iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Virginia M. Moncrieff

Virginia M. Moncrieff

Posted: December 4, 2008 10:18 PM

Burma - Another UN Failure


UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon has said he will not travel to Burma because he has no "reasonable expectations of a meaningful outcome."

Mr. Ban was urged by over 100 former world leaders to visit Burma to petition the military regime to release all political prisoners. The UN Security Council called for the release of all political prisoners in 2007. No need to elaborate here on what happened after that resolution.

Is this an indication - as many fear - that the UN have all but given up on the situation in Burma? To write off any possibility of having even modest progress sounds resigned, exhausted and pessimistic.

The UN added in their statement that Special Envoy Ibrahim Gambari would not return to Burma any time soon. (His last trip was August, when Aung San Suu Kyi in a confusing and wrong-headed move refused twice to meet with him).

I have friends who are in jail in Burma for the slimmest of reasons, or for what I see as no reason at all. One has a jail sentence of 142 years.

What is a "meaningful outcome?" How do you qualify and quantify that to people who are starving and desperate? Please explain.

UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon has said he will not travel to Burma because he has no "reasonable expectations of a meaningful outcome." Mr. Ban was urged by over 100 former world leaders to visit ...
UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon has said he will not travel to Burma because he has no "reasonable expectations of a meaningful outcome." Mr. Ban was urged by over 100 former world leaders to visit ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:58 AM on 12/11/2008
I find myself agreeing with DaveinBrooklyn again...in any organization, whether a bloaed governmental agency or a bloated charity, there are STILL good people doing the best,hardest and fastest they can to get the food, the word, the water, whatever out to the people. I also know that although many NGO's do the job, they are not perfect either....hello on the ground organization?
When people want freedom and justice more than they fear the government they will get it. This entire world is at war for the hearts and minds of the people who have to do indescribable things to have food, shelter, safety. Those are tomorrow's soldiers in the war on the rest of us.
Yes, we need a better UN or whatever it's name should be. Yes we must take care of our fellow humans. Unfortunately, there is nothing else at the moment....which means to me that we can invent it. After all, the UN was just an idea at one point...One place at a time, one miracle to a customer.
10:37 PM on 12/07/2008
I have met many many outstanding UN personnel who truly work to the limits of human ability to provide the best aid possible in a timely fashion.

Sadly the UN continues to prove its uselessness.
The UN was a decent idea that has grown fat, lazy and in some cases actually hinders real aid work.

There (to my knowledge) is no other group, organization or nation that can provide the level of food distribution, water and sanitation, health care and shelter to the world population. there in lays the dilemma. The UN is a failing and flawed organization who cant even meet its charter and protect those its meant to protect but there is no other way (currently) to distribute aid to the needy.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:29 AM on 12/08/2008
I agree DaveinBrooklyn. The best UN people always leave with the most terrible stories of waste and mismanagement and lack of concern and care by people paid large amounts of money to protect and serve. You hear it time and again. I think private NGOs do a much better job than the UN but I agree with your major points.

And their failures in Burma are just mind boggling.
08:15 AM on 12/05/2008
The UN is as corrupt and greedy an organization as any US Corporation..

The UN made 9 BILLION dollars a year, scamming and skimming the Iraq Oil For Food program.

The UN sent "peacekeepers" down to an African nation to disarm rebels and ending up selling them arms. At a substantial profit for the UN..

"The best thing for the UN to do is go condo."
-Robin Williams

Michale.....
01:37 AM on 12/05/2008
UN don't care about Burma as it is powerless to interfere anything in any country's crisis. Better change the name to United Nothing. sigh!
10:57 PM on 12/04/2008
I just read this! I am amazed that they don't take every opportunity to get in there and scream blue murder.