A big truth actually came out during the second "Shunning Truth" reunion special for "Breaking Amish: Brave New World." Abe's brother, Andrew, admitted that he and Rebecca had slept together, putting to rest those long-standing rumors.
“It was before Abe and them got together," he explained. "If I’d known the two of them was gonna get together, I would never have done it.”
Andrew said that they'd both been drinking -- Rebecca corroborated this -- and that it was a long time ago. He also said that he regretted it. In fact, he seemed to be more broken up about it than his brother. Abe said he felt fine about everything.
But while this admission solves one rumor, it adds more layers to another bit of speculation. There's long been talk that Andrew may be the father of Rebecca's daughter. Neither Rebecca nor Abe has ever revealed who the girls' father is.
That wasn't the only bit of news that Andrew had to share, though. He revealed that he'll be on the cast of the new spinoff show, "Breaking Amish: LA," which premieres next Sunday at 10 p.m. ET on TLC.
TV Replay scours the vast television landscape to find the most interesting, amusing, and, on a good day, amazing moments, and delivers them right to your browser.