STYLE & BEAUTY
03/30/2017 11:40 am ET

Un-Retouched Ads Aren't A Huge Money-Maker, But Brands Don't Care

"This was never about the sales."
Denise Bidot appears un-retouched in Target's new swim campaign. 
Target
Denise Bidot appears un-retouched in Target's new swim campaign. 

The use of Photoshop to alter faces and bodies is a point of contention in the fashion industry. For starters, it perpetuates unrealistic beauty standards and causes its fair share of epic fails

That’s why it’s so exciting that there’s an emerging movement to minimize the use of photo-altering tools by brands both big and small. Lonely Lingerie was recently praised for featuring Lena Dunham and Jemima Kirke sans retouching. Modcloth made waves when it pledged to ditch using Photoshop on its models in 2014. Lane Bryant and Target both left Denise Bidot’s stretch marks intact for campaigns in February and March, respectively.

But is going Photoshop-free meant to impact a brand’s bottom line, or is it simply a move made to garner positive attention? As it turns out, the answer might be neither ― and that’s the most exciting news of all. 

Aerie

Aerie is widely celebrated for its un-retouched Aerie Real campaign, which first launched in 2014. The brand has been candid about how the move has positively impacted its sales before, but told The Huffington Post that wasn’t necessarily its main goal.

“We stopped retouching to send an empowering message, and it’s been an added bonus that the campaign has had a positive impact on sales as well,” said Aerie’s global brand president, Jennifer Foyle. That “positive impact” translates to sales growing 20 percent in the 2015 fiscal year and 32 percent in the first quarter of fiscal 2016

Target

Target has had some swings and misses in the past when it comes to inclusion, whether it be through mislabeling items or offending customers with poorly named products. In recent years, though, it has used fashion-forward plus-size lines and Photoshop-free advertising as a way to connect more with its audience.

“Target knows that every woman deserves to look great and feel great in their swimwear, and we’re committed to offering a range of styles for every body,” Target spokeswoman Jessica Carlson told The Huffington Post. As far as sales go? “Target has the number one market share in the swim category and throughout this season (beginning in January 2017) we’ve seen strong sales across our swim assortment driven by the breadth of trend, style and size options.”

Target was also No. 1 in swimwear last year, but the brand has noticed a positive impact when it comes to connecting with customers on social media.

“Engagement with the #TargetSwim campaign content from Target guests has been positive,” Carlson said, adding, “specifically in regard to both the influencers that we worked with and our approach to the imagery used.”

Target hit a bullseye with this one. 
Target
Target hit a bullseye with this one. 

Modcloth

One brand that refrains from retouching its models, despite not seeing a financial impact, is Modcloth. “This was never about the sales,” Nicole Haase, VP of Merchandising for Modcloth told The Huffington Post. “But while we aren’t seeing any immediate impacts to sales, I feel strongly that our pledge to celebrating women’s bodies as they will benefit both the brand and our customers in the longer term.”

A 2016 Modcloth swim shoot. 
Modcloth
A 2016 Modcloth swim shoot. 

If Modcloth isn’t necessarily seeing an uptick in sales as a result of its pledge not to retouch, that doesn’t mean it’s not having a payoff ― especially on social media.

“The followers on all of our platforms have gone up, but more than everything so has the engagement on the posts, especially when we use our community as models,” Haase said. 

Aerie has social media to thank for growing its community, too. While Foyle said this all “started with a simple pledge not to retouch,” today #Aeriereal “is everything we are and in everything we do as a brand.”

That could not have been possible without its major social media initiatives: The brand commissioned the “world’s largest un-retouched selfie” in 2015. Its “Love the Swim You’re In” campaign raises money for the National Eating Disorders Association, asking fans to post their un-retouched swim photos on social media.

It could be said, then, that the customers are what make this movement work, more so than the models. Giving customers an opportunity to see what clothing looks like on people who look more like them might encourage them to buy it. 

Regardless of the financial payoffs, one thing is for sure ― brands are more committed than ever to reaching their customers on a personal level ― here’s hoping that translates to even less retouching in the future. 

HuffPost

BEFORE YOU GO

CONVERSATIONS