07/14/2014 05:27 pm ET Updated Jul 14, 2014

The Craigslist Killers

AP/Akron Beacon Journal

The preacher placed the ad: Wanted: a caretaker for a remote piece of Appalachian farmland. Housing provided. Bring all your own possessions. More than a hundred men applied; four were hired. The preacher and his "nephew" offered each a ride down to the farm. The men never knew what was going on—what bizarre scheme they'd stumbled upon. What happened next was almost too terrible to believe

Read more on GQ