The New York Times ran a tabloid-style hit piece on K12, the online learning provider. They apparently didn't speak to many parents that appreciate full time virtual schools as an option. Follow are excerpts of 10 notes I received from parents this week with a different story.
T. Weiss said, "There is almost NO flexibility in brick-and-mortar middle schools for students who love to learn but have delayed fine motor, gross motor, and organizational skills. Even his IEP was not honored, and he was termed "lazy." With the scheduling flexibility of OHVA which allows him to work longer on classes which take longer and move more quickly through content which comes easy for him, he has regained his love of learning and is reading every day because he WANTS to. He is progress monitored against the current Ohio 7th Grade Standards...He has teachers who WANT to hear from me as the parent, and he has an Intervention Specialist who knows his educational strengths and weaknesses. We have had bumps along the way, of course, but overall this school year has been FANTASTIC compared to the hell of 6th grade in a traditional public middle school."
Jen said, "My son attends Texas Virtual Academy at Southwest - only he couldn't start on time this year. He had open heart surgery on August 23rd, the first day of school. His surgery was 8 hours, and he was in the hospital three weeks. The surgeons wanted us to "keep him out of school" for another two months after that - when we explained about K12, that we would be able to pace him, that it would not be physically taxing, they gave us approval to start as soon as he was ready. He chose to return the week he was out of the hospital. His teacher was aware of everything, helped us get him back in a groove, and instead of missing the three weeks of school he was able to start from the first day of school 3 weeks late - without K12, I have no doubt his 8th Grade Year would have potentially been down the drain. Because of K12, he was able to ease back into his normal life at his own pace, with the support of his parents and the school - and most especially his teacher. I wish they would profile some of us for a change."
Jody said, "It's nice to have options! I have a wonderful sixteen year old son who is very creative & intelligent. He is bored to death in school. We have so much stimulation in the world today. We ask our kids to sit in a chair for hours, non stimulated. Our local public school system is on the cutting edge. But, it's not changing fast enough for him. K12 allows him time to do other things. He already is a budding entrepreneur and has a YouTube sight with 5,000 hits. We are grateful for this outside of the box option."
Amber said, "My Daughter made it through kindergarten in public school, she not only did not know how to read according to them but failed art and came home discussing racism at 5 years old, I pulled her and went through an alternative school which supported the K12 program. Now She is in second grade and tests off the charts! I have never made a better decision for her. She not only is getting a wonderful education but also is less cranky, and more involved with violin lessons, soccer, junior grange and more! Thank you K12 for what you have given my family, the right to a solid education without the torture that our public schools have become!"
Cathy said, "We are in our 9th year with OHVA, a K12 virtual academy, and my daughter will graduate as one of the kids who attended for all 13 years of her schooling (K-12). We initially chose e-schooling because of a learning-style issue for my son, but it's become a life-style for us. We love the flexibility that e-schooling allows. My mom is a retired teacher from a district with an excellent rating here in Ohio, and she said the K12 curriculum is the best she's ever seen. School doesn't take 10 hours/day, so my kids are involved in other activities such as 4-H, Boy Scouts, competitive dance, and volunteering. My son is a 17 year old Eagle Scout and my daughter is does historical re-enactments along side adults with DatyonHistory.org. We travel off-season (which costs less) and my kids have visited many of the historical sites other kids just read about in their history books. What an incredible opportunity technology has created for us!"
Warren said, "My son started K12 this year. He is a very smart child. The school he went to could not accommodate him. The learning pace was to slow for him therefore he was bored. He did not want to go to school for that reason. Now he can work at his pace. He loves it. He is making A's now and is ahead of his schedule. My wife and I are very thankful for K12!"
Rosa said, "My children have had the privilege of attending a blended K12 school since Kindergarten. It is more work than I had imagined and far more rewarding than I had hoped. Thank you, K12, for ignoring legislation and bad press. Thank you, K12, for providing my family with curriculum that I would have to pay $15k plus for in my city's private schools. $15k for each child, mind you."
Aimee said, "My children have been in California Virtual Academy (CAVA) for a year this January. We pulled out of brick and mortar school because of the way the schools are ran...My son is high functioning autistic and was bullied badly. We are a military family and the school district is the best in Northern California, but they were about 1-2 yrs behind. Now my daughter is working at a 9th grade level reading at a 12th grade level. My son had figured out the easiest and best way for him to learn. The district was not allowing him freedom to learn the way he is able to learn and in 1st grade was reading at a preschool level. Now he is learning at a 3rd grade level but is in 2nd grade. He is HAPPY...K12 is an amazing program...The families are held to a higher standard and held accountable for their education. The teachers are certified teachers. The students have several options to show they are within national education standards including mandatory state testing and other online testing. They receive one on one attention by being at home and are able to have a fully enriched education by including music and art, classes that are being removed from traditional schools. The teachers are available daily for anything. I am amazed by the program and how happy my children have become. My family is much more relaxed and I am watching my childrens' minds grow daily."
JMG said, "Glad no one closed the comments to this article like they did right after the Times piece was published. One of the things that irked me most were comments from the readers at the bottom of the article. My 11 year old read a few after the article and he asked, "Mom, have they ever even spoken with anyone who uses K12?" If he can point out bias and propaganda (ironically, the unit we happened to be covering in one of his K12 courses), why can't an adult? It was sad to see a complete misrepresentation of the program, the parents and students."
Gail said, "I speak as a learning coach for my two children, 10 and 8, who have attended Georgia Cyber Academy for 4 1/2 years. I have an MBA and a masters degree in health administration. Although an advanced degree is not necessary for success, I do think my input and interest enhance my kids' learning experience. We have been very satisfied with K12′s curriculum and with GCA as an option...They are able to move at an accelerated pace in some subjects. This keeps them challenged in the areas where they are strongest. They take the state standardized test every year, and they have the option (which I chose to do) of taking the ITBS also. GCA offers many interactive online lessons taught by certified teachers. GCA also requires 3 to 4 five-paragraph essays per student each year. These are reviewed and scored by GCA-certified teachers, providing good feedback in this important area. Scheduling is more flexible than in brick & mortar schools, and there are less distractions administratively. The online tools are amazingly fun and thorough, and they are balanced by an equally impressive set of offline textbooks, worksheets, and writing and math assignments. GCA offers many field trip opportunities, but I do also consider it important for my kids to have several other weekly activities where they interact with kids their age. We do scouts, music programs, tennis, and track. I'm sure not all learning coaches are able to stay as organized and persistent as needed, but GCA still offers a great alternative in my opinion. I am thankful to have this choice, and I feel my kids will one day be very equipped educationally to be productive members of society. They will also carry values which my husband and I think are important."
Follow Tom Vander Ark on Twitter: www.twitter.com/tvanderark
5. Were the students bringing the scores down for K12 overwhelmingly new students that were flunking in the brick & mortar schools?
6. The article also stated, "A third do not graduate on time." Of the third, what percentage graduated early, and what percentage graduated late, and if late how late, and what are the comparisons to the brick & mortar graduation rates?
7. What is the drop-out rate in comparison to the brick & mortar schools?
8. Once again using a statement from the article, "In Pennsylvania, about 30,000 students are enrolled in online schools at an average cost of about $10,000 per student." What is the average cost per pupil in the brick & mortar schools in PA?
9. Mr Wagner, the Pennsylvania State Auditor General, was quoted, "“It’s extremely unfair for the taxpayer to be paying for additional expenses, such as advertising,” Is it fair that the taxpayers also pay a higher wage that covers union dues so the unions can lobby the government officials?
10. The Memphis City Schools Deputy Superintendent is quoted as, "“The early development of children requires lots of interaction with other children for purposes of socialization, developing collaboration and teamwork, and self-definition.” Does he think the children are locked into a closet, never to emerge save for lessons? The truly amusing part is that I have dealt with Memphis City Schools and they have a very bad reputation.
1. Why were so many of the people quoted about how bad online school people from brick & mortar schools as opposed to the colleges to which the students from the online school would be applying?
2. The article said K12 has spent $681,000 on lobbying in Pennsylvania. How much has the Teacher's Union spent on lobbying during the same time frame? How about the NEA?
3. The article stated K12 had donated $500,000 to state candidates from 2004 through 2010. How much is that per candidate? Don't worry, I did the math on that one. It breaks down to $71,428 per year throughout the country, and a total of $1,428 per STATE (using all 50 states). A total of less that $1500 per state?? Considering the number of candidates per state running at any given time is probably a few, even at the low number of 3 candidates per state, that breaks down to the massive amount of $500 per candidate, not a particularly high amount. I wonder how much the assorted unions that have their income dependent upon brick & mortar schools contributed to each candidate?
4. The article started off stating, "Nearly 60 percent of its students are behind grade level in math. Nearly 50 percent trail in reading." What were the statistics for the brick and mortar schools for that same time frame with the same type of students?