03/21/2012 07:50 am ET Updated Mar 21, 2012

January Jones & Christina Hendricks: Red Carpet Faceoff! (PHOTOS, POLL)

Most people don't go overboard with the glamorous styling when they attend TimesTalks, those subdued discussion panels hosted in New York by the Gray Lady. After all, this is a world-renowned newspaper, not a glitzy party at Chateau Marmont.

For Tuesday's TimesTalk with the cast of "Mad Men," co-stars January Jones and Christina Hendricks set aside the daring dresses and plunging necklines, choosing demure outfits for the panel.

While January opted for a sheer top pared down with a black blazer, Christina took the opposite direction, choosing to hide her most famous, uh, accessories in a high-collared black dress. Both women pulled their hair back and wore black pumps.

So, who looked lovelier? Check out the pics and vote below!