THE BLOG
09/17/2014 12:35 pm ET Updated Dec 06, 2017

Why People Love -- and Love to Hate -- Pumpkin Beers

Shutterstock / MaxyM

I've yet to meet a beer style that has more people either lovin' or hatin' on it than pumpkin beer.

This delicious and seasonally-based style is so well liked that in the month of October it rivals the popularity of India pale ale (IPA), the top-selling craft beer style in supermarkets across America. In fact, pumpkin beers are so popular that for the first time ever, the style will have its own dedicated category at the 2014 Great American Beer Festival. Yet for every fan, there's someone else defiantly taking a stand against it.

Why do some beer lovers have their knickers in a bunch over pumpkin beers? Is it the fact that pumpkin beers (along with the rest of the seemingly endless pumpkin-flavored foods and products) are often released before fall properly begins? Or is it the flavor combination of pumpkin and pie spices that creates the divide? Maybe it's the way some brewers use alternative forms of pumpkin that are not picked fresh from the vine and put straight into the kettle?

To these questions, I say: "Who cares?" Yes, that's right, I said it. What is gained by bashing or dismissing a beer style or brand?

We as beer lovers are influencers, and new beer drinkers are impressionable--just as we once were. So if you don't like a beer or style, don't hate. Instead, let others decide for themselves.

No one objects to department stores putting out bathing suits in February, long before you'll be heading to the beach. Everyone loves the taste of grandma's famous pumpkin pie recipe--and heaven help you if you object to her making it with the same canned ingredients she's been using since before you were born, kiddo. But for some reason, people think objections like these are legitimate when it comes to pumpkin beer.

Even USA Today's beer columnist has joined the conversation:

"Yes, it's not even Labor Day and pumpkin beers have overrun my favorite beer boutiques. Oktoberfest fans will have to hunt through a patch of pumpkin beers to find those seasonal favorites. OK, I may be exaggerating...a bit."

Fall is for whatever fits my fancy at the time, including Oktoberfests, wet hop beers, porters, stouts, pilseners, barley wines, and hell yes, it's for enjoying seasonally-specific and appropriate spiced pumpkin beers made from fresh, frozen, canned or otherwise preserved squash.

Timing is Everything

Across the board, late summer is the time that retailers use to get us into the fall mood. Why should it be different for craft brewers? Brewing, packaging and marketing a beer takes time, not to mention if the beer is to be barrel-aged, or requires longer to ferment. And timing is important when brewers consider keeping up with their core brands while also adding a seasonal beer.

Plus, thirsty pumpkin lovers expect their favorite seasonal to arrive on time and in quantity. Google searches for "pumpkin beer" spike every year from late summer through the fall, exceeding searches for all other seasonal beer terms combined, as you can see in the graph below compiled by Brewers Association staff economist Bart Watson.

Watson says those searches really do correlate with the beers we buy and drink. In 2013, pumpkin beers led a surge in seasonal sales, which were lagging behind the ever popular India pale ale by about 125,000 cases going into that August. The release of pumpkin beers put seasonals at the front of the craft beer pack by 300,000 cases during September and October, and could do so again this year.

2014-09-17-pumpkinbeer.jpg Here are just a few of 2014 pumpkin beers from small and independent craft brewers:
  • Boxcarr Pumpkin Porter | Starr Hill Brewery | Crozet, VA
  • Flat Jack Pumpkin Ale | Flat 12 Bierwerks | Indianapolis, IN
  • Gourd Shorts (pumpkin ale) | Florida Beer Co. | Cape Canaveral, FL
  • Kentucky Pumpkin Barrel Ale | Alltech Lexington Brewing and Distilling Company | Lexington, KY
  • Mavericks Pumpkin Harvest Ale | Half Moon Bay Brewing Co. | Half Moon Bay, CA
  • Oak Jacked (imperial pumpkin ale) | Uinta Brewing Co. | Salt Lake City, UT
  • Potosi Stingy Jack Pumpkin Ale | Potosi Brewing Co. | Potosi, WI
  • Pumking | Southern Tier Brewing Co. | Lakewood, NY
  • Pumpkin Ale | Blackstone Brewing Co.® | Nashville, TN
  • Pumpkin Ale | Rivertown Brewing Co. | Lockland, OH
  • Pumpkinfest | Terrapin Beer Co. | Athens, GA
  • Roadsmary's Baby (rum-aged pumpkin ale) | Two Roads Brewing Co. | Stratford, CT
  • Rum Punk (Rum barrel-aged pumpkin beer) | Joseph James Brewing Co., Inc | Henderson, NV
  • Samhain Pumpkin Porter | DESTIHL Brewery | Bloomington, IL
  • Samuel Adams Fat Jack (double pumpkin ale) | Samuel Adams | Boston, MA
  • Smuttynose Pumpkin Ale | Smuttynose Brewing Co. | Hampton, NH
  • Wick for Brains Pumpkin Ale | Nebraska Brewing Co. | La Vista, NE
  • Witch's Hair Pumpkin Ale | Twisted Manzanita Ales & Spirits | East County San Diego, CA

Julia Herz is publisher of CraftBeer.com, a Certified Cicerone®, BJCP beer judge, and craft beer program director for the Brewers Association. Follow Julia Herz on Twitter: www.twitter.com/HerzMuses