09/24/2012 04:28 am ET Updated Sep 24, 2012

'Breaking Amish': Jeremiah Gets A Tattoo, But Is This Show Fake? (VIDEO)

Jeremiah took another bold step that would greatly upset traditional Amish communities on "Breaking Amish." He decided it was time to get inked up.

"Once they find out about this, there’s no turning back," he said. But did Jeremiah turn his back on the strictest parts of the Amish tradition before? Just how much of this fish-out-of-water story is true for these young people?

Zap2It details a list of several pieces of evidence that indicates these men and women may have "broken Amish" years ago. Things like Kate submitting photos to modeling sites for a few years. Or how about Rebecca and Abe already having a child together -- they are virtual strangers on the show, only flirting a bit. Has Jeremiah been out more than a decade; already divorced with three kids?

TLC has since come out and said that a lot of the controversies will be addressed in upcoming episodes. They also claim that while some of the alleged "facts" are true, some are not.

Keep tuning in to "Breaking Amish" to find out, Sundays at 10 p.m. ET on TLC.

TV Replay scours the vast television landscape to find the most interesting, amusing, and, on a good day, amazing moments, and delivers them right to your browser.



Emmy 2012 Winners