More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Trish Kinney

Trish Kinney

Posted: January 23, 2010 12:52 PM

US Airways vs Southwest Airlines: A Clear Winner

What's Your Reaction:

It was a stormy day in the Phoenix metropolitan area and it had already been raining for a while. The city was bracing for high winds and more rain, torrential at times, with a tornado watch in place. Wouldn't you know that it also happened to be the day my husband and I were traveling to Las Vegas for a quick getaway to see a show and enjoy what has become a favorite annual ritual. We kept a close eye on the weather throughout the morning and checked in on the airport sites for reports of delays or closures. We finally decided to head to Sky Harbor and make a decision then.

When we arrived, we passed the new Southwest terminal and saw on the board that nearly all of their flights had been cancelled. Assuming the same would be true of our US Airways flight, we were surprised to see that it was showing on time. I admit it was unnerving to know that one airline was willing to take off to the same destination at the same time and the other wasn't. But we went through security and proceeded to the gate anyway.

The plane was already there and right on time, they made the first boarding announcement. My husband, who was trying to be a trooper and not a party pooper, has a real fear, maybe even in the category of terror, that they are going to put him on a plane and then not take off for some reason, leaving him trapped on the tarmac, his worst nightmare. He is Dutch, stoic, and from Iowa, not exactly the hotbed of technology. We surprised him with a Blackberry for Christmas and he had grudgingly been learning to use it. He pulled it out and said "how do you get to the internet on this thing?" I showed him how to click on the globe icon and he painstakingly pecked in a Google search, his big fingers attached to his 6'4" frame struggling to limit their strokes to a single key at a time. Then quietly he approached the gentleman from the airline who was boarding the first group of passengers. I saw him show the man his Blackberry and engage in a brief conversation. The man then stopped the boarding process, asked the passengers for their patience and headed down the jetway, locking the big metal door behind him. After a few minutes, he returned, got on the mike and announced that the Las Vegas airport was experiencing delays in landing planes and that our flight would take off an hour late. If, however, Vegas changed their status, we may leave earlier so we should stay around the gate area. It was my husband and his brand new Blackberry who had informed US Airways of the delay in Vegas, causing boarding to come to a halt. With the combination of Southwest canceling their flights and US Airways apparently neglecting to check with the destination airport for weather status, our confidence was waning in a big hurry.

In the meantime, our grown sons each called to ask if we were going to get out. When I told them the nearly unbelievable story of their dad stirring it up with US Airways, one of them said "hey, look at Dad using his Blackberry" and the other said "I have never been more proud of a man in my life!"

Then the announcer came back to say that when the boarding resumed, the crew had already informed him that there would be no service during the one hour flight due to expected turbulence.

A few minutes later, he got back on the mike to tell us that he was certain we were probably aware that many of the other airlines had already canceled their flights and there was always the possibility that the airport would close followed by a big shrug of his shoulders and no definitive conclusion. It seemed that US Airways just couldn't make up their mind and was kinda sorta leaving the decision to us. We turned around and walked away.

Out of curiosity, we tracked the flight well into the evening. It left the gate two hours late and another two hours later was still in "delay" status and not in the air. It finally arrived in Vegas six hours late as we sat in front of a roaring fire at home listening to the rain fall as my husband declared for the first time ever that he could see how that Blackberry could come in handy in certain situations.

As for me, I think I will book my next flight using accumulated Dividend Miles and then start flying Southwest Airlines. I really respect their decision to cancel those flights and besides, you gotta love those cool ads with the ground crew rapping about bags flying free. US Airways could learn a thing or two about a lot of things from their closest competitor.

 
 
 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:19 PM on 01/26/2010
I was flying that day, on a USAirways Airbus. The wind was incredibly strong and gusting, often above the crosswind limit of the aircraft. Conditions were changing with wind speed going above and then below the limit and windshear on the approaches causing go-arounds. We were told Southwest had an engine nacelle strike and that finished off the day for them. I have no official confirmation of that however. The bottom line is that these are the days that airline pilots really earn their money. Not only landing or taking off at the maximum limit for the aircraft, but making the tough decisions to go around and proceed to their alternate airport, delay a departure, or cancel the flight(with dispatcher concurrance) Your clear winner title makes no sense. USairways or their pilots never compromised safety. Conditions were rough, and wind components did go above the limits for some aircraft quite a bit of the time, but saefty was put ahead of everything else, witness the various delayed and/or cancelled flights
11:18 AM on 01/26/2010
I’ve been following stories on Airline hubris and mismanagement. Airline delays are one of the many issues that need some major industry overhaul, loosing passengers’ personal items is another. It seems to relate to a story I read on Chris Elliot’s blog about Airline staff stealing a carryon bag, if it’s out of your sight any of your belongings may be forfeit.
http://www.elliott.org/blog/this-is-the-most-bizarre-action-i-have-ever-known-an-airline-to-take/
Also, there is a dramatized version of this story on youtube I found that is funny and cute.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1oR7C_VkaUE
08:31 PM on 01/24/2010
RE:AIRJER- I would say that aircraft aborting landing could be clasified as a "safety issue" for crosswinds and winshear. I have no beef with US Airways but I do think Southwest made the right decision.
03:30 PM on 01/24/2010
The crosswinds that Thursday exceeded the forecast in PHX and all over the west. All the airports in the SW US had reduced landing capacity. Many planes were aborting landings due to either crosswinds or windshear. So ATC imposed arrival limits on all the airports. They would only allow so many aircraft to be in the air going to these airports at the same time. This is so the controllers don't get overloaded. On days like that, they DO get overloaded. But they also do a fantastic job too!

The ATC delays were changing fast. Your husband and his blackberry got the word about the delay probably about the same time the crew did from our ops center in Pittsburgh. These days, that is not uncommon.

That Thursday really wreaked havoc with SW schedule. They run a point to point operation. US Airways runs a hub and spoke. SW had so many crews and planes "out of place" with the problem getting worse, they decided to shut down. Essentially, they "rebooted" their system. That gave their aircraft planners and crew schedulers time to figure out who and what was going where to get back on schedule. US Airways chose to ride out the storm so to speak. While many flights were up to 6 hours late, like your LAS flight, we ended up completing a higher percentage of flights than SW did. SW made an operational decision, as did US Airways.

It really had NOTHING to do with safety.
03:21 PM on 01/24/2010
I am a US Airways Captain based in PHX. I would like to add a little insight into what happened. Keep in mind I have spoken to several friends who are both US Airways and SW pilots. I was stuck waiting in SFO.

It was the worst winter storm I have seen in 23 years of flying out of PHX. The great thing about PHX t is the precipitaion doesn't freeze, like it does in Chicago, NY, etc. When a storm involves freezing precipitaion, those are the days that are the biggest challenges to airline operations. Thunderstorm days run a close second. The challenge this past week when you flew was the wind, specifically crosswinds.

The winds were very strong and at times well off the runway heading. The Airbus that US Airways uses for most of their service in PHX has a demonstrated crosswind component of 39 knots (about 44 MPH). That means Airbus has tested the plane to the equivalent of a 90 degree direct crosswind of 39 knots. The wingletted 737 that is SW dominant plane has a lower demonstrated crosswind ability. I can tell you no airline pilot I know from ANY major US airline will try to land in a wind that exceeds the demonstrated crosswind ability of the plane they are flying. You become a test pilot. The FAA doesn't prohibit this.But if you "bend some metal" you can kiss your career good-bye!

I'm out of space so I will continue.......
09:37 PM on 01/23/2010
Well since Southwest is the number one reason that the airline industry as a whole is in the tank, and most airlines continue to cut service to many smaller airports, why don't you just go to the great do nothing wrong southwest counter and buy that International ticket or the one you used to have a flight on close to home....I say southwest with it's Do. good er attitude and deceiving advertising techniques will be back to haunt us all sooner than you think...
05:06 PM on 01/23/2010
I realize that everyone brings their own perspective. I was in Charlotte this week and experienced similar weather related delays. Realizing that US Air does not control the weather or the air traffic controllers, I was not upset that my flight actually took off five hours after its scheduled time. My perspective is that I’m glad that the airline did not cancel my flight and that I was able to return home that day, even if it was almost five hours late.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tpabob
03:06 PM on 01/23/2010
Southwest has a great presence here in Tampa which means I can fly nearly everywhere in the states non-stop or direct and pay a low fare as well.
01:40 PM on 01/23/2010
Southwest is amazing for its customer service. I try not to fly any other airline. I also firmly believe it's better to make a sound, reasonable decision-even if it's not convenient, rather than vacillate until there's no decision at all! Glad you were able to still have a cozy evening!