Immigration has surfaced as one of the top issues in this Republican
presidential primary -- thanks in no small part to the United States'
ever-growing population of Hispanics, now the country's second-largest
Despite the voting power of this sizable bloc, the Republican candidates
haven't distinguished themselves as friends of immigrants. Former
Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney and former Pennsylvania Senator Rick
Santorum have effectively called for mass self-deportations. Both Romney and
former House Speaker Newt Gingrich have said that they would not grant
citizenship to college graduates who are the children of undocumented
Such anti-immigrant posturing attempts to divide this country into two
groups: "real" Americans -- whatever that means -- and those who are somehow
inauthentic. These divisions don't just marginalize entire groups of people
who call America home -- they tacitly authorize the powerful to disregard
the rules of civil society.
The first group's attitudes have driven the introduction of anti-immigration
laws across the country, including, for example, the controversial new state
laws that have caused many Hispanics -- both documented and undocumented -- to leave these states. Such legislation is playing out against a backdrop of
the Tea Party's divisive rhetoric, which has pushed the national debate far
to the right. Toxic attitudes cannot, unfortunately, be confined; they have
a way of spreading to the rest of society.
Some in the Tea Party movement may be genuinely motivated by concerns about
the economy or social issues. But the movement has also given shelter to
activists who feel the need to cast others as different and unworthy in the
face of the demographic shifts the United States has begun to experience.
The country's past is replete with examples of what can happen when some
Americans begin to think of themselves as entitled. In August, an especially
unsettling case came to light after being buried for more than half a
Between 1946 and 1948, the U.S. Public Health Service conducted experiments
on hundreds of Guatemalans, who were intentionally infected with sexually
transmitted diseases to test the efficacy of penicillin -- without informing
the subjects of the risk.
Worse, this was not the first time the U.S. Public Health Service had
engaged in such unethical practices. Similar experiments had also been
conducted on African-American men, beginning in the 1930s, in Tuskegee, Ala.
Those experiments didn't end until 1972, as a result of legal action and
How could the United States, the leader of the Free World, which had just
emerged victorious from World War II, secretly countenance such disregard
for the lives of a neighboring nation's citizens -- not to mention its own?
The experiments took place even as the nation was publicly launching the
Marshall Plan -- one of history's greatest humanitarian efforts -- to
rebuild Europe in the wake of the war.
Wasn't this the America of the "Greatest Generation," the one that created
the biggest middle class the world had ever seen, broadened access to higher
education, built an extraordinary interstate highway system, and grew a
powerful manufacturing sector during what would become known as "The
It happened because some Americans came to believe that there was one set of
rules for the privileged and another for everyone else.
This was the America that used its military and covert forces in Central
America to protect U.S. corporate interests during the 1950s. It was the
America that did not guarantee the right of its black citizens to vote until
This was an America that felt it could act with impunity when it came to
poor Spanish-speaking foreigners, just as it felt it could act without
restraint within its own borders when it came to the rights of its own
disenfranchised black citizens.
The government has a duty to protect its citizens, even from itself.
This is an America we cannot allow ourselves to be again. The challenge in
this still-new century is for Americans to embrace the changing world they
face and to appreciate the strength -- and, yes, exceptionalism -- that can
emerge from a genuine, in the words of President Reagan, "shining city on a