04/18/2008 05:12 am ET Updated May 25, 2011

The Other Google/AOL/Yahoo Coalition

Another Web coalition featuring Google, AOL, Yahoo -- and many other Internet players -- has gathered to fight proposed New York state legislation that would curtail targeted advertising and data collection.

The WSJ has a brief summary, but these two quotes summarize even more efficiently why the Web biggies have a tough case to make: Americans are all for free enterprise, but they're also against big government, business, or anyone else snooping on them -- whether or not that's what's really happening:

"[The bill] is unnecessary, most likely unconstitutional, and would have profound implications for the future of Internet advertising and the availability of free content on the Internet," wrote Jim Halpert, general counsel for the State Privacy and Security Coalition, in a letter to Assemblyman Richard Brodsky, the Westchester County Democrat sponsoring the bill.

Mr. Brodsky dismissed the letter. "These guys want the unadulterated right to invade the privacy of the citizens of this state and we're not going to let them do that," he said. "This is why we have governments, not just corporations."

Read more on Silicon Alley Insider