iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tracy Van Slyke

GET UPDATES FROM Tracy Van Slyke
 

Obama AWOL as 15.7 Million Homeowners Underwater

Posted: 05/25/2012 10:32 am

Thirty five point three billion and 15.7 million. Revealed this week, these two numbers perfectly capture the state of our economy and the lack of action by President Obama and his administration.

Thirty five point three billion dollars is the first quarter earnings of the financial industry, the highest earnings reported since before the economic collapse.

Fifteen point seven million is the number of homeowners in this country who owe more on their mortgage than their home is worth. That means that nearly one in every three mortgage holders is trapped, upside down or underwater on their mortgage. Put simply, Wall Street has more than recovered while the American people sink further and further away from economic security.

Conservative groups are attempting to portray Obama as a Wall Street pawn, and these numbers make that claim all too difficult to refute.

Wall Street's return to record profitability didn't happen by accident; a few short years ago the industry was on the brink of collapse, brought on by their own short-sighted and dangerous gambling with other people's money. They were rescued from their own hubris with trillions in tax-payer funded bail-outs and backstops, and have come roaring back. Meanwhile, far too little has been done to support the victims of Wall Street's criminal and negligent behavior.

One way to start to even the scales is by easing the debt burden on underwater homeowners by resetting their mortgages. Resetting mortgages at fair market value is the most efficient way to get our economy moving again and would put more than $6,500 into the pockets of the average underwater homeowner each year. With an extra $6,500, families could afford expenses, big and small, that they have been putting off. This would have a ripple effect throughout the economy, pumping $71 billion into the national economy, creating an estimated 1 million jobs and generating much-needed tax revenue.

Resetting mortgages also benefits the lenders, which publicly held banks are finally starting to realize. Foreclosure means an average loss to a lender of $60,000, in heavily affected states that number ranges from $115,000 to over $250,000. Restructuring a family's mortgage is much cheaper, keeps the family in their home, their children in school, and the community whole.

It's time to make the mortgage lenders and banks pay for what they did to American homeowners and begin to make Americans whole again. Here are three things the President can do to make it happen.

  1. It has been almost four months since President Obama announced the formation of a mortgage-backed securities fraud task force during his State of The Union, but there has been little to no significant progress to date. President Obama must put the full resources to hold Wall Street accountable. He must demonstrate to the American people that an aggressive, vigorous investigation into the banks is a priority for this administration.
  2. Fire Ed Demarco and replace him with someone who will order Fannie and Freddie to let their borrowers reset mortgages to fair market value. DeMarco is the head of the Federal Housing Finance Agency, which oversees Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and over half the mortgages in this country, and refuses to help millions of Americans reset their mortgages to fair market value. He even has gone so far as to hide recommendations from his own advisors that would help homeowners and the housing market.
  3. Push America's banks to reset mortgages to their fair market value and put an end to foreclosures so the housing market can stabilize for everyone. America has bailed out the banks for years -- the President must urge the big banks to pay us back.

If he doesn't do these things, 15.7 million underwater voters are going to want to know why this President Obama is not fighting for them come Nov. 6.

 

Follow Tracy Van Slyke on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@tracyvs

FOLLOW BUSINESS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 54
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimpager
01:21 PM on 06/26/2012
President Obama made a huge mistake in his first year...instead of injecting the trillion dollars into the consumer economy, he saved the five largest banks. Those banks should have gone under. They DESERVED to go under. Now American corporations have a two trillion dollar overhang on their balance sheets that they are sitting on and the economy still has a trillion dollar spending "hole". The toxic mortgages hole was too big for "just" a trillion dollar fill-up. But had President Obama found some way to get the trillion he wasted on banks out to middle class and poor families, who would have spent that trillion back into the economy right away at say a 5 to 1 multiplier effect, the banks would have gone but aggregate demand in the economy would have exploded, the stock market would have exploded, new corporations would have formed in the market economy, and I'll bet the Recession/Depression would be well along toward being a distant memory. Instead, President Obama listened to the New York bankers and now he's paying the price. And the ultimate irony, those same bankers are heavy contributors to the Romney campaign. Once again, Democrats were suckered.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Darius Molark
de gustibus non est disputandum
01:01 AM on 06/14/2012
Excellent. We must be vigilant and keep President Obama from becoming a one-term Hollywood President. He needs to put some fire in his and do what is right. Sure, the profiteers and speculators are making over good, private industry okay our president says and he is correct. Now the misbegotten wealth must be excised from the thieves to really liquidate home value for the people so the same people can live.
RealistBC
Micro-bios must pass muster.
10:27 PM on 05/27/2012
The second-biggest failure of Obama's after not putting Americans back to work instead of sending even more jobs to Korea, Panama and Colombia.If Romney wasn't clearly worse, Obama would be looking for a sinecure.
09:41 PM on 05/27/2012
The borrower got to keep 100% of any growth in house value even where the lender provided almost all the money - the flipside of that agreement is the borrower eats any decline in house value before the lender takes any losses. The financial circumstances of some people who are now underwater are unchanged. They were capable of making their payments when they took out the mortgage and are equally capable now. Why should the lender take the losses where the borrower is capable of making the payments that they contracted to pay? Some lender losses are insured against default - if they agree to forgive outstanding debt; then the borrower is not in default and the insurance will not compensate them for their losses.
photo
AlfredE69
Liberty Lovin' Tree Hugger
01:51 PM on 05/27/2012
What's next: the government helping those who owe more on their cars or college degrees than they are worth?
photo
lcr999
scientist
12:16 PM on 05/27/2012
You are conflating two different issues, actually three. Mortgage fraud, foreclosures, and being underwater. They are different.

Everybody's homes have lost value in the last 4 years. Even those who own them outright. The fact that you have a loan and that now the house is less than the loan is pretty much irrelevant. It is an investment. It went down. Get over it. My facebook stock went down too. It is not the government;s job to fix that. Sorry, no one forced people to pay inflated prices for houses. Here in upstate NY the bubble was pretty small, there has not been massive devaluation. Because people didn't over pay. The fact that the worst is located in a few cities (LV, atlanta, california) shows that it was a local feeding frenzy. Sorry, not my fault, not the bank's fault, and not the governement's fault either.

The housing crisis will fix itself when the jobs crisis is fixed. Attempting to fix it is just taking money from those who made good decisions and giving it to those who made bad.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ruolivert
03:39 PM on 05/27/2012
Unfortunatly much of this is the governments faulth through the encouragement of howeowneship to the citizens and the loose monetary policy they engaged in that allowed the banks to give loans to everyone that asked, whiched inflated the housing bubble. Its a fair argument to say that the government has a responsibility to help fix it; its naive and divisive, however, to actually believe that they can fix it.
photo
lcr999
scientist
08:09 PM on 05/28/2012
The government encourages you to do a lot of things, that does not make it a sound decision.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
IndyFem
11:58 AM on 05/27/2012
Banks do NOT want to reset mortgages.....because that would mean that they have to "keep" these loans....and have to settle for their profits dribbling in on a monthly basis for years. They want the CASH NOW plain and simple. Cash that they can invest in anything...knowing that the Tax payers will bail them out if they squander it all.
09:26 PM on 05/26/2012
He spoke about it in a speech, and now you are demanding action too. What kind Obama supporter are you??
11:29 AM on 05/26/2012
Lot of Republicans want to cover their tails by blaming homeowners for taking out mortgages they couldn't afford, or more likely, didn't understand. That's human nature and in no way excuses the predatory and often illegal actions of bankers. This is one of the biggest disappointments of this administration... failure to pursue criminal charges against illegal activity, such as robo-signing. It has been reported that some banks are STILL actively involved in robo-signing. Why has this practice not been rooted out and the bank officers who continue to authorize it been arrested?
12:33 AM on 05/26/2012
Wow. Great article. Thanks so much.

3 excellent points; Now here's a follow up...

Number one, Take the FINDINGS FROM THIS INVESTIGATION, and DO SOMETHING WITH IT!!
In a serious light of extreme prejudice against failure as option, a balance of re-action to the action that has caused the damage needs to be decided on, brought to light, and EXECUTED. No apologies, the chips to fall WHERE THEY MAY!! Just do it! Tell the banks, "Get ready for jail time for what you did, OR be prepared to take the cut.

Number Two... Before firing him... Answer the question that keeps Demarco doing what he's doing, which is, "If we re-set the motgages, who will pay the banks??" The reason he states, which incites the definite pause is, it would be the TAXPAYER !!!!!!!
Hold it right there!! Stop even FOLLOWING that line of thinking!! Stand up to the banks!! Tell them your value is gone on this, SORRY!! Give a tax incentive or something which helps them to make it up over time, while the Homeowners are also given time to heal from these gaping wounds!!! Then resetting the mortgages becomes much more into view!!


Number Three!!! Explain what benefits to resetting mortgages WOULD LOOK LIKE!!!
Do studies, EASILY done without wasting much money or time, and LET PEOPLE PICTURE IT!! It deserves to be a VISION SHARED!!!! It's a lot easier for people to get moving when they KNOW WHERE THEY'RE GOING!!!
12:13 AM on 05/26/2012
What Obama can do is fire the guy who's standing in the way of recovery - Ed DeMarco. Resetting mortgages works. Many lenders are now doing it because it works - they lose less money, the borrower loses less money, the economy stabilizes and your property values stop going down. We got no such good deal when we gave the banks a ish-ton of our money - the only people who benefited from that were the big bank execs.
The psychology behind this is fascinating to me. This is a clear, rational, economically sound policy, but people are so freaked out that somewhere, at some point, it's possible that SOMEONE IS GETTING AWAY WITH SOMETHING (unless they're on Wall Street then, hey, what are you going to do?) that they are - a lot of YOU are - willing to let the economy continue to go down the tubes and let communities and families fall apart. Wow.

The right has done such a good job of brainwashing people. Personal responsibility must be paramount for all you little people! Gag.
08:24 PM on 05/25/2012
So if I get this right you want the President to get every body out of the housing misery they are in. How exactly do you suppose he does this? Everyone knows Wall Street is back on their feet. What now? Come up with some proposals that make sense instead of laying it out as if all of this is caused by the man in the White House. Resetting mortgages should come from the banks who hold the paper. I do not see them jumping to get into the fray. This is an election year in case you have not noticed. I am sure the President would like to put a chicken in every pot and a Ford in every garage. He also likes to get rid of pesky commentators who make impossible demands just to cloud the picture.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
dadw5boys
Disabled Vietnam Vet
11:26 PM on 05/25/2012
yes if President Obama could get in the Ultra Secret Time Machine and go back before they were telling Americans to become part of the Ownership Society. To use the $1,000 tax rebate Bush used to stimulted the Economy to make buy a home with a Sub Prime Loan.
If President Obama could stop the Republicans from changing the laws pushing Fannie and Freddie to begin handling Non Conforming Loans then the only people stuck with bad mortage would have been the Banks and Finance Companys.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:57 PM on 05/25/2012
If you're gonna complain when your investment loses value, you must give away any profit you make from an investment.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
dadw5boys
Disabled Vietnam Vet
11:33 PM on 05/25/2012
thank you , we get so few people willing to say that today a House is only an Investment .
We no longer buy homes seeking to have a home in America .
It is just like a paper stock ! A House's only real value is what someone will pay you for it.
No real way to fix a price.
photo
4eva
.-.. --- ...- . --..-- / -. --- - / .... .- - .
07:48 PM on 05/25/2012
Nearly everyone has lost 'value' in their homes.
Why should so-called 'underwater' mortgageholders get special consideration?
Lots of people who are not underwater still have lost jobs, had their income reduced, had other financial or health setbacks ... why all the special fuss over 'underwater' mortgage holders?

It was a bubble.
It burst.
We are all affected by it
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert SF
11:06 PM on 05/25/2012
That's why everyone should be outraged. I mean, look at what happened. The "housing mess" was a deliberate transfer of wealth from the middle-class to the 1%. So why the complacency?
photo
4eva
.-.. --- ...- . --..-- / -. --- - / .... .- - .
11:26 PM on 05/25/2012
I don't know that there is complacency.

People were perfectly fine with bubble economics when prices were on the way up, and naturally they are upset when they lose perceived value (even if that value was bubble value).

The problem is with bubbles and investing in a bubble economy. Lots of peoplel are going to get burned. Naturally people left holding the bag are going to yelp and complain ... but is this really helpful?

Wouldn't it be more helpful to learn about bubbles and their pitfalls?
photo
lcr999
scientist
12:08 PM on 05/27/2012
No , it was a transfer of wealth from people who bought property in the early 2000s to people who sold property in the early 2000s. What to know where your money went---it went to the guy you bought your house from. Probably the equivalent of your parents.
07:26 PM on 05/25/2012
Bank of America mortgage holders: Be sure to read ALL of your mail if you are underwater. There is a program at work there where a significant amount of your homeowner debt is being forgiven. Essentially, the forgiven amount will relieve you of the "negative equity" that resulted from your home losing value. Look sharp! There are programs available!!!