iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Travis Reed

GET UPDATES FROM Travis Reed
 

Stanley Hauerwas: Hauerwas On Healthcare (VIDEO)

Posted: 07/13/2012 7:18 am

"Medicine can't get us out of life alive." --Stanley Hauerwas

is there something in between a business person or the government making the medical decisions
in our lives? Something more radical? Stanley Hauerwas, one of America's most respected theologians, says the answer to the healthcare crisis is, "to teach people how to die." Our culture tends to ignore death. At the very least, we make wild attempts to distract ourselves from it for as long as possible. Are we just living "lives of quiet, desperate atheism," as Hauerwas suggests?

Watch more films with Stanley and check out his books at TWOTP.

 

Follow Travis Reed on Twitter: www.twitter.com/travisreed

FOLLOW RELIGION
"Medicine can't get us out of life alive." --Stanley Hauerwas is there something in between a business person or the government making the medical decisions in our lives? Something more radical? Stan...
"Medicine can't get us out of life alive." --Stanley Hauerwas is there something in between a business person or the government making the medical decisions in our lives? Something more radical? Stan...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 83
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
Erdgeist
per omnia extrema
10:20 PM on 07/20/2012
Death is not the end. It is hard for secularists to grasp this—even religious secularists who tend to be Western Buddhists. But research done at the University of Virginia demonstrates that we are greater than the sum total of our anatomical parts. Where this leads to is the fact that the physical sciences can only explain so much. They certainly can't explain the 'first person' whom we are all too familiar with. They can even explain what is beyond the Planck length although Max Planck did. It was a spiritual (Geist) matrix (Urgrund).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jdl51
12:53 PM on 07/22/2012
Whatever makes you happy. There is no evidence of an afterlife, other than in your mind. Not saying there isn't one, but there is zero observable, quantifiable, measurable evidence of such. Just because you can imagine something doesn't make it so.
photo
Erdgeist
per omnia extrema
01:30 PM on 07/23/2012
Want to make a million bucks? Check out this site.

"One million dollars is offered to any skeptic who can rebut the evidence for the existence of the afterlife - see paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 hereinafter."

http://www.victorzammit.com/skeptics/challenge.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edander
Mary Full of GRACE the Lord is with You
06:56 AM on 07/20/2012
What is so sad is that a good majority of people are scared to die because society has conditioned us into thinking that the holy words of God are untrue. The promise of an afterlife given to us by Jesus Christs sacrifice should help us welcome death instead of fearing it. There has been thousands of NDE's where people have died and crossed over and felt what heaven is like with joy, happiness and love. Children who died have come back speaking about angels and meeting Jesus with the ultimate feelings of love surrounding him. Scientists talk this off as just our brains playing tricks on us as a way of comforting us before we go from life to nonexistance. I find this hard to beleive though because if life ended after earth then what reason were we created? Other people have spoken about NDE's and going to hell where souls are lost in the dark miserable because they are awa from God. Science serves a purpose for satan since it tries to make us believe there is no God and no afterlife. This also helps the leaders of the world who control us through fear which is another part of satans doing. God has put us here to follow his words n live in harmony with eachother. Again satan and his children are the one's who are corrupting God's plan for us. But rest assured its only for a short time before he is thrown back in the abyss.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edander
Mary Full of GRACE the Lord is with You
06:38 AM on 07/20/2012
I BELIEVE in one God, the Father Almighty,
Maker of heaven and earth,
and of all things visible and invisible.
And in one Lord Jesus Christ,
the only begotten Son of God.
Born of the Father before all ages.
God of God
Light of Light;
True God of True God
Begotten not made; of one being with
the FATHER; by Whom all things were made
who for us men, and for our salvation,
came down to Heaven
And was made Flesh by the HOLY GHOST
of the Virgin MARY: AND WAS MADE MAN.
He was also crucified for us, suffered under Pontious
Pilate and was buried.
And on the third day he rose again according
to the Scriptures. And ascending into Heaven,
He sitteth at the right hand of the Father.
And He shall come again in glory to judge
the living and the dead; and of
His kingdom there shall be no end.
And I believe in the Holy Ghost, Lord and Giver
of Life Who proceeds from the Father and the Son.
Who together with the Father and the Son is no less adored and glorified:
Who spoke by the Prophets. And I believe in One, Holy, Catholic and
Apostolic Church. I confess one Baptism for the remission of sins.
And I look for the resurrection of the dead
And the Life of the world to come . AMEN
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
sophie M
ANTI WAR./animal rescue
02:50 PM on 07/17/2012
i was brought back to life at age 29.
i do not fear death at all.
i remember my last breath, .. i said in my mind: why is this happening ...please let me die. .
(and i woke up in a hospital room).
11:20 AM on 07/17/2012
I once read a Hospice nurse wrote that in her experience Christian hospice patients had a much harder time dealing with the end than the atheist patients she had. What does that say? I believe that atheists
know that the end is the end but Christians really aren't sure.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edander
Mary Full of GRACE the Lord is with You
06:09 AM on 07/20/2012
Christians should be sure since they have faith in Christ whos suffered died and resurrected in order to give back to humanity another chance of living eternally with him. The only thing they should hope is that they led a good Christian life as Jesus instructed us too and if not then to repent sincerly for everything they know they did wrong. God will forgive if you sincerly want forgiveness; he has deep love for all of us and wants us to share the next life with him.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jdl51
12:56 PM on 07/22/2012
If God loves us so much, why did he create suffering and evil?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Yorksgal
Violence doesn't end violence, it extends it.
09:59 PM on 07/16/2012
The hospice movement has always advocated dying with dignity and allowing those that are dying a say in their end of life moments.

As for me - I am a Spiritualist - while I readily admit I am afraid of the way I will die, I am not afraid of death.

I believe:

Declaration of Principles
These principles are neither dogma nor creed but a set of guidelines:

1. We believe in Infinite Intelligence.

2. We believe that the phenomena of nature, both physical and spiritual are the
expression of Infinite Intelligence.

3. We affirm that a correct understanding of such expression and living in
accordance therewith constitute true religion.

4. We affirm that the existence and personal identity of the individual continue after
the change called death.

5. We affirm that communication with the so-called dead is a fact, scientifically
proven by the phenomena of Spiritualism.

6. We believe that the highest morality is contained in the Golden Rule: "Do unto
others as you would have them do unto you."

7. We affirm the moral responsibility of individuals and that we make our own
happiness or unhappiness as we obey or disobey Nature's physical and spiritual
laws.

8. We affirm that the doorway to reformation is never closed against any soul here
or hereafter.

9. We affirm that the precepts of Prophecy and Healing are Divine attributes
proven through Mediumship.
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
05:34 PM on 07/17/2012
Fanned, Yorksgal. That is an impressive post.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
SamBaby
Life is Sweet!
04:01 PM on 07/20/2012
Thank you for sharing. Your description of your beliefs sound like those of my Sweet Mother-in-Law.
05:54 PM on 07/16/2012
Galatians 2:20
My old self has been crucified with Christ. It is no longer I who live, but Christ lives in me. So I live in this earthly body by trusting in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tjboyo
Not taking bullshit from either extremes
12:42 PM on 07/16/2012
It may just be me, but I'm seeing more doctors look in this direction for end of life care. There's just a point when medicine won't work and it's time to go. Let's go with comfort and dignity.
06:04 PM on 07/15/2012
The biological entity wants to live forever, the human graft may get tired after a century or two. Irrespective of belief, some people are more comfortable with the thought of dying as it approaches, others go through the process kicking and screaming. It is difficult to tell before coming face to face with it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Debra Martinez
Who is your God...
02:39 PM on 07/15/2012
I'm not afraid of death...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Yorksgal
Violence doesn't end violence, it extends it.
09:49 PM on 07/16/2012
It's not death that is the problem - it is the bit just before you die that I am worried about.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Debra Martinez
Who is your God...
07:37 PM on 07/17/2012
Why should i be scared of death. I know I wont have to suffer where I am going...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sistagirl Young
12:10 PM on 07/15/2012
We all have different perceptions as to what occurs at death. I believe the soul/Spirit leaves the "container" it resided in. For believers we look forward to being in the presence of The LORD. Now, I know there are those who laugh and say this is a myth and even less kind things. So be it. Just for the sake of discourse, suppose you're right? There is no heaven and The WORD is not true? Well, I've not lost anything by beleiving and trying to live a life in acccordance with The WORD. It's made me happy, and I like to think I may have brought some happiness to others as well.
But suppose it "is" true. Whether one beleives or not "all" will "know"...one day. If I'm in error. I prefer to err on the side of The WORD. Life.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Just My Thoughts 2011
Life's but a walking shadow
03:33 PM on 07/15/2012
Very well said.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sistagirl Young
06:58 PM on 07/15/2012
Hello Just My Thoughts2011; To HIM be the glory. Life.
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
03:15 PM on 07/16/2012
I'm not sure that one has to be a believer in some religion in order to expect a continuation of life after death. There are at least 2,500 convincing stories of reincarnation in a study done by the University of Virginia. About 8% of all Americans have had near death experiences (NDE). Information can never disappear from the universe; even Hawking now admits that.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sistagirl Young
05:24 PM on 07/16/2012
Hello phal4875; I have to admit there are possibilities to all you say. I only know of one whom I believe rose from the dead, ascended to heaven, and promised to return. I cannot speak for thers; but I look forward to HIS return. Provided, of course, I'm still around. Thank you for sharing. Life.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sistagirl Young
11:51 AM on 07/15/2012
I used to fear death. Why? I suppose it was the 'finality" of it that created my distress. Yet as I became more knowledgeable in The WORD, I came to view the beauty of it. "Therefore we are always confident, knowing that, whilst we are at home in the body, we are absent from The LORD:
(For we walk by faith, not by sight:)
We are confident, I say, and willing rather to be absent from the body, and to be present with The LORD." ll Corinthians 5:6-8.
This is my belief. Obviously. How sad for those who have nothing to look forward to. For those who do not believe...there is more to death than what they believe. I know some will find this humorous. Yet The LORD has a way of making a believer out of folk. Whether y'all beleive it or not. But as I said. this is my belief. Life/
SelfAwarePatterns
seek truth; question everything
05:21 PM on 07/14/2012
A very good posting. I'm a non-believer and I'll admit that, as a descendent of millions of years of creatures with a strong survival instinct, I do have a natural fear of death. However, I console myself with the knowledge that death is simply an end to consciousness. I wasn't conscious before I was born. I'm not conscious when I fall asleep. Subjectively, death will simply be returning to that state I came from and visited every night.

"Are we just living "lives of quiet, desperate atheism," as Hauerwas suggests?"

I think this is true for many "believers", otherwise they wouldn't experience the searing grief all of us have when a loved one dies, or the intense fear of death that leads to such costly treatments at the end of life. When you admit non-belief, at least to yourself, it forces you to come to terms with death and, I think, approach it and life in a more prepared, serene, and non-desperate, manner.
photo
Wayne Conner
God is just pretend.
04:37 AM on 07/15/2012
Don't you find it very insulting when people make those statements about non-believers? I still enjoy receiving gifts during the holidays even though I no longer believe that they are delivered by an obese man in a red and white suit. Likewise, I still enjoy my life and find meaning in it even though I no longer believe that there is an invisible man looking over my shoulder judging me all day long. Being an atheist doesn't mean your life is all that much different from anyone else's, you just get to sleep in on Sunday.
SelfAwarePatterns
seek truth; question everything
10:01 AM on 07/15/2012
I agree completely. When someone equates non-belief with bitterness or unhappiness, they're either projecting their own fears on us or just being dishonest. I'm giving Hauerwas the benefit of the doubt and assuming he was projecting.

My point was that the "quiet desperate atheism" he describes really applies to people who don't truly believe, but nevertheless desperately cling to religious rituals in the forlorn hope of receiving some comfort. I think they'd be a lot better off if they accepted their non-belief and thought through the implications, which are far easier to live with than they fear.

Overall, I said it was a good posting because it might get people to contemplate how much continued life is really worth to them. I don't think I'd want an extra month of life if it was only filled with pain and misery, and given how expensive such months tend to be, it's good to have people think about it.
09:26 AM on 07/15/2012
I don't know if the last part of your post is true though I agree with the first. I usually think about when I was under general anesthesia during surgery. It seemed to me just a fraction of a second. The only difference is that after death I will not wake up. After I again become non-existent and a tragedy strikes the earth or humanity, I will be totally unconcerned.
I think your last sentence is too bold. We all go through the same stages of death no matter our religion or non-religion. Consciously and unconsciously our bodies strive and struggle to survive. There is no dignity in the dying process. If you have seen it, you very well know this to be true. I am an advocate of euthanasia. I would rather if faced with a terminal illness have the choice to die when I want instead of the long drawn out suffering and degradation. I would call in my family and talk with each one. Tell them I loved them and to live their lives to the best of their abilities then send them home. Call the funeral home and tell them the front door was open and which room I was in then go take my pills and lay down to die on my terms. Now that is dignity.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
arachne646
No more hurting people--Peace
01:38 PM on 07/15/2012
You can't get those pills now. At least, as far as I know, Oregon, and I think a few other states back east are the only places that physicians can assist you at the end of your life, even with advice and a prescription, to kill yourself easily, and surely. I'm a Christian, and in the medical field, and it's not as easy as one might think to just swallow an overdose and not just wake up after a long time unconscious, or to be alive with some impairment worse off than before. None of us really knows what happens after death, and of course I'm concerned with that "slippery slope" argument "once euthanasia with consent is legal, we'll be knocking off the unconsenting disabled left, right and centre". There are, however, people whose pain cannot be controlled without sedating them so much they can't stand it, dying people who have non-pain symptoms like shortness of breath that are unendurable, and people who just don't want to live as their dementia advances, or while they live for years frozen in a body that can't communicate. Right now, the legal burden is on their loved ones, who know that they're the only ones who are able to act for the patient, but their risk of criminal prosecution is great. I hope that assisted suicide by doctors is legalized in Canada, as courts and Canadians agree, but our Consevative government's right wing religion won't allow them to let it go through.
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
03:17 PM on 07/16/2012
There is pretty good evidence that one's consciousness can separate from a person's body. If it can do so temporarily, why not longer?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
samearl
What is truth?
02:29 AM on 07/14/2012
Maybe I missed something here. I'm an unbeliever and I can honestly say though I don't relish death I'm not afraid of it. What I am afraid of is getting sick and leaving my wife bankrupt or my daughter with not enough money to get her through college. I think dying with dignity is important and I'll will not spend a great deal of money on trying to stay alive when the time comes. It wouldn't really matter if I had insurance or not.

I, like others commenting, have no idea what "lives of quiet, desperate atheism" is and I don't really like the sound of that.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Redv14
Evolve Beyond Belief
06:11 AM on 07/14/2012
I'm an atheist and don't fear death either. I was a skeptic long before I became an atheist . During that time I didn't really know what I thought about death. Now that I am an atheist and have spent a lot of time thinking about it, death just means I won't exist any more.
photo
ZenSufi
Sisters and Brothers of America!
05:34 PM on 07/17/2012
This is a curious phrase: "I won't exist any more." The elements of your body will exist; do you mean to say that your thoughts and feelings will cease to exist?
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
05:43 PM on 07/17/2012
Why would a lifetime of learning simply disappear upon a person's death? Physics says that it can never be lost. Where does this information go? Why do some people have near death experiences that allow them to bring back information from some distance? Why does the University of Virginia have 2,500 strong cases of reincarnation?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:13 AM on 07/14/2012
For what it's worth, I think Hauerwas is speaking to church crowds. And he's not talking about real atheists, he's talking about religious people who are "practical atheists." They do not live their lives informed by their own theology.

This doesn't need to be heard as a slam on real atheists or agnostics who may have their own reasons and ways of facing death with dignity and a minimum of costly technology. But for Christians, prolonging the inevitable seems to indicate a failure to grasp their own theology.
05:08 PM on 07/13/2012
I think Hauerwas is at his best when he speaks on this subject.

http://www.humanismandculture.com/communal-and-personal-henri-de-lubacs-catholicism/