09/04/2012 12:39 pm ET

Minka Kelly, Chris Evans Dating: Stars Reportedly Rekindle Their Romance

Minka Kelly doesn't mind giving love a second chance.

The 32-year-old actress rekindled her romance with Yankees baseball player Derek Jeter in December 2011, only to call it quits again in March. Now, she's giving love another shot with actor Chris Evans, reports Us Weekly.

The pair were rumored to have briefly dated way back in 2007, and now sources tell the magazine the couple are game for round two.

"She did a number on him him back then, but she reached out to Chris this time," a source told Us Weekly of how their second-time-around romance began, noting that Evans is "still a little insecure, so he's being cautious."

Whatever hesitation he may feel hasn't stopped the new couple's burgeoning relationship. The pair were spotted at Max and Dylans eatery in Evans' hometown of Boston on Aug. 18, and they were seen enjoying Broadway's "The Book of Mormon" on Aug. 24.

Kelly dated Jeter for three years before they broke up the first time in August 2011, and since their second split she has been linked to former "That 70s show" star Wilmer Valderrama. It was also reported that Kelly had a "secret hookup" with actor Jake Gyllenhaal, after things didn't work out with Valderrama.

For his part, Evans has also dipped more than his toe in the Hollywood dating pool. The 31-year-old "Avengers" star has dated Kate Bosworth, Jessica Biel, Gisele Bündchen and Christina Ricci, and has been linked to Stacy Keibler, Emmy Rossum and Dianna Agron.

Celebrity Couples