Josh and Matt first met outside of the musical "Hairspray." After a second chance meeting a few months later at a mutual friend's birthday party, they began to date and it wasn't long before Matt was considering proposing to Josh.
The happy couple got engaged on the day that New York passed marriage equality, after sharing the momentous victory with an entire movie theater.
Now, upon comparing the pricing and possible outcomes between adoption and surrogacy, the couple has decided on surrogate and are awaiting twins.
Check out Josh and Matt's full story in the video above.