Much has been written about the "mommy wars" and almost all of it speculates on the costs to mothers and children of the decision to stay at home or stay in the paid workforce. In this "war," women who have continued to work full-time while having children look down at their stay-at-home counterparts for backing away from the workforce. In return, those women who are caring for their children full-time, denigrate the parenting of women who have combined work outside the home with motherhood.
Most women writing about this topic still have children in their homes and thus can only guess how they will feel about their decision, when it is all said and done. But a generation of time has passed and there is no reason to speculate, we have the data, if not the answers.
Millennials were raised by women who came of age after the feminist revolution. They were raised by mothers who graduated from college in equal numbers as their fathers and entered the workforce with similar qualifications. They were raised by the first generation of women who truly had a choice. These children are leaving home or have left and the fall-out of their mothers' decisions, the benefits and the regrets can now be examined.
The War Within
I don't believe that women are at war with each other, but rather that any hint of a clash sells copy. If there is a conflict, it is inside each of us, not between us. The only mommy war I waged was with myself.
We wage a war with ourselves from the moment we drive away from our babies and go back to work. Sometimes the professional in us wins, sometimes the mom. We wage war within ourselves when we stay home to nurture our children and then berate ourselves for "wasting our education" and not living up to the dream we had during our younger years. Some of us find an uneasy peace, others never quell the internal battle.
I am just going to put it out there and say I have huge regrets about leaving the full-time workforce. I stopped working in an office when my older sons were two and three and I was contemplating having their brother. I had a job in which I left home before my children awoke and came home to find them in pajamas, showered, fed and ready to wind down for the evening.
If I wanted to know what was happening with my children, I asked my nanny and at some point, for me, that didn't feel like parenting.
So I found a way to work from home by writing books, joining boards and volunteering my time. Like so many other women, I opted for flexibility.
I regret not using my degrees for the purpose they were intended, but when I look upon my grown and nearly grown sons, it is very hard to have a moment's doubt that spending the last 17 years with them was the right decision.
Clearly I am of two minds, torn as to whether I could have or should have done things differently. I think that if technology had allowed me to work differently, more flexibly, I might have kept working outside of our home. But since I am ambivalent, I asked others for their retrospective thoughts and I am going to ask you for yours.
Sharon "I don't regret giving up my career at all - though there were times when I wished I was earning money, and there were times when the tedium of motherhood made a regular job seem glamorous and fun."
Linda "Staying home with my kids and beginning a new career as a writer and then editor was fantastic -- but in hindsight I see that if I had stuck it out, I would probably have landed a position at a prestigious university in the area and achieved my original dream career and be doing something that I would feel good about."
Mary Dell "I was gung-ho about working as a new MBA and loved my Manhattan job, before I had my first baby. Then, with a small child at home, an hour commute each way, babysitting to juggle and a husband who began traveling quite a bit, the stress began to outweigh the pleasure. I was a pretty tired mom when I arrived home to greet my firstborn and he deserved better. I hope that as I stepped down from the workforce, to job share, and then to stay home full-time, that both kids got a more engaged mom than they would have otherwise. I know it made me happier. "
Amy "I don't handle stress well and I know for me personally, that I would not have balanced work/home well. What I wanted most, was to be fully present and enjoy my kids and, for me, staying home was how I accomplished that. I did begin to feel regret as they grew. I began saying to my husband "what was I thinking?" as I moved into the "what do I do now, I'm 50 and jobless stage." But in the bigger picture, I know it was right for me and them."
Pam "And sometimes I feel like a 'loser' for not working outside the home! I also have to say that working in a male-dominated environment as I did I was able to get the male perspective on things - and believe me, they have as many concerns about their children as women do. They just don't have these guilt games thrust upon them by our culture."
Both Sides of the Battle Lines
The reality is that, to some extent, I had a choice, something most men I know never had. The fact that it's not a perfect choice, is laid out by Michael Winerip when he discusses how both he and his wife each took a decade on the home front and a decade as the primary breadwinner. Each lost something in their decade at home as they did in their decade in high career mode. Men are not immune to the pull of the home front. Recent Pew research found that only 23% of mothers felt that they spent too little time with their children while 46% of fathers felt their time was inadequate.
If there is one thing life teaches us it is that we never get to wind back the tape, never again watch a movie with our 6-year old cuddled in our lap or spend hours sledding on a snow day with our 10-year old. We can go back to work, but we cannot go back to their childhood. Work is still there, the children are not. I am not naive enough to think I didn't make a professional sacrifice but not foolish enough to say that many who worked full-time didn't make a personal one, as well.