08/15/2011 11:23 am ET Updated Dec 06, 2017

Anne Hathaway Or Carmen Kass: Who Wore It Better? (PHOTOS, POLL)

There's nothing we love more than a "who wore it better" face-off, our favorite kind being the classic battle between model and celebrity (see: Naomi Campbell vs. Beyonce, Karlie Kloss vs. Jennifer Lopez).

So we were delighted to see top model Carmen Kass on the September cover of Elle Spain wearing the exact same Fall 2011 Miu Miu dress donned by Anne Hathaway for Harper's Bazaar's August 2011 issue.

Anne looks every inch the Hollywood golden girl with windswept hair and a wide smile, while Carmen gets her smolder on with smoky eyes and just a hint of side boob.

Take a look below and tell us: who wins the sartorial smack-down?