iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tom Doran

GET UPDATES FROM Tom Doran
 

How Legitimate Was My Rape?

Posted: 08/20/2012 10:32 am

TRIGGER WARNING: this article contains references to and information about sexual assault and/or violence which may be triggering to survivors.

Sexual assault is justly considered one of the most serious crimes a person can be accused of. This makes it all the more critical to dispel any ambiguity over what constitutes "rape". To help you navigate through all the confusing, often contradictory definitions of the word, I present this handy questionnaire.

Am I Pregnant?


If YES, congratulations! You weren't raped. No less an authority than Representative Todd Akin of Missouri's 2nd congressional district says:

First of all, from what I understand from doctors [pregnancy from rape] is really rare [...] If it's a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down.

Not willing to let such left-wing diversions as so-called "medical expertise" and "common decency" stand in his way, the good congressman is here to give all you ladies a refresher course in reproductive health. When a woman is legitimately raped (once the perpetrator has waited the required 6-8 weeks for his Rape License to come through), a microscopic set of steel hangar doors immediately seal her fallopian tubes shut, rendering fertilization impossible. Rep. Akin is currently running for Senate, so GET DONATING! It occurs to me that I neglected to mention his party identification, but that's probably unnecessary.

If NO, proceed to the next question.

Am I Married to the Perpetrator?


If YES, congratulations! You weren't raped. Pastor Ron Hamman of Alaska sets the record straight:

The truth is that God has given to us physical needs we commonly refer to as a "sex drive," and he has designed for these to be met within the bounds of marriage. The trouble comes when one spouse or the other decides to exact retaliation against the other because of some offense and withholds him or herself from his or her mate. This is wickedness, and such is a violation of the spirit of marriage on the part of the withholder.

I know you wish he wouldn't drink so much and keep hitting you, but fair is fair -- no need to take that out on him by neglecting your bounden duty as a household masturbatory aid. Nonetheless, I appreciate that some may find this position a little extreme, which is why I was so pleased to alight on this brilliant compromise proposed by Atghan Shia cleric Mohammed Asif Mohseni: you can refuse sex, but if you do, he can refuse to feed you. Everybody's happy!

If NO, proceed to the next question.

Did the Perpetrator Ever Direct Any Really Awesome Movies?


If YES, congratulations! You weren't raped. Now, this one can present difficulties to some. When you're a powerful Hollywood director and use your influence to get a 13-year-old girl alone with you, then ply her with drugs and forcibly sodomize her, you might think a description like, off the top of my head, "scumbag rapist" would be appropriate. But let me ask you something: Have you ever played a rape victim in a movie? Well, have you? I thought not. That's why you should respect the superior wisdom of Whoopi Goldberg.

If NO, proceed to the next question.

Have I at Any Point Ventured Outside Without Submitting My Wardrobe to the Authorities for Approval?


If YES, congratulations! You weren't raped. Toronto police officer Michael Sanguinetti sparked mass outrage when he told female college students to "avoid dressing like sluts" -- but why? It's good, commonsense advice. You see, ladies, when you reveal more than the socially-sanctioned amount of skin (the amount changes according to location, time of year, religion, social class, age and the kind of mood I'm in), you want it. I know you think you don't. I know it seems very much like you're saying "no", screaming for help, struggling, praying for it to be over and suffering internal injuries and long-term psychological damage, but deep down, you asked for all that. Your rapist was just obliging you. Why would you send him to jail for being a good citizen?

If NO, proceed to the next question.

Does the perpetrator really, really hate the United States government?


If YES, congratulations! You weren't raped. In fact, I think it's rather impertinent of you to raise the question, don't you? Don't you know how many innocent people are being killed by drone strikes? Don't you know about Bradley Manning? Don't you know about all the other, much more reassuring subjects we could change this one to? Julian Assange is a visionary who speaks truth to power. He has bigger things on his mind. That's why, during his address from the balcony of the Ecuadorian embassy, he didn't mention you or your accusations once. Why are you so offended? I'm just saying you don't matter.

If NO, then tough luck. You were raped. Well, probably, but don't worry. Courts always take the side of the accuser, they're well-known for it. In fact, your chances of attaining a conviction are... Oh. Well, you really should have thought of that before being born a woman.

Good luck!

If you have been affected by any of the issues raised in this article, please visit rapecrisis.com for further information.

 

Follow Tom Doran on Twitter: www.twitter.com/portraitinflesh

FOLLOW POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 88
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Katherine Hompes
Common sense is not so common
06:18 PM on 08/27/2012
Comparing the Julian Assange situation to rape really offends me, as a survivor.

Also you forgot - "If you don't show up to the ER as a mass of bruises...."
or ""If you don't report it"
or "if you are engaged in the sex industry"
08:09 PM on 08/24/2012
This column was brilliant. You articulate so well what I cannot.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Patricia Hutchins Lyon
05:32 PM on 08/24/2012
I have never understood why I as a woman am responsible for the lack of control of men over their sexuality or anger.
Seems that I am responsible for my control over my impulses; so why aren't they responsible for controlling theirs?
04:57 AM on 08/26/2012
shout that from the roof tops I remember having this question back in grade school in the 60.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
allthisandbrainstoo
11:29 PM on 08/26/2012
Throughout history, men have held a superior place over women. They are (allegedly) mentally, emotionally, spiritually and of course, physically better.
And we the inferior ones are responsible for their good behavior.
Never made any damn sense to me.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
anon004
Yes, it's true -- reality has a liberal bias
02:25 PM on 08/24/2012
" neglecting your bounden duty as a household masturbatory aid. "

That's a classic. It's even better than "Close your eyes and think of England."
04:24 AM on 08/23/2012
I wonder how many "illegitimate" rapes Mr. Akin has committed himself? There is really no difference between being a pro-rapist and a rapist in my opinion.
01:42 PM on 08/22/2012
One man (er, human), in one state, in one race, in one instance - said something wrong/bad/incorrect/misstated/erroneous/stupid, etc. And we're going to react like this?! We're going to label everyone in the party as we are!? We're going to project this one statement into every other political race in the country? Really?? Seriously??? This is insane.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:38 PM on 08/22/2012
Sigh. If only it were confined to one instance. Rep. Akin along with Paul Ryan introduced a bill last year which essentially set out exactly what he said. "Legitimate" or forcible rape (is what I believe he meant) is basically someone breaks down your door and rapes you and funding would have been provided for an abortion in that situation. "Non-forcible" rape (i.e. statutory, incest, CONSENTING TO SAVE YOUR LIFE or where someone was drugged) would not be eligible for a publicly funded abortion in the event of pregnancy. Problems: 1. The idea that women can self-abort under stress is lunacy. 2. He sits on the House Committee for Science, Space and Technology. 3. He has introduced and will continue to introduce bills that reflect the position he "erroneously" stated to the chagrin of the GOP. The same GOP that now has a "no abortion under any condition including rape or incest" plank in its platform. I agree that we should allow people room for error but this is no error. I am personally glad he said it because it was honest. I am disgusted by what he said but he told the truth about what he believes. How refreshing. I hope he is crushed in the election.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ron Hovey
Empathy, Rationality, Equanimity
09:17 AM on 08/23/2012
The Republican Party Platform - the Platform of the Whole Republican Party - denies the need to terminate pregnancy in the case of rape or incest. The only difference between Akin and the rest of his party is not his policies or ideas it was his words. You are right, "One man (er, human), in one state, in one race, in one instance - said something wrong / bad/incorrect/ misstated/erroneous/ stupid, etc." But that one instance illuminates the rest of the party.
photo
Inkosi
The gods themselves rage against stupidity
12:40 PM on 08/22/2012
In a jury trial - once something is said, it cannot be unsaid. The judge can strike it from the record, tell the jury to disregard it but nevertheless, it is still there. The thugs want to cut off access to birth control, abortions so a woman is either compelled to have the baby or seek an old time abortion in a back room with a wire coat hanger - while at the same time cutting off any and all assistance in providing for the child. No food stamps, health care, housing assistance. I am particularly amused by Joe Walsh- he is the poster man for this issue. I wonder how much he owes in back child support now! Just imagine how may illegitmate kids are going to be born to our illustrious politicians! Maybe there will be a junket for female interns to Costa Rico or other countries where abortions are legal.
06:09 PM on 08/21/2012
I don't care what PARTY you are, he was so very wrong in what he said.....Yes, he should be saying he is sorry, however, the damage is now done!!!!!
04:03 PM on 08/21/2012
A bold piece of satire. I'd like to see a follow up article about what happens when the answer is Yes. What's the process for "legitimate"? How long to get a judge to listen to your case? Will all those close to you have to submit DNA for a match? Will the legitimacy be figured out before the abortion deadline?
photo
Gestas
Mountain Man
12:36 PM on 08/21/2012
The Republican Party would view a Legitimate Rape about the same as a Legitimate Election..
photo
Inkosi
The gods themselves rage against stupidity
12:01 PM on 08/21/2012
I am the mother of a rape victim. My 14 year old daughter was a rape victim. I can tell you the emotional turmoil is unfanthomable, the financial burden is astronomical. The trauma never really goes away. All future relationships are colored by the experience. She is now 32 years old and married to a police officer. She has a gun in the nightstand drawer. She never goes out alone at night. Her house is locked up like maximum security prison and she has two big dogs! I would love to have Mr. Akins experience the full spectrum of the rape experience for himself before he takes a stand on the issue. An incarceration in prision would do nicely in this case.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CSDofNM
I speak lolcat
01:34 PM on 08/28/2012
F and F'ed!
photo
playsindirt
So much dirt, so little time.
01:36 PM on 08/28/2012
Best post I've read today. God bless you and your family.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:37 AM on 08/21/2012
That was really, really good. The ability to use humor to cope in these times is the only thing that will save our sanity.
10:54 AM on 08/21/2012
You left out consensual rape where the "victim" consents but is not legally entitled to do so such as age differences, intoxication, or mental disability. The legitimacy of such rape should be questioned on a case by case basis and would not qualify as forcible assuming the victim is conscious and willingly consents.

The retroactive removal of consent is the source of many false rape claims. A person may agree to sex then declare themselves raped because they regretted it. It's a legitimate concern along with claims of rape to avoid embarrassment or shame for having engaged in some sexual activities. Saying someone made you do it is a easy way out and I imagine men would also employ the tactic if it were considered plausible.
photo
Inkosi
The gods themselves rage against stupidity
12:45 PM on 08/22/2012
And the victim should was a Scarlet Letter "W" for hoe or "A" for adulteress. Of course the man goes scott free.
05:19 AM on 08/26/2012
men have been using that tactic forever, 2nd dumb bunny award. she had on the short skirt and she smiled at me and every body knows that I am so hot no girl can resit me and no really means yesand if she did not want it she should not have been in that dark parking lot after school I can go on but i hope you get the point.
07:05 AM on 08/26/2012
Uh, NO I am talking about consensual sex being reinterpreted as rape after the fact by a women who was some how unsatisfied with the experience. He went too fast, he was pushy, I was annoyed by something he did, even though I initially did agree to have sex with him.

When you keep extending what's classified as rape it become anything a partner doesn't like before, during, or after sex. It also gives people great reason to question rape accusations to be sure the claim of RAPE is indeed valid.

"men have been using that tactic forever, 2nd dumb bunny award."

Men don't have a tactic here, your describing what rapist do to excuse their behavior. I am talking about what illegitimate accusers do to rationalize false rape claims.
10:51 AM on 08/21/2012
Tom thanks for this post. It is men like you that give me hope for all men. We need more men like you. :-)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bradlinsky
Concept Other Than Self
09:47 AM on 08/21/2012
I didn't think you could pull this off, given the subject matter. But man, your writing is fantastic! Well done. It just get chills, however, knowing that people (the bat-sh*t crazy ones) actually believe some of the scenarios you outlined ...