More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Yoani Sanchez

Yoani Sanchez

Posted: January 2, 2011 01:03 PM

The Buried Revolution

What's Your Reaction:

On December 31, precisely at midnight, a waterfall poured from every balcony of my Yugoslav-style building. Cubans keep the tradition of throwing a bucket of water at year's end to clean all the bad brought by previous months and to spiritually "clean" the January about to begin. This year there were infinite reasons to throw water -- that precious liquid that prepares us to face everything to come -- from the windows, balconies and roofs. So my husband and I found the biggest container we could and together, from our 14th floor balcony, threw its contents into the void, thinking about everything we want to leave behind. The first sun of 2011 reflected brilliantly from the puddles in the street, formed not by rain but by our desires.

Few confess aloud the full list of hopes they harbor for the next twelve months, but it's easy to guess that an important point on every list is the need for political changes on this Island. Each defines it in his or her own way. "This has to end now," some say. "May Raul's reforms succeed in improving our lives," say others. Or, "May 2011 be the year that so many of us have been waiting for," is the cryptic declaration of some who lost patience and faith long ago.

Curiously, the word "revolution" is absent from these popular predictions, as the vast majority of citizens no longer consider it a dynamic entity, alive, in transformation. When they refer to the prevailing model in the country they do so as if it were an immovable structure, as if it were the most confining straitjacket, rigid and unlikely to adapt to the new demands of the 21st century.

All those ideals of renewal brought down from the mountains by young bearded men have given way to a government where power is concentrated in figures in their seventies and eighties, deeply suspicious of innovation. Nonetheless, in official pronouncements January 1st continues to be spoken of as the birthday of a living creature, when in fact it is the anniversary of something that died long ago. The Revolution has been buried by stagnation. The social project lies deep within the earth and the question on everyone's mind is what date should we carve on its tombstone.

For thousands of my compatriots the Revolution died in 1968 when Fidel Castro himself applauded the entry of Soviet tanks into Prague. The fierce bear hug that engulfed us, the omnipresence of the Kremlin, the thousands of barrels of oil it sent Cuba each year, its massive subsidies and its geopolitical demands, ultimately drowned any semblance of spontaneity.

The so-called Five Grey Years (1971-1975) turned out the lights on culture, as Socialist Realism clipped the wings of our creativity and reduced us to triumphalist stories whose protagonist was always the never-realized "New Man."

For my parents, the Revolution ended in the first months of 1989 with the criminal trial of General Arnaldo Ochoa, charged with drug trafficking. The subsequent executions, of him and others, and the purges in the Ministry of Interior, clarified for many that the anxiety to maintain power took precedence over all ideals, Marxist manuals, scientific communism and everything we had been taught in school.

For my generation, the requiem of the Revolution was confirmed some years later, with the punches and stones thrown on the streets of Havana in August 1994. When, in response, Fidel ordered the coast guard to stop patrolling the shore and to "let the scum that wants to leave, leave," Cubans climbed aboard rickety rafts all along the coastline.

For many, their departure destroyed the remaining illusions of those who thought the Revolution was a social project "of the poor, the meek, and the humble." It was precisely the poorest Cubans, in those days of despair, who risked the sharks and the overcrowding at Guantanamo Naval Base, where they were taken by the American forces who plucked them from the waters to wait for planes to complete their escape to the north. The thirty thousand who set sail in a single month took with them the last shred of believability of our authorities' insistence that the government represented all Cubans.

Now we are left with too-often stated reminders of an idealized past: "What could have been and wasn't," people say. Meanwhile, reality negates every word spoken from the dais, leaving the black market the only option for survival as apathy casts its corrosive acid over attempts to ideologically motivate us.

It is the long funeral that never gets to the end, where the family of the departed can't bear to shovel the sod over the coffin. Somehow, a few of them can't shake the belief that the deceased Revolution can rise up from its shroud, reinvent itself, shake off the wrinkles and chronic diseases.

The rest of us attend the funeral, asking the poignant question, "What went wrong? At what instant did the Revolution become a cadaver?" Deciphering this question may be of vital importance to our national future. We already know many of the chronic diseases that played a part in its death: personal ambition, bureaucracy, red tape, selling out to a foreign power, and copying a model that only looks good in a text book.

What we don't know is if it was the push we ourselves gave it, if it was our hands, our minds, which finally choked the creature they tried to create. Or if the genetics of the process were based on the chromosomes of failure from the start.

A version of this post originally appeared in Peru's El Comercio newspaper.

Yoani's blog, Generation Y, can be read here in English translation.
Translating Cuba is a new compilation blog with Yoani and other Cuban bloggers in English.

 
 
 

Follow Yoani Sanchez on Twitter: www.twitter.com/yoanisanchez

 
 
  • Comments
  • 76
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
07:33 PM on 01/03/2011
A friend of mine went to Cuba. She said the women were all very thin.....and hungry.

Cuba shows a rich side to tourists, but the political elite have siphoned off all the money.
Castro is right in there with Lenin and Stalin.
04:31 PM on 01/03/2011
Ok, this gets tiring, so, once again (slowly): a 50+ year dictatorship, over ten percent of the population in exile and continuing to brave the Florida straits in rafts to escape, thousands killed in firing squads, disappeared, and continuing to languish in jails for mundane "political" crimes such as meeting without a permit, and so on ad infinitum. Please, enough with the pro-Fidel propaganda. It keeps coming from either: trolls, or genuinely naive simpletons. No, medicine in Cuba is not "free," it is nonexistent for most Cubans. No, the embargo is not responsible for the Cuban fiasco, they trade freely with every other country besides the U.S. No education in Cuba is not great, it is not even very good, in fact it is terrible, and even that level requires active genuflection toward the regime. None of this is controversial or in dispute, and there are literally millions of living witnesses inside and outside of Cuba to all of it and more. Goodness! The level of willful ignorance of the trolls commenting on this blog is truly breathtaking.
photo
CDL1
Sultry in Seattle
02:50 PM on 01/03/2011
Prior to the country's liberation Cuba was treated as a dumping ground for American vices. The people were illiterate and destitute. At best they worked as servants for tourists and field hands for the rich and Black Cubans lived under Jim Crow type discrimination, Back then Cuba was a US trading partner and all was fine and dandy. When Castro freed the Cubans from US capitalism he brought them the highest literacy rate in the Americas, the lowest mortality rate in the Americas, ended racism, and gave them a sense of pride. The only reason the country is poor today is because the US has pushed its embargo against Cuba for the last 50 yrs and it has taken its toll. Cuba is in a perfect geographic position to trade with several nations, including the US, but is effectively cut off due to the embargo. It isnt Castro's system that is failing, it's the US embargo that is succeeding.
Bladernr1001
Vote Libertarian
04:25 PM on 01/03/2011
NO....I would say it is one of the best examples of the failure of Socialism.
10:13 AM on 01/05/2011
Castrofascism have nothing to delivery to the public opinion but crimes and repression, that’s why they released those fables about health and education but without to explain that those was achievements of democracy prior castro. In same fable category matches this thing about Americans owning Cuba and dumping their vices and mafia there. No one that states such things have investigated this fables personally but just repeats what they heard from castrofascism’s apologists and propaganda machinery. No one offer a single prove, a documented testimony, UN or WHO records, nothing just vain and false words. Some others want to present Mayer Lansky control over a hotel in Havana as “mafia controlling casinos in Cuba”……. At the end, no one stops to think about the fact that supposing castrofascism propaganda is true it don’t justify 53 years of crimes, economical and social destruction and repressive tyranny.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Peter Noble 2
01:16 PM on 01/03/2011
I would prefer a country that provides basic welfare and health care and education to what we have in America.
Having seen our "Change President" order the assassination of an American Citizen, having extended powers to detain and surveil American citizens..I am not impressed by American Capitalism.

Yes ALL dictatorships are vile and should end but do we really want the fine people of Cuba to end up being serfs to Oligarchs like the American people?

Freedom is relative. In America we have the freedom to speak but we also have the horror of poverty, for some of you..that means NOTHING to eat!

Not all Americans use their Freedoms and do not notice as bit by bit, it is being taken from us so when a nut gets jailed for a poem musing on the death of Obama we ignore it. However it was just a poem..a poem no matter how bad is art and was once protected..no longer.

I remember Russian artists who had clamored for American Capitalism being horrified they had to work in boiler room as no one supported them any longer. As an artist I've scrubbed toilets! They had no idea how EVIL and how cruel American Capitalism is.

American Capitalism is the last ism to survive except for Cuba. I hope unlike the East Germans they think long and hard about letting America turn them all into waiters.
10:19 AM on 01/05/2011
You are talking about things you simply don't know.... castrofascism does not provides welfare, no health or education but death, killing, jail and repression.
Capita;lism is the only economical system that exists all other "beens" created by tyrant aprentices (Communism, socialism, fascism, etc) are simply ideological doctrines with no economical system to support them. Commies and fascists uses to say they will built a better economical system but in reality they don't know what to do when taking the power and regulary ends destroying the country.... that's why they all perished politicaly or got back to the wildest and cruel capitalism...... like castro who went from stalinism to fascism!!!
12:51 PM on 01/03/2011
Communism always leads to totalitarianism, and totalitarianism always destroys freedom and prosperity. There should be no surprises about this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Peter Noble 2
01:25 PM on 01/03/2011
American Capitalism has produced a dictatorship. We now have a 2 party system of Total War and Welfare for the Wealthy. There is only the difference of bigotry, that is who you hate but the substance is the same.

You are delusional if you think Cubans would be better off as waiters for Oligarchs. I hope they choose freedom of speech but keep welfare, free education and a stellar public health care service.

Not everyone has to cheer on Facebook billionaires as they give away 0.00000001% of their wealth to charity BUT will hate paying taxes like the rest of us.

I am a Socialist and can tell you there has never been a true Marxist State. A dictatorship is not Marxism..or any form of Communism. It's never been tried..sad to say.
02:38 PM on 01/03/2011
A) American corporatism has produced a corrupt system, yes.

B) "You are delusional" if you believe Cubans are better off as impoverished serfs than free individuals.

C) Marxism inevitably leads to totalitarianism-- economic planning necessitates choices between groups of people that can only be ultimately decided by a central authority if the goals of the society are to be preserved.
12:33 PM on 01/03/2011
Golly, Communism didn't work in Cuba...
What a surprise.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Peter Noble 2
01:25 PM on 01/03/2011
It's working better than American Capitalism.
02:53 PM on 01/03/2011
I'd rather be poor here than poor in Cuba. I like having things like electricity, running water, the opportunity to improve my lot in life,,, you know small things.
Bladernr1001
Vote Libertarian
04:47 PM on 01/03/2011
Ddi you see the footage of the cities in Cuba during the Winton Marsales piece on 60 minutes? All the cars were like 1950's 60's vintage, the buildings were all beat up...even the narrartor on the peice had to acknowledge the obvious 3rd world look of the place 9that have killed the liberal 60 minutes staff to have to acknowedge that), the continual shortages and general doledrum of the people.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:07 AM on 01/03/2011
For excellent Blogs from variety of Cubans from Cuba check out the Havana Times. "Open-Mind­ed Writing from Cuba"

www.havana­times.org
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:15 AM on 01/03/2011
http://www.havanatimes.org/
10:25 AM on 01/05/2011
Dear one..... happy new year!!!
I see you still fighting for Havana Times........ the problem is that they censures what they do not like..... that's why people don't last there and after a couple of censured comments they leave to not come back never!!!!
09:45 AM on 01/03/2011
How many poor Cubans would like to move to Haiti, which has excellent diplomatic relations with the U.S.,since the U.S. overthrew Haiti's democratically elected president and shipped him off to South Africa?

How many Cubans would not mind living in poverty in Honduras, another country with the U.S. selected puppet leader in charge?

As poor as Cuba is, I never see the appalling poverty and suffering of the people there that one sees in Haiti and Honduras, and other countries the U.S. can't keep its hands out of. Pakistan? What happened to the millions of people who were flooded out of their homes? The U.S. bombed the other side of Pakistan. How about the thousands of Afghans killed by U.S. bombing raids?

I've been to Cuba and I've been to Haiti, which the U.S. Marines have invaded and occupied several times during the past century. I would take Cuba any day.

Read U.S. Marine Corps Smedley Butler's book online for free, "War is a Racket."

Will HP publish this? Probably not.
05:59 PM on 01/03/2011
well what about Argentina, seems they can't get there fast enough. Dominican republic seems to be favorite and then of course Belize. I think you give them a choice again cuba would be empty.
10:31 AM on 01/05/2011
Cubans not only wants to live in Honduras better that in Cuba but they risks their lives and their sons and grand parents lives and put the family altogether in a improvised raft and try to sail to Honduras, Guatemala, Mexico, Gran Caiman.... and they do that because US coast guard and Clinton's dry-wet feet law works effectively to avoid them get in USA...... every week decens of cubans left the island heading central america in rafts..... 70% of them never reach the destiny and become food for shark..... those people knows this fact but anyway they prefers to take the risk than stay in castro's "paradise"
08:10 AM on 01/03/2011
I would say that the ability of Yoanni Sanchez to write this blog openly from inside Cuba shows that there has been an enormous amount of loosening up there.
photo
Cannonball Taffy O Jones
Khaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan!
08:24 AM on 01/03/2011
I would say that the inability of Yoani to vote out her government shows that any recent changes in Cuba are largely cosmetic.
08:43 AM on 01/03/2011
As if voting in Twiddle Dee (D) vs Twiddledum (R) makes much of a difference other than the windowdressing. Must be nice to go toCcuba if you choose. Apparently we don't have that freedom--and btw, been to a US airport recently? Speaking of freedom and government intrusion.
07:47 AM on 01/03/2011
Newsflash for Yoani: Cuba's 2010 infant mortality rate 4.5, the lowest in its history and the LOWEST in the Americas.
Other available rates from 2009: Canada 4.99, USA 6.14, Chile 7.52, Costa Rica 9.72, Argentina 11.11, Colombia 16.87, Brazil 21.86, Dominican Republic 23.10
photo
Cannonball Taffy O Jones
Khaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan!
08:22 AM on 01/03/2011
Newsflash for Heavyduty!
 
According to the UN your figures are wrong:
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_dependent_territories_by_death_rate
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:03 AM on 01/03/2011
Heavyduty was talking about infant mortality rate; the link you point to is talking about crude death rate.

Very different statistics. The infant mortality rate is widely recognized as a much more valuable measure of a public health system, as it is not influenced by factors like the proportion of elderly to young in a population as a whole.

Also, you are not linking to UN data. You are linking to a Wikipedia article.

But thanks for playing.
07:38 AM on 01/03/2011
Newsflash for Yoani: Cuba's 2010 infant mortality rate 4.5, the lowest in its history and the lowest in the Americas. Here are some 2009 rates for various countries:
Canada 4.99, US 6.14, Chile 7.52, Costa Rica 9.72, Argentina 11.11, Colombia 16.87, Brazil 21.86, Dominican Republic 23.10
10:48 AM on 01/05/2011
Cuba's infant mortality rate of 32 per 1,000 live births in 1957 was the lowest in Latin America and the 13th lowest in the world, according to UN data. Cuba ranked ahead of France, Belgium, West Germany, Japan, Austria, Italy, and Spain.
Today Cuba ranks in the place 28 in the world what means castrofascism has spoiled the wanderful health system it inherited from democracy...... even accounting this data that place actual Cuba in place 28 is true.... we all know totalitarian regimes controling al information in the country uses to fake and inflate statistics.... there are many "political" prisoners in Cuba that are in jail just for dismantling regimes lies.... like Dr. Biscet or Dr. Darsis Ferrer.

http://ctp.iccas.miami.edu/FACTS_Web/Cuba%20Facts%20Issue%2043%20December.htm
07:27 AM on 01/03/2011
Free dental and healthcare in Cuba for all their people.

Cuba has a higher longevity rate than the USA.

In America if you get sick and have no insurance, you can always ask the local fire dept or some other organization to help you raise money to pay the bankrupting doctor bills or die.

I have to wonder which political system is more humane?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Middle Blue
What's a micro-bio?
07:37 AM on 01/03/2011
...and you believe the stats published by a police state because...
07:46 AM on 01/03/2011
This reminds me of the way in which the Right continually strives to portray the truth as some liberal consiracy.
Haven't got the facts on your side? Go for the manufactured buzzwords and fear-mongering.
photo
woodshoe
MAYDAY! BastaYA!
08:08 AM on 01/03/2011
and YOU believe the stats published by a police state because?

(news item; 'state' refers specifically to the "men with guns" aspect of occupation by domestic government,. so academically, the phrase "police state" is redundant.. and meaningless as a comparison between 'states' as 'police' as quite necessary to the maintenance of ANY 'state', by definition.

i would prefer NO state.

that does not appear to be a luxury i should expect to enjoy in my lifetime.

so then, with the assumption of the ubiquitous police state in modern late-capitalism globally, i must make a reasonable measure of the nature and extent of repression and who it serves in the case in EACH respective state ( ..each respective police state.)

does the state align its forces to protect, as "best" it may with such an apparatus, the rights of the vast population to enjoy lives of relative health and security, while repressing those very few who would compel the rest the rent themselves as a way of life? is that what the police are doing?

or does the state align its forces to "protect the minority of OPULENT, from the majority"? (james madison as publius) to project force power onto abstract religious concepts such as the legitimacy of wealth accumulated by the fractionalized labor of others, to protect usury property over the property of use. (usufruct) to protect the very predatory few.
is THAT what the police are doing?

and select accordingly, tactically, for now.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Peter Noble 2
01:27 PM on 01/03/2011
I am going to FAN you! Thanks, I've been posting that American Capitalism is nothing to boast about but ...
02:49 PM on 01/03/2011
Sorry you don't care for it. Its been great to virtually everyone I know. I've traveled a fair amount and wouldn't care to settle down anywhere else.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
scholasticus
I don't have to believe your "-ism".
07:12 AM on 01/03/2011
The US embargo is an excuse. Cuba has trade relations with the EU and China, and other places. Sadly, it is monopoly communism that is to blame for Cuban poverty.
06:42 AM on 01/03/2011
How is the health care?
Think of it this way--you could be us.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Eileenla
Author, "Sacred Economics"
01:27 AM on 01/03/2011
Nations the world over are facing these same problems, as humanity itself is coming to grips with the limitations of its longstanding power/dominator model of governance. That model is a win/lose paradigm marked by control, exploitation and the success of a few at the expense of the many. Every civilization that ever adopted it has eventually collapsed, no matter its economic model or mode of allocating power. What's called for is a win/win paradigm - one that values the freedom of every individual to bring forth his/her highest creative capacities and fully nurtures that process. In turn, self-actualized individuals will recognize their responsibility to support the larger community that is supporting them and will be inspired to their gifts to the community out of love and gratitude for what they've received. It will be marked by long term thinking, a focus on replenishment of what we use rather than constant consumption, good stewardship of the planet and it's resources, and a focus on improving the quality of life for all beings versus measuring the financial profitability of our actions.