More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tony Newman

Tony Newman

Posted: March 15, 2010 04:58 PM

Bloodbath in Mexico: Drug Prohibition Is to Blame for Thousands of Mexican and Now American Deaths

What's Your Reaction:

When we think about wars happening in the world right now, Iraq and Afghanistan jump to mind. But there is war in our backyard that can match the violence anywhere in the world, and that is the Drug War in Mexico.

Mexico President Felipe Calderon launched a full-scale military assault against the drug traffickers in his country as soon as he took office in December 2006. Three years later, the "surge" against the cartels has led to Mexico spinning out of control with jaw-dropping violence -- with no meaningful impact on the export and availability of drugs. More than twice the number of Mexicans have died in these three years -- 15,000 -- than have Americans in both Iraq and Afghanistan combined after more than seven years.

In the past three days, the insanity has made front page news, as it often does. The New York Times published a piece about the "death of journalism," about how cartels have threatened and killed so many reporters in Mexico that the press is too terrified to cover the drug war. Today there is another front page New York Times piece about the two U.S. consulate officials who were gunned down over the weekend, the highest ranking Americans to be murdered to date. And this weekend we also heard about the 24 people murdered, including several beheadings, in the spring break hot spot of Acapulco.

While the mayhem has been covered in tens of thousands of news stories around the world, rarely is the root of the problem explained: drug prohibition. Remember alcohol prohibition, Chicago under Al Capone, shoot-outs in broad daylight? That's what we have in Mexico, a thousand times over.

There is nothing inherently evil or violent about marijuana and coca, but prohibiting these plants makes them worth more than gold. And people are willing to kill each for the enormous profits to be made by bringing them to market. Now that alcohol is legal, no one is murdered over a case of Budweiser.

The best next-step we have towards reducing the violence in Mexico is ending marijuana prohibition. The Drug Enforcement Agency estimates that 60% of the cartels profits come from marijuana, a plant that more than one-half of Americans have consumed at some point in their lives. Regulating the multi-billion dollar marijuana market would significantly diminish the power of the cartels.

But don't expect our elected officials and other leadership to make this happen any time soon. With the exception of a brave few, most in Washington are too politically timid to even have a debate about the root problem.

Fortunately, there's a history of citizens taking the lead on de-escalating the drug war at home, most prominently in California where they approved measures at the ballot to create access to medical marijuana in 1996, and a treatment-instead-of-incarceration program for nonviolent drug users in 2000. This November, the people of California will once again have an opportunity to vote on an anti-drug war ballot initiative, this time to tax and regulate marijuana in the state.

If it passes, it could prove to be a pivotal first step towards ending marijuana prohibition in the U.S. -- and the violence in Mexico. As we've learned these past three years, more guns, tanks, and bombs in Mexico are not the answer. It's time for an exit strategy from the failed war on marijuana. If the people lead, the leaders will follow.


Tony Newman is the director of media relations at the Drug Policy Alliance (www.drugpolicy.org)

 

Follow Tony Newman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TonyNewmanDPA

 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
04:13 PM on 03/16/2010
Know how else we can reduce the Mexican drug violence? Reduce the amount of guns in the US. A large portion of the guns used by the Mexican drug gangs are of US orgin.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tresco
Sistagirl Laughin' Thingy Award Winner!
11:47 AM on 03/16/2010
Buying dope from Mexico is unamerican. Why do people even have to buy it? Get off your lazy ass and grow it yourself! A nation of damn couch potatoes.
11:00 AM on 03/16/2010
Check out www.leap.cc to see what the experts say about whether or not drugs should be legalized. The name of the organization is Law Enforcement Against Prohibition. Enough said
photo
Kassandra
Idiot savant artistic genius
10:37 AM on 03/16/2010
Think of the tax base legalizing these drugs would give dying states like CA which burned 1 billion in maryjane alone last year. Stup!d, stup!d stup!d!
We've GOT to stop legislating "morality" we get "early mortality" instead! And lots of crime.
Remember it was prohibition of alcohol that created the mafia
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
waynesmyer
08:21 AM on 03/16/2010
Unless we take the money out of drugs, the killing in Mexico will continue! The problem is our Polticos
are either too stupid or to venal to do anything about it! I have lived off and on in Mexico for over 50 years
and the present situation is worse than any other times. My many relatives in Mexico are afraid to go out at night, or to the market in day-time. POBRE MEXICO! TAN LEJOS DE DIOS, TAN CIRCA LOS ESTADOS UNIDAS
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
realitytrumpsbull
two 'alves of coconut!
12:22 AM on 03/16/2010
Demon Weed has long been the subject of social controversy. I don't think it's that exciting, I tried it, I inhaled, I don't like it, I don't smoke it, have a nice day. But, I also think that the Prohibition angle is very important to discuss, it failed with liquor, and it doesn't seem to be working out so well with marijuana.

Should all drugs be legalized? Should any drugs remain illegal, or is it time to just decriminalize the creative personal chemistry stuff, and start focusing law enforcement efforts on people's conduct, either under the influence, or sober? Lots of people take drugs every day, but it's legitimized because they're bought through a pharmacy, in capsule or tablet form. Why not have pot-caps? For that matter, Heroin was a product of the Bayer company, cocaine was used as the active ingredient in Coca-Cola, so, in one sense, what's the big deal? The big deal is, it's ILLEGAL, and hence profitable, and has been the driving force behind some of the most violent organized crime this country has ever known.
When smoking pot becomes about as exciting as smoking your lawn clippings, we will have turned a corner on the issue of drugs, and the folks in Mexico, and in our southern states, will finally be able to breathe easy. People do the stuff anyway, despite all the billions spent, so why not save a whole bunch of money?
11:50 PM on 03/15/2010
But if you legalized pot and taxed it, you'd get $35B a year in revenues and save $15B a year in the "justice" program. Over 10 years, that's $500B.

Pay for ObamaCare by legalizing pot!
10:36 PM on 03/15/2010
Here's a talking point that I really think needs to be made, but I've not seen it mentioned, by anyone.

From above:

"Regulating the multi-billion dollar marijuana market would significantly diminish the power of the cartels. "

I'm in favor of the legalization of marijuana, but two things need to be absolutely clear:

1. Marijuana consumed in the US should be supplied by US growers and distributors only. Period.

2. Additionally, no US grown marijuana will be available for export, ever.

The economic impacts of legalization are vastly underestimated, by both sides of the issue, because its not really being visualized. During the next week, stop and truly consider the current impact of beer distribution, and I think you'll get a much better feel. Marijuana sales, et al, would not be anywhere near that big, especially at first, but grant even 10-20 per cent and it adds up very quickly.

In my opinion, the "flow" of this money should remain entirely within US borders. If we truly want to control and ultimately end the impacts of US drug demand on the economies and politics of other countries, then we need to stop their importation, legal or otherwise.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:05 PM on 03/15/2010
Legalize It...
06:03 PM on 03/15/2010
Tell that to CNN and others of the MSM that often just repeat the same old tired Government propaganda and talking points.
10:36 PM on 03/15/2010
And morally, we have an obligation to limit the impacts of US drug use to US citizens. For years, many Americans have vilified the governments and people of the countries that grow and send drugs to our shores. It would not be right to then export for sale our own "legal" drug products.

Until these two items are honestly considered; and, until a standardized detection and penalty system is designed for drug impaired driving, we're all just toying with the idea.