CULTURE & ARTS
05/01/2013 03:49 pm ET

Mr. Brainwash Loses Copyright Case For Not Being 'Art' Enough

Getty Images

Just days after Richard Prince triumphantly won his copyright lawsuit, just when we supposedly established that “law does not require that a new work of art comment on any of its source material to qualify as fair use” — today, appropriation rights take a step back. A California judge has ruled that Mr. Brainwash was, in fact, breaking copyright when he appropriated a famous 1977 black and white photograph of Sid Vicious by Dennis Morris.

After surveying Mr. Brainwash’s art, the judge says “most of [the] defendant’s works add certain new elements, but the overall effect of each is not transformative.” Try harder, Brainwash. You’re not using enough decorative fuchsia splatter. How about a little mole doodle or something?

Read more on animalnewyork.com

CONVERSATIONS