10/23/2013 04:50 pm ET Updated Oct 30, 2013

Details Of Erin Cox's Designated Driver Story Called Into Question


Erin Cox, the student who says she was punished after attempting to drive a drunk friend home from a party, may not be such a hero after all.

Conflicting accounts of the incident are starting to arise several weeks after Cox's title as captain of the North Andover High School volleyball team was revoked.

Earlier this week, a North Andover police officer told The Valley Patriot that Cox’s version of the events may be a “lie.”

"What the media reported was the details of the student and her family and their attorney, and they just ran with it as if her version was fact," the officer told the outlet. "We now know that her version is in dispute, and there is a lot of evidence to show she was at that party a lot longer than she claimed."

Cox previously said she had shown up at the party just as police were arriving. She also said she was sober at the time.

The new revelations come after another North Andover police officer wrote a statement last week swearing that Cox was sober when he met her at the party.

Erin did not have the slightest odor of an alcoholic beverage coming from her person,” Brian Neely said in a statement, according to The North Andover Citizen. “She was polite, articulate, steady on her feet, and very remorseful for her decision to go into the residence but was only helping a friend out that had called her for a ride.”

Last week, district Superintendent Kevin Hutchinson said he could not discuss the details of the case but that “each incident is fully investigated and decided upon based on the individual facts and circumstances,” according to the North Andover Citizen.

Wendy Murphy, the Cox family attorney, has come to her client’s defense in light of the new claims. On Tuesday, she issued a statement on the Valley Patriot website saying, “Silly claims meant to distract public attention and insulate the North Andover School District from shame will not be dignified.”

Her statement also referenced monetary donations that have been offered to the Cox family. She said the family has “growing concerns that people may be using this case to exploit concerned citizens” and that they “have requested no money, received no money, and want no money.”

Matt Holland, the North Andover citizen who started a fund for Cox, takes issue with Murphy’s statement. He says that, at least in his case, the family was fully aware of the money he was raising, and they had expressed to him that they would want to keep it.

After recent revelations about the case, though, he has given back the thousands of dollars raised back to donors. Still, he thinks it’s important to keep in mind that a teenage girl is at the center of the matter.

“Whatever the reason it was blown out of proportion, we still have to consider it’s a 17-year-old, and her health is at stake,” Holland told The Huffington Post. “We should just let this thing go. It happens every weekend all across the country.”



Teacher Controversies