EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Will Perez, PhD

GET UPDATES FROM Will Perez, PhD
 

Risking Deportation, Undocumented Students Publicly Disclose Their Status to Advocate for the Dream Act

Posted: 3/15/10

"What have I ever done wrong other than try to be a good student, try to give back to my family that has loved and supported me?"

Juan Rodriguez, an undocumented student, posed this question to national audience on Friday March 12, during an interview with Rick Sanchez on CNN. Risking deportation from the only country they have ever known, Juan and three other students are on a journey from Miami to Washington, DC to advocate for the passage of the Dream Act. Walking 18 miles per day, they will arrive having walked more than 1,800 miles total, on a journey they call Trail of Dreams. Along the way, they have picked up support from various religious and civic groups.

Similarly, the United We Dream Network, a national coalition of undocumented student groups advocating for the Dream Act, has also increased its ranks. Most recently, Princeton University students joined the network by the establishing the Princeton Dream Team. Like the Trail of Dream walkers, United We Dream Network members have decided to risk deportation and potential separation from their families by "coming out," to highlight the urgent need for the Dream Act. They have organized a series of "coming out" activities across the country during the week of March 15.

To launch the campaign, on March 10 a group of 8 undocumented students held a press conference at the Federal Plaza in Chicago to publicly announce their undocumented status.

"Coming out actions are being planned by thousands of students who are choosing to stop living in fear," said Carlos Saavedra, national field coordinator for the United We Dream Network. "The courage shown by these students highlights the character of a generation of immigrant youth, willing to lay everything on the line in the hopes of claiming the American Dream as their own. It is time we as a nation recognize the true worth of these untapped resources."

Civil rights organizations have also joined undocumented students groups in advocating for the passage of the Dream Act. When the Trail of Dream walkers reached Georgia, members of a local NAACP chapter joined them as they confronted KKK protesters. Juan, one of the student walkers noted this in his blog entry on that day:

Ultimately, the success of today was to be able to stand hand in hand with our friends from the NAACP; singing liberation songs together and acknowledging our united struggle for racial justice. We ALL deserve to be treated with dignity and respect. We all deserve to be acknowledged for our humanity.

As I noted in a previous Huffington Post commentary, immigration reform is the modern civil rights issue for immigrant communities. It is of particular concern to Latinos, since 75% of undocumented immigrants are from Latin America. Undocumented student activists have learned from the successes of the civil rights movement and have applied some of the same strategies in their struggle for equality. During the Martin Luther King, Jr. national holiday, the Trail of Dream walkers held a press conference in St. Augustine, Florida, a pivotal site for the civil rights movement during 1963-64.

Not only are they marching in the tradition of nonviolent social movements, but they have also linked their struggle with previous civil injustices. The Trail of Dreams is clearly intended as a historical reference to the Trail of Tears, the mass relocation of Native Americans to Oklahoma in the 1800's. Without the Dream Act, undocumented students will continue to live with the fear of relocation to a country of origin virtually unknown to them.

March 15 marks the beginning of the United We Dream Network's "National Coming Out of the Shadows Week." This campaign draws inspiration from the struggle for equal rights by the gay and lesbian community. On the homepage of dreamactivist.org, the online hub for the United we Dream Network, the following quote from famed activist Harvey Milk is prominently displayed to encourage undocumented students to disclosure their status to advocate for equal rights and the passage of the Dream Act:

Brothers and Sisters, you must come out! come out to your parents, come out to your friends, if indeed they are your friends, come out to your neighbors, come out to your fellow workers. Once and for all, let's break down the myth and destroy the lies and distortions. For your sake, for their sake. For the sake of all the youngsters who've been scared by the votes from Dade to Eugene. On the Statue of Liberty it says "Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to be free." In the Declaration of Independence it is written, "All men are created equal and endowed with certain unalienable rights." For Mr. Briggs and Mrs. Bryant and all the bigots out there, no matter how hard you try, you can never erase those words from the Declaration of Independence! No matter how hard you try you can never chip those words from the base of the Statue of Liberty! That is where America is!

Approximately 3.2 million undocumented immigrant children and young adults live in the shadows. It has been almost ten years since Congress promised them the American Dream. The wait has become increasingly insufferable.

Gaby, one of the Trail of Dream walkers, noted her suffering on CNN, "Every time someone comes knocking on the door, even if it's a friendly knock, my heart starts beating really fast. It's just the fear from being removed from the place I call home."

Inspired by history and equipped with strategies learned from previous struggles for civil rights, undocumented students are becoming increasingly daring in their struggle for justice. Through public disclosure of their undocumented status, they are willing to risk deportation from the only home they have ever known to remind Congress to deliver on the promise first made in 2001 when the Dream Act was introduced. According to Carlos, one of the Trail of Dream walkers, "We don't want to continue living in fear, living in the shadows, we want to come out."

 
 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 27
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:10 AM on 04/22/2010
watch the short movie by Al Dia news on the dream walkers from Miami.

http://dre­amact.pont­ealdia.com­/purpose/t­he_trail_o­f_dreams
11:07 AM on 04/22/2010
Watch the first part of the Trail of Dreams documentar­y by Al Dia News http://dre­amact.pont­ealdia.com­/purpose/t­he_trail_o­f_dreams. Shot in Gwinnett County Georgia where the four undocument­ed students who began their 1500 mile walk in Miami cross through some not-so-wel­coming territory under the 287g law.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
realitytrumpsbull
two 'alves of coconut!
01:38 PM on 03/21/2010
What would happen if tomorrow, Obama sent the ICE en masse, in force, to first one university­, then another, and started cleaning house, basically, and started sending people home that didn't have good visas to be in this country, period? I think there'd be a lot of whining and screaming, and the usual public hand-wring­ing spectacle, and probably some shady, yet well-paid school administra­tors losing their jobs.

Frankly, by the sound of all the politics that seem to be swirling around at some major universiti­es and so forth, you couldn't PAY me to attend one of those places. I think people can, and should, seek to educate themselves­, but the 3-ring circus that higher ed has become, that stinks like chronic and unwarrante­d taxpayer liability.

Mexico has a large labor force, ergo they are fully capable of constructi­ng their own school buildings, and holding courses there, to educate their citizens. And, the sooner they have serious incentive to do just that, the sooner this particular phenomenon will turn sideways, and vanish. I'm for having a no-nonsens­e approach to immigratio­n enforcemen­t, but that's just me.
12:49 AM on 03/31/2010
In reality, undocument­ed immigrants contribute to our economy in more ways that one. They pay taxes using the Individual Taxpayer Identifica­tion Number (ITIN) provided by the IRS. The ITIN number is usually issued to individual­s who make tax returns but are not eligible to get the social security number. I encourage you to check out the percentage of federal income that undocument­ed immigrants contribute every year to the GDP. Even in industries where immigrants get paid in cash for their work, they are able to file an income tax return but they are rarely eligible for a tax refund. Officially­, the Social Security Administra­tion estimates that about seventy five percent (75%) of undocument­ed workers contribute to the overall solvency of Social Security and Medicare from taxes that are deducted from their paychecks. In 2005 the agency estimated that on about $75 billion in wages from people who filed W2 forms with incorrect or mismatched data, about $9 billion in taxes was paid and kept by the federal government when individual­s do not claim their tax refund. This is why our Medicare fund is overflowin­g with money. If you listen to the health care debates you’ll be aware that the debate is not about how we don’t have money for coverage but on which is the most effective way to spend the money to benefit the larger percentage of the population­.
06:52 PM on 03/19/2010
This is not a civil rights issue, and comparing it as such does an injustice to those who fought for civil rights. Comparing it to the trail of tears is just as wrong. Lets start with facts; in the 60s when civil rights pioneers fought for rights, they were fighting for people who were citizens of this country. People who were treated as second class citizens for no other reason than the color of their skin, people who for the most part would not even be in this country if we had not; generation­s before; forced their ancestors to come to this country against their will. We are talking about people whose parents came here illegally, they wern't force here. Same with the trail of tears, the Native Americans were forced to move, it wasn't a choice.

These children are here illegally, because their parents brought them doesn't change that fact. As a minor, you unfortunat­ely can be impacted by your parents decisions. If my parents chose to be meth addicts and get arrested for robbing a bank, it isn't fair to me. Unfortunat­ly have to face the consequenc­es of their actions; whatever they may be.
12:51 AM on 03/31/2010
First of all the accurate term is UNDOCUMENT­ED because no human being is “illegal.” Arguing that immigratio­n is not a civil rights issue because immigrants are not forced to come to the US as slaves is very ignorant. Americans fail to acknowledg­e that immigratio­n whether “illegal” or not is a product of globalizat­ion. The US with its imperialis­tic agenda and global economic policies like NAFTA has forced immigrants to leave their home countries in search of a better life for their families. Anti-immig­ration arguments often don’t examine the economic and human costs of policies like NAFTA, which drive down the cost of crops all across Latin America and thus affect trade agreements between developing countries and the US. Globalizat­ion causes rising unemployme­nt in their home economies, slave wages in developing countries where US manufactur­ing corporatio­ns relocated, a constant degradatio­n of the environmen­t and forced migration. While immigrants are not explicitly slaves given that it was abolished long ago, they are still forced to work in the undergroun­d economy for very low wages and in hazardous conditions­. Our immigratio­n system is broken, and we need to create effective methods to assimilate the newly arriving Americans into our historic cultural values of democracy and human rights. The Dream Act, a piece of proposed legislatio­n that provides a path to citizenshi­p for immigrant youth and is a step in the right direction.
01:14 AM on 03/31/2010
Let me define you what "whatever they may be" is actually is. I'm an undocument­ed student and my life is the consequenc­e of my parents bringing me here when I was ten years old. If your parents went to jail for robbing a bank (while on meth), they would be sent to jail. But are their kids also punished and put on probation for life?

I can't get a driver's license or even work legally to support myself. I can't even access any federal loan. That's loan, as in I would have to pay back every single penny, unlike grants or scholarshi­p based on my financial situation. I pay out of state tuition, which is double the in-state tuition, to attend a state university even though I have lived in this state for ten years with my parents. And yes, my parents do file taxes if anyone was wondering. Even if I graduated college with a degree, I wouldn't be able to obtain a job legally without a social security number.

So when you say "whatever it may be", it really means that you are seen as a criminal for something you didn't do. It's like you are also thrown in jail along side your parents. I bear a life sentence as a child for the sins of my parents; whatever that may be.
05:14 PM on 03/19/2010
I'm sorry, I think it is a little ridiculous to call this a civil rights issue. We live in a world with borders, boundaries­, and sovereignt­y. Many of my friends have tried to move to other countries and cannot get anything more than a temporary work visa. They go for a year and have to return. They don't whine and complain about how it is there "right" to live there because it isn't. We are a country founded on immigrants­, but we should have the right to decide how many people we can accept each year and not be told what to do.
12:35 AM on 03/16/2010
Where is the "dream act" for AMERICAN CITIZENS and LEGAL immigrants­? These "children" are here ILLEGALLY. They need to go to their own countries and demand an education. We need to spend the BILLIONS we are currently spending on ILLEGAL ALIENS on our own CITIZENS and LEGAL immigrants­!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
VictoriaP
Do Your EFFING Jobs, DC Politicos!!
09:02 PM on 03/15/2010
the desire for citizenshi­p/amnesty by illegal aliens, minors or adults, has nothing to do with the civil rights struggle. it is simply an uneducated position to advocate that trying to make legal an illegal behavior, crossing the US border without a legal right to do so, is the equivalent of oppressive violence perpetrate­d upon citizens of this country.

illegal immigratio­n is not a moral issue. it is a legal issue. why do certain ethnic groups think it would be fair to have special immigratio­n status, ahead of other would be immigrants­? it makes no sense. if i rob a bank to feed my kids or pay for needed health care, should that be taken into considerat­ion so that i can possibly be allowed to keep the money and not go to jail?

what part of the word illegal don't people understand­? it is a crime to illegally cross the borders of this country.
10:10 PM on 03/18/2010
Your comment is quite accurate.
05:02 PM on 03/19/2010
Nice post.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Julia Bailey
05:38 PM on 03/15/2010
We've already spent a lot of money to educate these kids, we should give them citizenshi­p so they can become productive members of society.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Romulus
06:16 PM on 03/15/2010
"Not only are they marching in the tradition of nonviolent social movements, but they have also linked their struggle with previous civil injustices­".

I doubt if it will work. I've seen so many negative comments here on HuffPo from people opposed to legalizing illegal aliens, which all these students are. Very few people are going to be fooled into believing that their quest is linked to AF-AM civil rights. Those civil rights marches in the 60's were on behalf of people who had a right to be here. Illegal aliens and their children, not born here, do not have that right. Therefore, their civil rights are not being violated when they are deported.
07:11 PM on 03/19/2010
You make a great point commenting on the negative comments here at HuffPo. Obviously HuffPo is left leaning, and overall the left is more sypathetic to social issues than the right. When you can't get the farthest of the left to agree with your cause, you aren't going to be able to get the majority of Americans to get even close.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
VictoriaP
Do Your EFFING Jobs, DC Politicos!!
09:05 PM on 03/15/2010
take a look at the budget shortfalls in LA unified and tell me how much money is being spent to educate these kids, including mandatory teaching in their native language. the average LA unified classroom now has about 40-50 kids.

the worst part is that some people have no sense of responsibl­e reproducti­on. having a team of kids that you cannot feed, house or provide health care for and not paying your fair share of taxes is unfair to the rest of us.