04/09/2013 03:25 pm ET Updated Jun 09, 2013

Time to Widen View of U.S. Wine Scene


By Jancis Robinson
and Linda Murphy

I wonder how many Americans realize their importance in the world of wine. The United States has recently overtaken France and Italy to become the globe's biggest market, drinking a full 13 percent of all the wine produced on the planet, more than any other nation. While wine drinking has been declining rapidly in the European countries that make so much of it -- France, Italy and Spain -- we are amazed at how rapidly and firmly a wine culture has been established in the U.S.

In cities such as New York, Chicago and San Francisco, you can hardly move for wine tastings, wine bars, wine courses and people who are parlaying their interest in wine into building collections, visiting urban wineries and taking wine tours. But even in the vastness of America between the coasts, wine has been catching on. We looked up wine events in Des Moines, for example, and were delighted to find at least one a month. What we like about this development is that these new wine lovers, many of them relatively young, are working out their own preferences rather than being spoon-fed a series of ratings.

Related: Tips for trekking in wine country.

But it is not just as a consumer that the U.S. now leads the world. Americans overtook Argentina in the 1990s to become by far the most important wine producer outside Europe, with the total amount of American wine produced gaining on the amount made in France, Italy and Spain. The shifting balance is due in some part to a determined program to rip out surplus, low quality vineyards in the EU.

Robert Mondavi was always convinced that California could make wines that were the equal of Europe's best. That point was made long ago, but what thrills us is that American interest is so great that wine is now being made in every state in the Union. Hawaii and Alaska have their own wines, and North Dakota has eight bonded wineries. We long ago recognized that California, Washington and Oregon could make great wine, but now is the time to check out what we call The Other 47.

Related: The latest for Virginia (wine) lovers.

The curious American wine lover would be well advised to investigate the less-celebrated steely Rieslings of northwestern Michigan and the Finger Lakes region of New York. In blind tastings of Rieslings from throughout the world, their offerings have been ranked among the finest. 2013-04-04-JancisRobinson.LindaMurphy.jpg

But perhaps the best Viogniers, Petit Mansengs and Bordeaux blends of Virginia would be an appropriate starting point for an exploration of American wine in view of Thomas Jefferson's early efforts on his Monticello estate to turn Americans into a nation of wine drinkers. (It was the local phylloxera louse that scuppered his early plantings of the European vinifera vines, by far the most dominant vines in wine production.)

In some of the more inhospitable sites for grape vines, where the climate is too cold and the growing season too short to support European Vitis vinifera varieties such as Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot, grape breeders, particularly in Minnesota, have been developing cold-hardy hybrids that ripen their fruit relatively early and produce fully mature grapes that can be vinified into seriously good table and dessert wines. Look for La Crescent and Brianna whites, and Frontenac and Marquette reds. Older French-American hybrids, with names such as Baco Noir, Cayuga, Chambourcin and Vidal Blanc, remain important grape sources in the most challenging terroirs in the Midwest.

Related: Do wine medals matter?

In wet, humid Southern states, native Muscadine vines, which have adapted to the conditions, produce musky-sweet aromas and flavors that can be an acquired taste for some, but are embraced by others who have grown up drinking them. In New York, Michigan and Pennsylvania, the native Concord grape used so widely for juice, jelly and grapey wines such as Manischewitz, can taste pretty extraordinary to a palate not raised on Cabernet and Chardonnay. However, some American vine varieties -- the Norton grape of Virginia and Missouri comes quickly to mind -- can produce admirable wines without the rankness associated with Concord, wines that should appeal to any lover of fruity reds with character.

Then again, there are wineries in the U.S. that ship in grapes from sunnier climes (often California), and vinify and bottle them under their own labels. Despite movements across the country calling for only locally grown grapes to go into locally produced wines, importing West Coast fruit keeps many a winery tasting room financially afloat.

Related: Using two bottles of $150 wine to transform cheese into a silky dessert?

And in some parts of the country -- Alaska, North and South Dakota in particular -- vintners make their living selling wines made from vegetables and non-grape fruits. Pumpkins, rhubarb, berries, cherries, apples, pears, peaches, just about any produce that has natural sugar, can be fermented into wine. Many of them taste surprisingly good.

We feel strongly that the dramatic increase in quality of wines made in The Other 47 deserves more recognition. Be adventurous in your wine choices.

Photos, from top:
Grand Valley AVA vineyards are planted along the base of Colorado's 2,000-foot Mount Garfield, on the eastern edge of the Book Cliff Range." Credit: Colorado Wine Industry Development Board

Authors Jancis Robinson and Linda Murphy. Credit: Michael Wright Studio

Zester Daily Soapbox contributor Jancis Robinson is the first Master of Wine from outside the wine trade. She has been studying the American wine scene since 1976. Her latest book is "American Wine," which she co-wrote with Linda Murphy. Murphy is the former managing editor of The New York Times' wine website and the first wine section editor of the San Francisco Chronicle, where she won two James Beard Awards.

More from Zester Daily:

» Related: A wine lover's dilemma.

» Closing of Stuff magazine hurts Boston food scene.

» The mystery of almond boneless chicken.

» Busting fish myths: Easy tips for making seafood.

Subscribe to the Lifestyle email.
Life hacks and juicy stories to get you through the week.