first set of braces was done when he was to young. as soon as my daughter had her braces removed ( within 1 yr) see had to have a root canal, then a yr later another one. Iam in my mid 40s and have had dentures for over a year now and love them. They are straighter, cleaner and easier to maintain then naturall teeth. My daughter is so fustraited with going to the dentist for root canals, bridges, crowns, fillings, and etc. she wishes she would of got dentures. So as far as biting power yeah maybe a little less. but flopping around , no not at all and i eat anything i want whenever i want, unlike my son has to watch eating anything to cold of too hot. Having gotten dentures is one of the best decisions of my life.