iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tom Matlack

GET UPDATES FROM Tom Matlack
 

Tiger Woods And The State of Modern Manhood

Posted: 12/02/09 03:27 PM ET

The continued revelations about Tiger Woods are crushing because his public persona was so perfectly manicured. We loved his goodness as a man as much as his perfect swing. Edwards, Letterman, even Madoff is one thing. But Tiger? The answer should cause us to look deeply in the mirror as men.

Guys we are at a crossroads. You can go back into the cave if you want to but it isn't going to do you, or your family, any good. The guys I know, from investment bankers to Marines, are asking themselves how they can possibly be good fathers, sons, husbands, and workers at the same time. In a way its what women have struggled with for decades but us guys are just facing into as the challenge of a "he-cession" at work and increased expectations at home have us reeling.

At its core is the problem is our caveman instinct to compartmentalize our lives. Many, many men have achieved great public success while failing miserably in their private lives.

I should know. Like Tiger I once had two baby children, a big house and the public spotlight. I was the 29 year-old wunderkind who led the unlikely IPO and, 90 days later, the $2 billion sale of a century old media empire. The same week I was on the front page of the Wall Street Journal my then wife kicked me out of the house for being a failure as a husband and father. That Saturday morning I found myself in a church parking lot trying to explain to my mother why I had nowhere to go. (Read my story HERE)

That phone call began a fourteen year ongoing journey into the meaning of manhood that has culminated in the publication of a recent anthology of men's stories about manhood.

4094918683_dd0e6a4a39(2)

Tom Matlack addressing The Belmont Hill School where students asked questions like, "If I do something bad is it still possible for me to be a good man?"

From traveling the country talking to men of all walks of life the one theme that comes up over and over again is the importance of honesty--with ourselves as men and with our loved ones. A blogger on our website recently called it living a life of "congruence" meaning being the same man as a father and husband as you are a worker. And being willing to talk openly about the challenges of each.

There is no silver bullet for us guys these days. But silence sure as hell isn't the answer. We have to willing to open our mouths and tell the truth about our lives, our successes, and our failures if we are going to get anywhere.


 

Follow Tom Matlack on Twitter: www.twitter.com/tmatlack

The continued revelations about Tiger Woods are crushing because his public persona was so perfectly manicured. We loved his goodness as a man as much as his perfect swing. Edwards, Letterman, even ...
The continued revelations about Tiger Woods are crushing because his public persona was so perfectly manicured. We loved his goodness as a man as much as his perfect swing. Edwards, Letterman, even ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 30
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
CuriousGuy
Media Professional
02:39 PM on 12/11/2009
Give me a break with your puritan 17th century prognostications ethics.

Have you looked at the stats on infidelity? It's at 80% -- and that's probably an under estimate. Monogamy is a human construct. We made it up -- just like the silly sense of guilt that surrounds it. Oh, we should suppress our natural impulses because society says so? Hum, that seems natural.

Everyone involved here is a consenting adult. If his wife feels cheated she is naive.

Tiger Woods is a man -- and he did what all men would do, given the opportunity. He has good looks, money and lots of opportunity. Most married men have a regular schedule that requires they be home after work.

This is a private matter and has nothing to do with his ability as a golfer.

I want to know how many of the corporate executives that sign Tiger's endorsement checks have been faithful to their wives. The hypocrisy is maddening!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chas53
05:16 PM on 12/03/2009
Let us not forget about Evolution, alpha males and pack mentality. Look at history, it is replete with men who had power and a harem/concubines etc.etc.. Not saying what Tiger did is "right", but it might be fighting nature to be monogamous. Not sure if this is a "moral" issue. Biology may have taken precedence here. Just a thought.
11:21 AM on 12/04/2009
I tire of the "biology" argument. Cannot the brain control the body?

Any one who does not want to commit to monogamy, if that is the agreement with the loved one, should stay single.
01:46 PM on 12/03/2009
As a divorced woman in her 30's, I can attest to the idea that there is a shocking lack of "good men" out there in the world. To the point that I've stopped dating and decided that for awhile, I'm just better off single. There just seem too be many selfish, narcissistic men-boys out there and not enough "men".
02:00 PM on 12/03/2009
It seems that you equate dating with 'finding a husband". When you're dating, you're still single and are not tied to anyone.
Too often, women are looking for a husband, when they should relax and go out with people they like and have many things in common. Having a good meaningful relationship with another person should be the goal; Not marriage.

Not dating and only going out with girlfriends and doing your own things will not bring you closer to finding that guy that you can build a healthy loving relationship. Jaded women never attract good men. If you're really attractive, guys will not care if you're jaded and will be just interested in taking you to bed. Sad, but oh, so True!
11:51 AM on 12/04/2009
I think you might have misunderstood Landgeek's post.

I was 34 when I divorced my first husband, and there are close to no "good guys" out there, even to date. They are a bunch of selfish and narcissistic boys, and lots have drug or alcohol problems. I was very lucky to find a wonderful man. We were friends at first and hung out together. It did eventually lead to marriage, and we will be married for 10 years on Jan.1st.

Landgeek, it is not entirely hopeless. I found a great guy. He is 15 years my senior. Maybe you should start dating older guys, even if you think they are not your type.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
bikerdude
On the left side of progressive
10:01 AM on 12/03/2009
With whom are these "bad" men cheating? Why has that become an option? Is it a bad sex life at home, or better "offers" across the street? If a guy who is married, and maybe with family, what causes him to look elsewhere? What about the married women who are doing the same thing? Cougars are on the rise....I will take the responsibility for my actions, but it takes two (or more) to tango.
11:14 AM on 12/04/2009
Please, no "cougars". Besides, I believe that derogatory term is not used for women who are looking for old, married men.
09:39 AM on 12/03/2009
If you are defining a "Good Man" as a man that doesn't have affairs, then 8 out of 10 men (80%) would be 'Not Good". Are 80% of the men in this world really evil and deserve scorn?
The answer is "No".
Society's idea of "Evil" men is that they broke a sacrament.
We can take away this charade characteristic of "Evil" through one simple solution:

Men should not marry.

If Tiger Woods was not married, but living with his partner/girlfriend, then he would not face the heinous ridicule through the media today. Under such circumstances, If Tiger was having a relationship with another woman, he and his long term girl could have separated and lived apart. Tiger would have been able to date the other woman and live life on his terms.

However, because of a marriage certificate, If Tiger wants to separate, he has to think about his financial holdings, his properties, his money, etc. And most likely, to keep Tiger on a leash, his wife is threatening him that she will take half of his 100's of millions of dollars in wealth and his properties and his yacht and he would have to continue paying her alimony for many years.

A marriage certificate is a "Power Transfer" document, giving control to the woman.
Proof? 70% of marriages end in Divorce. As a result of divorce, men have reduced wealth and property. These are Facts.

(continued below)
11:16 AM on 12/04/2009
"Men should not marry."

I agree that NO ONE should marry if they aren't prepared to either live up to the commitment of monogamy OR if they don't have an open agreement with their proposed spouse.
09:38 AM on 12/03/2009
Simple solution to have more "Good Men" in this world: Men should not marry.The court system in a divorce proceeding is designed against the benefit of Man. The legal system has too much power over the relationship of people, especially in the cases of Separation. Men should live with their girlfriends and if they choose to stay together, that's their decision, not that of a judge on a bench.

The trend among intelligent men today is to not marry. Men today understand the risk of marriage and the chance of financial ruin of an impending divorce. It's can be a financial debacle for a Man. More and more men are not getting married and they are correct.
11:55 AM on 12/04/2009
It is also a financial nightmare for the woman. In fact, more women come out of the marriage worse off financially than the men, mostly because they have the responsibility of raising the children and child support doesn't even come close to making up that gap. Look up the statistics for yourself, if you don't believe me.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thinkingwomanmillstone
great, green, globs of greasy grimey GOPerspeak.
09:21 AM on 12/03/2009
I've met several star athletes who were not ethical men off of the field. I tend to think that some of it is the sports' attitude that it's not wrong unless the ref calls you on it and even if he calls you on it, it's still not cheating even if you did it deliberately. It's all just part of the sport and spills over to real life. Over and over again, we hear: "Oh I made a mistake and let my family down." This comes only after they have been caught. Many of these "mistakes" are in fact long patterns of misbehavior, sometimes criminal, almost always deliberate violations of trust and morality. Tiger Woods has apparently engaged in an almost 3 year adulterous relationship with a woman during a 5 year marriage. It appears that there are other instances of infidelity. Sorry is inadequate. Tiger is known for his temper and controlling nature. He is known to send his caddy after fans who somehow bother him. In this case, he will send his lawyers and publicists. If you don't want the media to out you, don't do things worthy of being outed. It seems that he's more mad at the messenger than he is at himself. These types of failings of men require more than an apology. They require introspection, and character rehabilitation. His publicist may be able to polish some of the tarnish off of his image, only he will be able to polish his character.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
KIVPossum
Moldova Marsupial
09:18 AM on 12/03/2009
Everyone makes mistakes in life. It's how you handle them that shows your mettle.

Tiger screwed up, big time. Yet he has always seems a good man and I suspect he will handle this with more dignity than most adulterers.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
bikerdude
On the left side of progressive
10:04 AM on 12/03/2009
Did he screw up or did he react to a changing situation in his life?
Going from basically high school to being a self-made multi-millionaire has got to play with your head....How much "growing up" did he miss out on?
When they asked Bill Clinton why he did what he did, he said it was because he could. There always seems to be a willing, accomodating partner waiting to jump into the breech....
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
KIVPossum
Moldova Marsupial
01:04 PM on 12/03/2009
I guess different people 'react to a changing sitiuation' differently. Actually somewhat surprised Tiger found this to be his outlet.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:12 AM on 12/04/2009
Strangely, I have never viewed Tiger as "a good man" I thought him a control freak and terribly difficult to live with. Without knowing him, I came to the same conclusions about his personality that "thinkingwomanmillstone" outlined in her comment.
Maybe we are both wrong, but I sure hope his wife busted out of that prison when she clubbed him. Maybe she should THANK his many women for exposing the slimy underbelly of Mr Clean Green. Power and the abuse of power calls for a REVOLUTION. Golf clubs weapon of choice for the peasants.
photo
TParrish
Favoite game: Mobius Strip Poker
07:01 AM on 12/03/2009
1. Professional sports is almost always the wrong place to look for shining examples of manly behavior. With only a few exceptions it is an environment populated by physically mature children who play games for a living, seeking a life of privileged and entitlement.

2. Manliness...ACTUAL manliness is unpopular today. Even the phrase "Be a man." is politically incorrect. As a teenager I was embroiled in a hot dispute with a friend, and said some regrettable things about him and his family. My father, who was one of those guys who seemed to know everything I did or said, no matter where I was when I did or said it, pointed out to me that my friend's father was a fine man, salt of the Earth, and I had wronged him terribly. I admitted that he was right. "What should I do?" I asked.
"Be a man. Go apologize to him." he said.
I did. Hardest thing I ever did.

The idea that manliness can mean that when you are wrong, you SAY that you are wrong is foreign to much of our testosterone-driven, overgrown teenager-riddled society.

Tom, if you can get that point across, then you are doing good work.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Tom Matlack
Man, Husband, Dad, Writer, Venture Capitalist
11:04 AM on 12/03/2009
Thanks for the support and encouragement!
11:58 AM on 12/04/2009
Being able to apologize for your mistakes is one of the best qualities of a man. I bet your wife is one happy woman.
09:20 PM on 12/02/2009
I am a young father and huge golf/sports fan. Growing up following sports and the people who play them I've learned that often times there is a direct relationship between how good a professional athlete is and how flawed they are personally.

I would have never believed this was the case with Tiger. I totally bought his image and admired him as a person and as an athlete. This week I'm mourning the loss of my last sports hero. Good thing I've already learned to look for good men to emulate in my every day life.
11:27 AM on 12/04/2009
How sad. I wish you luck.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dukedraven
05:29 PM on 12/02/2009
We should always aim for better and try not to repeat past mistakes. It's only way to break the cycle.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Trilby
Like candy for dinner.
04:59 PM on 12/02/2009
Personal ethics for men is a subject that men need to address themselves. It is no good if we women do it. I follow the articles about the trafficking of women and girls all over the world and right here at home, and I wonder, when are men going to stop telling each other that it's ok, even manly, to pay for sex when the "provider" may be someone powerless who's been coerced, drugged, beaten into submission. That's not ok! Men, step up. Stop the constant [wink, wink] prowl for the next piece of ass. Love the one you're with! Think of the children! Make the world a better place!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Tom Matlack
Man, Husband, Dad, Writer, Venture Capitalist
06:04 PM on 12/02/2009
Yes i was actually just talking to the Publisher of GQ who runs the Gentlemen Fund and he was quoting the worldwide numbers on the sex trade and sex slaves. It was unbelievable, frightening, maddening and very sad. Something that we all have a moral obligation to do something about.
12:13 AM on 12/04/2009
Trilby,

There used to be a time when most folks kinda knew that you could only go so far.
Couples struggled with it and either broke up or decided to get married and had a short engagement.

Apparenlty, it worked pretty well.

Now things are different.

Why would any man marry if they could "shack up"?
11:26 AM on 12/04/2009
The old "why buy the cow" argument.

Doesn't "shack up" mean "living together"?
04:25 PM on 12/02/2009
I keep waiting for more than a tidbit in your articles. Drexler is on here several times a week, NYT has Motherlode and one other mom blog. I keep hearing men ask when will there be a "man' blog on HuffPo or NYT, etc. I keep wondering when men will step up and write one. I need/want to hear mens views on things. Please give us more than a few sentences telling men they're at a cross roads.
Please.
Thank you!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Tom Matlack
Man, Husband, Dad, Writer, Venture Capitalist
04:59 PM on 12/02/2009
Have you actually looked at our blog www.goodmenproject.org or read our book of 31 essays on manhood THE GOOD MEN PROJECT (available on Amazon) or watched our documentary film on the same topic?

We have more content on this topic that you probably want but the format for Huff Post limits me to 750 words. I would *like* to say more but can't here.

Let me know if there is something specific you are looking for that you don't think is here. The truth is in the stories of the men in the book and dvd.
03:51 PM on 12/02/2009
Nicely put. I think you're right.