08/10/2012 05:38 pm ET

Caption Contest: Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez

On Tuesday we posted this random photo from our archives on Facebook and Twitter and asked you guys to fill in the dialogue.

A photo (or this photo, anyway) is apparently worth a thousand snarky remarks, so we picked the five best and recreated the photo with those suggestions in the slideshow below. Agree with any of them? Have a different take? Think you can do better? Tell us in the comments!

Caption Contest: The Biebs and Selena Gomez