iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Valerie Plame Wilson

GET UPDATES FROM Valerie Plame Wilson
 

Why Is the U.S. Government Bullying an American Hero?

Posted: 09/14/2012 5:00 pm

Every day thousands of Americans working for the U.S. government spend all their waking hours keeping their fellow citizens safe. The vast majority of them work quietly -- and anonymously -- as they track our enemies, aid our allies, and seek out any and all threats to our country. And most of the men and women don't give a damn about the absurd posturing and contrived drama generated by America's political process. As I learned first-hand in 2003, there are times when the politicians bring the posturing and drama to you.

I served my country, loyally and well, as a covert CIA operations officer focused on stopping nuclear weapon proliferation until the Bush administration decided to betray my secret identity as payback for my husband questioning the White House's justification for the Iraq War. The lesson was simple: If you offer the public a true story that is at odds with what the government wants you to know, they will stop at nothing to destroy you, your reputation, and the reputations of the people around you.

In the past few weeks, we have heard riveting stories of heroism and valor from one of the U.S. soldiers who participated in the combat mission that killed Osama bin Laden. His book, written under a pseudonym (his true identity was subsequently made public by Fox News), is by most accounts devoid of any classified information. In fact, most of what is in the book had been already leaked by top officials of the U.S. government themselves. I am dismayed to read the steady stream of criticism flowing from the U.S. government aimed at the book and its author. The Defense Department and administration officials have called the author's decision to publish the book the "height of irresponsibility." Former CIA Director and current Defense Secretary Leon Panetta has even gone so far as to say, "I think we have to take steps to make clear to him and to the American people that we're not going to accept this kind of behavior."

At the same time that they threaten the author and try to "make clear" they're not going to accept an honest account of what happened in Abbottabad, Americans have also recently learned that the CIA and other U.S. government agencies have been cooperating with Hollywood figures on a movie about the same topic. In fact, according to CIA emails released recently, one writer was given a "deep dive" inside the Agency as they wrote a screenplay on the bin Laden raid. Are U.S. government officials angry that the author wrote a book, or that his book came out before their movie? This, of course, comes after the U.S. government officials have participated in and been sources for newspaper articles, magazine features and even movies -- like Act of Valor.

It is time for the public to make clear to our government that we will no longer accept their unsubstantiated or spoon-fed version as the only one of significant historical events. I don't believe that cooperating with an author or a screenwriter or even a movie producer on an authentic account of what happened in war is necessarily a bad thing, as long as no classified information is jeopardized. In fact, it has happened throughout American history and inspired many Americans to serve our country in their careers -- myself included. However, next time you hear an American government official attacking the author of No Easy Day -- stop and ask yourself why they are trying to bully an American hero. I just wish the officials making these threats would do the same. Our government has survived as long as it has because there are those prepared to hold it to account for its words and deeds. It's the essence of our democracy.

 
 
 
FOLLOW POLITICS
Every day thousands of Americans working for the U.S. government spend all their waking hours keeping their fellow citizens safe. The vast majority of them work quietly -- and anonymously -- as they t...
Every day thousands of Americans working for the U.S. government spend all their waking hours keeping their fellow citizens safe. The vast majority of them work quietly -- and anonymously -- as they t...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,575
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (37 total)
12:57 PM on 10/29/2012
I am currently reading Ms. Wilson's "mystery." It is a mystery because the publisher decided to include all the redactions as provided by the CIA--strips of black. And that spurs me to try to figure out what they are hiding. It also makes me wonder if they are hiding information we really need to know as citizens of a democracy, since they had no compunction about "outing" one of their chief operatives.

Or maybe this is simply hypocrisy and people who secretly have low self esteem and who abuse their power because it is possible to do so, and doing so tricks them into thinking they are better than they really are.

The black strips do slow down reading, especially when I try to fill in what is missing. Having a good imagination, this makes the book interactive.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:03 PM on 09/22/2012
Ms. Wilson remains one of my heroes.

Thank you for your service, and thank you for speaking out, again.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DeepThought24
NATURE, REASON, FACTS and SCIENCE...not
07:45 PM on 09/17/2012
The Pentagon, DOD, intelligence agencies and mainstream press is the biggest organized criminal syndicate in the world, all controlled by the greed of the Military Industrial Complex (MIC) and partners in crime the World Bank and IMF. They got us in Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan…all failed missions to date costing 70,000 American lives, who knows how many serious causalities, and trillions of dollars in debt…all for their power, glory, careers and greed.

The proposed 2013 defense budget to include off budget items, wars, intelligence, Homeland Security, and etc. is nearer $1.2 trillion. THAT’S 45% OF TOTAL US REVENUE OF $2.7 TRILLION! This is morally criminal and treason since it’s destroying the country economically. Investment in technology and the economy trumps everything. Five years after WWII the whole war could have been won with one US aircraft carrier.

This American War Machine is a crime against humanity and especially the American taxpayer as the Soviet Union war machine was to the Soviet Union:
tomdispatch.com/archive/175361/

We (US) are a ‘garrison state’ and destroying the very qualities and virtues and principles we originally set about to save.”

I was a patriot when I went to Vietnam and a patriot when I returned and protested and demonstrated against the war, Military Industrial Complex, the Pentagon and Johnson.

-USN/USMC First Marine Division, I-Corps, Vietnam, 1967-68
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:05 PM on 09/22/2012
Pres. Johnson left office in Jan. 2009.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mrs young
Benghazi.......answers please..
07:29 PM on 09/17/2012
So who did a spread in "Vanity Fair ?
04:32 PM on 09/17/2012
He signed a non-disclosure agreement, he then went behind the Pentagon's back and is attempting to cash in. End of story.
01:43 PM on 09/17/2012
Heroes should not be chest pounders tell your story and leave your version of the politics out of the story
01:08 PM on 09/17/2012
Valerie Plame should know better than most what happens when you get outted. This stupid man put himself and his fellow Seals in danger by putting out this book. Why was it necessary to write the book now? It must have been extremely easy to get around his alias since the stupid folks at Fox managed to out him in just a few hours. Now his life is in danger for his folly. Personally, I think the Administration is right to admonish him. He signed an agreement and didn't have his book vetted like every other person who's written a book about the govermnent. I don't need to know the details. I don't care about them. We are free of Bin Laden and that's what counts. But this guy is now going to have to look over his shoulder for the rest of his life because the terrorists never forget or give up. Ms. Plame should be happy the government is actually taking steps to make sure classified information issn't be deciminated without their knowing it. The Bush Adiminstration barely gave her or her safety or the safety of her contacts when they outted her as a CIA agent. Some things are meant to be a secret. I can live with that.
02:40 PM on 09/17/2012
These childish games must come to an end otherwise we will all suffer the consequences.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
louisediane33
09:59 AM on 09/17/2012
If you believe this article is all about the question "why they are trying to bully an American hero" then we have all reduced our standards of what an "American hero" truly is. The author of the book is not a "hero". He was employed by the U.S. Government, trained by the U.S. Government, and is merely a tool of the U.S. Government- aka a tool of the American people. He, and several others by the way, did the job that they were EMPLOYED for and compensated to do. His being chosen for the mission is not heroic- it was his job and he was heavily supported by the greatest military on earth. His writing a book and making millions from it is simply not heroic in any sense of any one's imagination.

What defines someone as an "American hero" should be the question that people ask themselves. The dictionary defines hero as "a person, typically a man, who is admired or idealized for courage, outstanding achievements, or noble qualities". How does the writer of this book fall into this category? He did did his job admirably, but not heroically. He did the same as every other man on that mission and at the direction of his commanding officers. He was paid by the American people and now he is going to benefit again and again and again. Personally, having served this great country myself- for pay- I find his actions since the killing of Osama disgusting.
11:33 AM on 09/17/2012
Your post is a slap in the face to every soldier who has ever served our country (yourself included), as well as every soldier who has died for our freedoms. All soldiers "do the job they were employed to do" - if that's how you want to classify it - but the level to which they sacrifice family and their own lives is exponentially deeper. Perhaps you only joined for the paycheck, as you state - but how dare you put every soldier in that category, including the author of this book. What part of the epilogue didn't you understand?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
louisediane33
12:00 PM on 09/17/2012
Perhaps you would have an argument and I would feel duly chastised IF the writer donated all of his money to the military (other soldiers that have made the choice to "sacrifice family and their own lives") but he hasn't and he won't. He took his pay for his job, just like I and every other military personnel, but this guy exploited the opportunity provided to him at the hands of the American people's military and he will profit from it to the tune of MILLIONS of dollars. He is not, nor ever will be considered any kind of hero.

I get that we need to have our heroes, but this guy is not one. As for the epilogue, I would not buy this guys book. I have already paid, trained, and thanked him for his service. I would not pay him one cent more for doing his job.
04:31 PM on 09/17/2012
I'm sorry, I wasn't aware that this guy wasn't paid.

This guy is seeking to cash in, and he broke the normal chain of events of having the Pentagon clear materials such as this.

If he cared or was a "Hero" then why won't he participate in the military way of going about getting a book published?
12:07 PM on 09/17/2012
you were Rear Echelon I bet
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
louisediane33
05:06 PM on 09/17/2012
I am a retired 45 year old woman- what you are suggesting would never happen.
09:05 AM on 09/17/2012
Well said.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jerry Frey
unCommon sense for the common good
01:12 AM on 09/17/2012
Valerie Plame Wilson, still a looker; Cheney, Rove, Scooter, still trash.
photo
Unca Wiggilie
I am but a meager bookworm...
11:32 PM on 09/16/2012
I support this valiant Hero's right to write whatever he so desires, as it was his butt on the line
and it is those of his fine being who make Our Country safe and strong!
Whether or not I agree with him is not relevant...
Our government has survived as long as it has because there are always those who step forward prepared to lay their lives on the line to defend it, be it right or wrong! (Yourself included)
01:03 AM on 09/17/2012
Well said!
11:23 PM on 09/16/2012
Feds are most likely upset because they didn't control the flow of information in this case. Guys in Special Ops sign a non-disclosure agreement that is pretty ironclad. For him to break that agreement and publish the book the government feels he crossed the line they had drawn a long time ago. As far as the movie goes, the government is able to control what information the producers get, review the script, and likely review and sign off on a rough edit of the movie to make sure that the Feds and US Armed Forces are portrayed in a good light.
01:45 AM on 09/17/2012
Exactly.
10:57 PM on 09/16/2012
http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2012/sep/16/details-of-bin-laden-raid-leaked-first-by-aides/?page=1

Check out this new article! Looks like there is a NEW book coming out 3 weeks before the election on Bin Laden!!! (One that McRaven and Obama sat down and provided interviews for.) Hmmmm... this ALL makes perfect sense now!!!
09:54 PM on 09/16/2012
Mrs. Wilson, I'm sorry to tell you that you can't have it both ways. You can't be on the side of supporting government to have the unilateral power to withold and and all of its shadow activities from public scrutiny visa vi NDAA, executive privalege, spy acts, immunity from prosecution of corporations giving personal information, ability to kill u.s citizens without trial or proof of probable cause, indefinite detention, etcs, AND be on the side of smaller government activists who don't want a government with that level of intrusive, malicious and coercive authority. A democracy means just that. The people must know what the gov is up to, AT SOME POINT, in order to determine in an informed manner if the gov they have elected is doing the job that best represents the constituents. The gov had its chance to release the ENTIRETY of the bin laden raid that was streamed into the whitehouse. They could have redacted (names and such) from the audio while showing the engagement, and all the other events that ensued, but they chose not to and open themselves up to scrutiny from the informed electorate. They wouldn't even release photos of a dead osama bin laden. Why i wonder? Would it have been evidence that the raid was an assassination of an unarmed man and that the shots that killed him were deliberate with no intent to take him captive to avoid a political fiasco and court drama?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ystorm
dumb people make me angry.
07:49 AM on 09/17/2012
Yeah but look at the bell curve. The majority of people unfortunately fall into the 'average' intelligence. They don't understand much, and are prone to panic over the dumbest things. There is a time and place for 'everyone to know' but there is also a time and place when they do not need to know. How many people outside of the posters here (and indeed inside as well) are actually aware of the issues, and not only that, how many can actually understand , for example, the true principles of economics (just for example) and not the spoon fed crud that the media shoves around? Not that many.. I don't think the general populace needs to know EVERYTHING all the time, particularly when a majority of them care more about the kardashacraps and snookie rather than their own lives.
11:56 AM on 09/17/2012
Unfortunately that is the same type of logic the GOV uses as basis to support and continue its policies. I fundamentally disagree with any notion that the public should not be informed.
09:39 PM on 09/16/2012
Come to think of it, other former Seals have published books with no screaming from the Govt. Dick Marcinko comes to mind