05/16/2012 06:09 pm ET Updated Dec 06, 2017

Kelly Ripa vs. Ginnifer Goodwin In Roksanda Ilincic: Who Wore It Better? (PHOTOS)

Growing up with rather petite genes, we were always taught to steer clear of clothes that overpowered us. Yet Kelly Ripa and Ginnifer Goodwin both took the same fashion risk, clothing their diminutive frames in a powerful pink dress with oversized bell sleeves.

Goodwin picked the neon dress by Roksanda Ilincic (a favorite of Lady Gaga) back in January at the 2012 People's Choice Awards, offsetting the bright color with black accessories, that edgy cropped haircut and a rather serious red carpet stance.

Ripa, on the other hand, channeled her blonde, bubbly persona on the "Late Show With David Letterman" this week, wearing her hot pink dress with red and pink platform pumps (and an ankle tattoo we'd somehow never noticed before).

Each star wore the dress her way -- but do the mega sleeves overpower them both?

kelly ripa ginnifer goodwin

Vote on more outfits and tell us who wore it better!

Who Wore It Better?