03/14/2014 01:20 pm ET Updated Dec 06, 2017

Committee Chair May Stonewall Medicaid Expansion Bills Early in FL

Many of us have heard the facts and figures regarding Medicaid expansion in Florida.

It would cover 1.2 million people who are now uninsured. The federal government would provide $51 billion to Florida over the next 10 years to offset most of the cost. For the first three years, the federal government pays the entire cost.

That money would also be used to pay hospitals for care they are required to provide for poor patients and cover the $487 million per year currently spent on the state's Medically Needy Medicaid program.

Last year, the state Senate agreed to accept the federal funds, but the House refused. It endorsed a "free-market solution" that would cost the state more and cover far fewer people. Medicaid expansion failed and Florida retained its title as one of the great donor states of the nation.

And it looks like the House is ready to do it again.

Sen. Rene Garcia (R-Hialeah) has filed a bill that once again attempts to accept federal funds and expand Medicaid.

On the House side, Rep. Amanda Murphy (D-New Port Richey) filed the companion bill to expand Medicaid. Both bills mirror the approach that the Florida Senate proposed by ACA committee chairman Sen. Joe Negron (R-Palm City) which accepts federal funds and expands Medicaid using state infrastructure.

The key to start the discussion in the House lies on the shoulders of the chairman of the Select Committee on the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, Rep. Richard Corcoran (R-Lutz). He needs to put it on the agenda for his committee.


Sen. Negron and Rep. Corcoran at a joint ACA committee meeting.
Photo courtesy of Tampa Bay Times.

If the bill does not pass this first hurdle, two things occur:

1. The bill never gets the debate it deserves. Opinions have shifted on a great number of things since last session and the conversation needs to be re-opened.

2. Florida will once again reject expansion and the federal money we would have gotten will go to pay for health care in other states.

In my conversations with Corcoran recently, he was 100 percent behind the anti-expansion House bill he helped to craft last year, but no one so far has reintroduced it this year.

In the Senate, Garcia's bill must first go to the Health Policy Committee, chaired by Sen. Aaron Bean, who has shown a preference for the Florida Health Choices program. That's an attempt at a state-based, highly limited insurance exchange that was begun in 2009 and has yet to be fully implemented. However, the plan is so limited that it technically cannot be called an "insurance exchange" because the products are so limited they do not meet the legal definition of insurance. Bean has not put Garcia's bill on his committee agenda either.

Considering the importance of the Medicaid expansion question, it's critical to allow discussion of any expansion bills.

We hope that Corcoran and Bean will open the committee to discussion.

Otherwise, the Affordable Care Act will be, for the most part, yet another unfunded mandate that Florida cannot afford.