01/29/2013 06:17 pm ET Updated Mar 31, 2013

Is Fox's Bold and Bloody The Following Too Sadistic for its Own Good?

Fox's profoundly disturbing serial killer drama The Following is unarguably the boldest new series of the broadcast season. In many ways it is also the most problematic, but everyone involved had to know that controversy and criticism would come with such extreme material. If this show had turned out to be just more TV schlock, then it would be easy to ignore, if not condemn as many critics have been happy to do. But the acting, production values and direction that are on proud display in this project demand respect, and with that comes a deeper consideration of the program at hand. Series lead Kevin Bacon as Ryan Hardy, a tormented former FBI agent called out of miserable retirement to help thwart the plans of an especially sinister serial killer he apprehended several years earlier, must already be considered a front-runner for every major television acting award.

Let's begin by addressing the elephant in the industry: Due to truly unfortunate timing, The Following has found itself at the center of the important debate about violence in the media that came to an immediate boil after the school shootings last month in Newtown, Conn. It doesn't necessarily deserve the distinction, at least not where gun violence is concerned. I only recently watched the second, third and fourth episodes that Fox provided for advance media consideration (and I saw the pilot, which I first watched last June, for a second time on a giant screen at Fox's gala premiere for the show at the New York Public Library), and with the gruesome details of each hour still fresh in my mind, I'm comfortable saying that there is much more high-action gunplay in average episodes of numerous popular crime dramas than I have seen in the first four installments of The Following combined. I'm certainly not an expert in such matters, but it would seem that if there is a connection between fictional and real-life gun violence it likely has something to do with gunfire itself.

All that said, the show ought to be a lightning rod for those who object to the escalation of brutal violence against women in contemporary entertainment. Yes, men are killed in The Following, but the number of butchered females far outdistances that of murdered males, and the often-sickening details surrounding the killings of the women will be a turn-off to anyone who has had his or her fill of such stuff.

Many things may impress me about The Following, which I have previously cited as the best new broadcast drama of the season. But with each passing episode, it's difficult to move beyond the unrelenting misery and sadism that informs virtually every minute of this show. I admire quality as much as the next critic, but by the end of Episode 4, the horror of it all was beginning to wear me down. At this point, an awful lot of innocent people have met terrible ends, while Ryan has been tormented and tortured to a greater degree than any other character I can think of from any other television series ever, including certain losers on Lost.

This column continues here.