07/10/2012 07:47 am ET Updated Dec 06, 2017

Jennifer Lopez vs. Victoria Beckham: Who Wore It Better? (PHOTOS)

Even though Victoria Beckham's clothing line has a pretty impressive list of celebrity devotees, the designer herself has never seemed to mind stepping out in one of her popular dresses. So when Victoria attended Simon Fuller's birthday at the Roland Mouret store in London yesterday, she picked a design that already had the celeb seal of approval.

As the Daily Mail cleverly spotted, the tangerine sheath that Mrs. Beckham wore last night was the very same fitted number that Jennifer Lopez wore during an episode of American Idol back in April. On Idol, J. Lo brought her usual va va voom factor with a bouncy blowout, hoop earrings and metallic sandals.

For her turn in the dress, Victoria veered more demure, sweeping her hair up and carrying a white clutch as her sole accessory. She paired the look with sky-high, peep-toe pumps, naturally.

So which look do you prefer: Victoria Beckham's pared-down elegance or Jennifer Lopez's flashy take? Check out the photos below and tell us what you think.


jennifer lopez american idol

Who wore all of these ensembles better?

Want more? Be sure to check out HuffPost Style on Twitter, Facebook, Tumblr and Pinterest.