iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Van Jones

GET UPDATES FROM Van Jones
 

Super Committee Fails, but American People Win

Posted: 11/23/11 08:57 AM ET

The big buzz on cable news this week is that the Super Committee failed when it couldn't come to a compromise on how to cut the federal budget by $1.5 trillion.

But the truth is that the American people won.

And now, we must keep on winning.

We won when Democrats on the Super Committee held their ground on the expiring Bush tax cuts on the wealthy.

Instead of focusing like a laser on job creation, conservative Republicans in Congress held our nation's finances hostage in July. To appease the hostage-takers, Congress created a closed-door committee to force through major cuts this fall.

Thankfully, enough Democrats held together on the Super Committee to stop severe cuts from going through. Many proposed to seek revenue from small tax increases for the wealthy and a tiny "Wall Street Tax" on risky stock trades. But those cries from the 99% fell on the deaf ears of conservatives on the Super Committee.

Progressives don't often battle the concentrated forces of corporations and their armies of lobbyists to a stalemate. For that reason, we can stop, reflect on a job well done, and thank the congressmen and women who stopped the worst from getting through.

But we're not out of the woods yet.

The so-called economic recovery hasn't reached the vast majority of jobseekers and homeowners who have been battered by the financial collapse and its aftermath. And the bill that created the Super Committee mandated massive cuts to education, health care, environmental regulation, and job creation in 2013. So we still have some work to do.

In fact, the fights coming up are likely to be brutal. The Super Committee trigger does not identify where the domestic cuts are coming from. And conservatives are already trying to roll back the trigger's cuts to the defense budget and replace them with deeper cuts to domestic programs. So we need to keep fighting if we want to protect the EPA, science, energy research and development, home weatherization, and other vital programs.

We also need to prepare for the fact that the deficit reduction battle will continue to rage in different forms, between now and the end of 2012. Throughout the election season, the same battle about extending Bush tax cuts for the rich (and maybe all the Bush tax cuts), cutting social programs and cutting defense will continue.

There is the possibility for a good outcome. Democrats have a tremendous amount of leverage, because the Bush tax cuts will automatically expire at the end of next year and $600 billion of cuts in defense will go into effect automatically [which would be truly historic] in January 2013 if Congress does nothing.

They can do it -- if they show the courage that we saw in the past few weeks by the Occupy The Highway marchers.

A handful of activists this week walked more than 200 miles to D.C. from Occupy Wall Street's "Liberty Park." They did so to make sure that Washington heard the cries of the 99% for fair treatment.

They pointed out that many students have already mortgaged their future for their education, only to graduate off a cliff into the worst job climate since the Great Depression. Seniors and veterans have already given much to this country and deserve fair treatment in return. These groups did not cause our fiscal and financial calamities.

The culprits are Bush's tax giveaways for the rich, lax oversight of Wall Street and endless wars. Any sacrifices to solve the problem should come primarily from those who enjoyed the tax breaks, bonuses and bailouts, not those who suffered.

Coming off this victory, people of conscience in Congress should follow the example of these marchers -- and go the extra distance to find real solutions for our country.

 
 
 

Follow Van Jones on Twitter: www.twitter.com/VanJones68

The big buzz on cable news this week is that the Super Committee failed when it couldn't come to a compromise on how to cut the federal budget by $1.5 trillion. But the truth is that the American pe...
The big buzz on cable news this week is that the Super Committee failed when it couldn't come to a compromise on how to cut the federal budget by $1.5 trillion. But the truth is that the American pe...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 632
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (10 total)
08:06 PM on 11/30/2011
Van,
You'll be a thing of the past come 2012. You'll be like so last year.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
inLA
03:28 PM on 11/29/2011
Thank you, Mr. Jones.

Am a big fan -- please keep writing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blarneydude
I can handle the truth. Now let's talk about you.
02:51 PM on 11/28/2011
Nice blog.

The "failure" of the supercommittee is one of the biggest blows struck for freedom since Churchill stood off the Germans.

That was a backdoor move spurred by people who don't understand how democracy works. We pardon the brief interruption by those hellbent on the country's failure.

Back to democracy.

Occupy.
photo
florencephoenix
Sometimes I feel like a nut.Sometimes I don't
10:49 PM on 11/27/2011
So they signed a pledge that wouldn't increase the taxes on the 1% but wanted the 99% to except all the cuts to program and social services. Well now that the Super Committee that all of you wanted has failed. Let see how you benefited from them staying the course. First: That extra money that you were seeing in your pay check. Gone. Second: Those extended unemployment checks.Gone Third: All that protective gear for our soldiers. Gone. But that all right. As long as it stop the President from moving this country forward and make him look bad. But guess what it doesn't. You didn't want him involved and he gave you what you asked for. But in your hatred for him you forgot one thing. Who really was going to be effected by this. You see Norquist and Congress and the 1% aren't going to be effected by this but you are. See they are going to get the same paycheck regards of this outcome. They don't worry about unemployment they get a pension when they leave. None of their families are ever going to be on the front lines. Can you say the same? So it leaves me with one question for all of you Conservatives.Who's Waterloo is it really?
08:05 PM on 11/27/2011
Current legislation requires the stalemate will still produce 1.2 trillion in budget cuts over the next 10 years, half from defense.

Unfortunately, the author doesn't understand the scope of the federal deficit. This deficit is not from Bush or Obama, it is from Congress which passes all bills dealing with money.

We have to reduce the deficit or in the future the US will be forced to deal with matters Greece and Italy are forced to deal with today. While we are a much bigger economy, you cannot maintain a permanent deficit without lower standards of living.

All of us must have skin in the game. We have to expect and accept a smaller government, reduced or eliminated programs, etc. Even when revenue increases it should first be restricted to pay down the deficit and not to increase entitllement programs.

We have to deal with decades of poor decisions made by both parties. But, are we to pass the problem on to our children? No, we have to reduce government spending now.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blarneydude
I can handle the truth. Now let's talk about you.
02:54 PM on 11/28/2011
There is one way this will happen.

When the party running on smaller government wins, it puts its own sacred cows, OK calves, on the block first as a show of good faith that it means what it says.

Loser-pays government is how we got where we are.

Everyone-sacrifices is how families balance budgets, GOTea.
03:07 AM on 12/01/2011
Interestingly enough, you have called all the programs that need to be cut entitlement programs. It is ignorant at best, to believe that when you pay into a program and then expect it to be there for you when you need it, it is considered an entitlement. Social Security and Unemployment are not just freebees from the government. Working Americans (and some nonAmericans) are paying into these systems in every paycheck they receive. As far as other programs, I would be ashamed to live in a country that was ok with having those who have the least, do even worse so that the wealthy can become more wealthy.

No matter how you look at it, trickled down economics do NOT work. With all the Bush tax cuts, they haven't created one job. As a matter of fact, they drove us in a huge recession. The wealthy aren't creating jobs with their tax cuts, they are banking them. Look at the numbers! While the middle class is shrinking, the upper 1% isn't growing. Just those in the 1% have growing bottom lines. It is the class of people living in poverty that is growing.

Are we saying, it is ok for us to turn into a third world country where children go hungry on the street and the main cause of death is starvation? Not me!

Are we forgetting that Clinton raised taxes on the wealthy and they actually did better than they are doing even now!

Continue Below
07:13 PM on 11/27/2011
Am I correct in thinking that the majority of the public agrees that this stalemate is a victory? Is this what american politics has come to, the remnants of the new deal being bartered over behind closed doors by a "gang". Calvin Coolidge would be "lovin it"!
06:54 PM on 11/27/2011
I don't feel like I have won anything, I feel like the people in Congress that have put us on an unsustainable debt path have done nothing to change that . . .

You may view leaving Medicare as is as a victory but as a 30 year old, that only ensures that the program will not be there for someone like me.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheTightwireGuy
Attempting to balance reason and passion
05:55 PM on 11/27/2011
Well said.
05:16 PM on 11/27/2011
Wow. We're finally to the point where we're better off if congress does nothing.

Just pray they'll keep doing nothing so the Bush tax cuts -the single largest driver of the deficit- expire on schedule.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dawn2dusk
REALLY!?!
03:46 PM on 11/27/2011
now matter how you slice it...still feels like an accidental "win" to me
03:37 PM on 11/27/2011
My problem with the Republican plan is that they don't carry it to its logical end. 1) Cutting taxes creates jobs - therefore lets eliminate all taxes and create the maximum number of jobs. 2) Cutting Federal programs balances the budget - Lets cut all programs and not have a budget. 3) Privatization is best for the US lets privatize the military by turning it over to the war profiteers' - They can make not just billions but trillions. 4) Federal government cannot operate programs as well as private companies - Lets do away with Congress and no Federal programs can be created. Just think how great America would be - no new laws, no Federal enforcement agencies, no EPA, no FDA, no controls on firearms, no Federal taxes on alcohol, no Federal drug controls, no immigration department, no prisons, maybe even no America.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blarneydude
I can handle the truth. Now let's talk about you.
02:55 PM on 11/28/2011
f/f for pointing out the bankruptcy of partisan voodoo economics.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RU Mad II
Conservative Conservationist and Conversationalist
01:14 PM on 11/27/2011
Only people like Van Jones can call a do-nothing congress a success. The true shame is that the liberal base of which he caters to, will believe this bunk.
07:15 PM on 11/27/2011
Right, I forgot we almost got our government hands on your Medicare.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blarneydude
I can handle the truth. Now let's talk about you.
02:58 PM on 11/28/2011
Indeed, the liberal base agrees that the do-nothing Republicans are the problem. They ran on jobs, now they just run on and on about sex. While trying to ensure the country fails.

The supercommittee was no more legitimate than Mussolini's government. Its failure is a triumph of our democracy.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:20 PM on 11/27/2011
Until:
taxes are increased
loopholes are closed
entitlements are changed or cut
congress is held accountable
We will continue to have problems
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
jmpurser
See My micro-bio
12:55 PM on 11/27/2011
My only argument with this is you fail to define who "We" are. For the people the politicians answer to these aren't problems at all. They're either cost savings or profit centers. So there's no problem so there's no need to fix anything.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:26 PM on 11/27/2011
The politician­s no longer answer to we the people.
11:03 AM on 11/27/2011
Anyway, well whoopie. Looks like the Big Fail means we all won? I don't think so.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill Duckworth
It is a DOOZY
10:57 AM on 11/27/2011
We agree the Bush Tax Cuts are the single problem causing the Great Recession by exemplifying the Reaganomics for the last 30 years.

I do disagree there is any "Coming off this victory"."

Obama has said he will Veto Military Spending and Welfare Programs. Instead he wants to extend Payroll Tax Cuts for the Worker and throw in an equal Payroll Tax Cut for the Rich businesses. This once again could have been used as a Bargaining chip. But Obama is playing politics with republicans showing his is willing to throw the worker and SSA receipients and SSA program under the bus. For just 1 Accomplishment to put on his ACHIEVEMENT card

I'm talking about a new proposal to rob from Social Security to fund a continuing tax break for people who don't need Social Security — the wealthy.

Make no mistake: This is a bipartisan effort. It started back in December, when President Obama capitulated to the GOP on a budget. deal by cutting the payroll tax, which funds Social Security.
-Hilzik

For a measly $1000 for each worker and $billion for the rich business and stock traders the Republicans and Democrats are Bipartisan while throwing SSA under the bus. 2 Trillion SSA DEBT in just 5 years. From the fanacy of the Debt debate by the Debt Creators and No Job Creators?
11:02 AM on 11/27/2011
"We agree the Bush Tax Cuts are the single problem causing the Great Recession"

We can?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
TheBlueCoyote
Random Opinion Generator
07:01 PM on 11/27/2011
70% of debt accumulated over the 30 years can be attributed to republican administrations. So much for the party of fiscal responsibility.