This piece first ran on the On Being website
I played the Christmas game when my children were little. I was not reckless with the sense of wonder that collects around Santa Claus and the Baby Jesus and, alas, morphs the two together. I bought presents. Some years I even decorated a tree. Though some years I could let their father do this -- a rare plus of raising children in two households. As he is an Episcopal priest, they would also go to church with him, leaving me to stew in my Scrooge-friendly juices.
Don't get me wrong. I enjoy giving gifts. I think ritual is essential to human flourishing and to family life. We need more of it. I have a deep reverence for the incarnational heart of Christianity. I even still recognize faint glimmers of these impulses in the trappings of Christmas as we know it now, 21st-century style. But I think this season has more overwhelmingly become a distortion of them -- a distortion of us as a culture, as humans, as families. And I for one am done.
Why do I dislike Christmas now? Let me count the ways.
I don't like -- don't approve, refuse to throw myself into -- the spirit of obligatory gift-giving. In my lifetime, this has become existentially linked to a commercial orgy that has now even co-opted the ritual angle. We have Good Friday and Maundy Thursday; we have Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Unlike Good Friday and Maundy Thursday, however (though like "fiscal cliff") these terms are repeated and reported by the most serious of journalists. Like all mantras of ritual, they work on us from the inside. They are an economic event by which we measure a certain kind of cultural health.
This form of cultural health is not health at all. It is overwhelmingly an exercise in excess and trivia.
When I was growing up, even in a financially comfortable family, we waited all year for the new bicycle, the new Barbie, the new book. Christmas was a reward for a kind of patience. It was, in some sense, an exercise in delayed gratification. Those gifts were even presumed to be a reward for a year of goodness -- a proposition, to be sure, that always had its fluff factor.
But we who are fortunate to have money to spend on Christmas presents inhabit a world now where the new bicycle -- in modern-day translation: the new phone, the new video game, the latest greatest shoes -- are purchased on demand throughout the year. I routinely wake up to find that my teenaged son has left my laptop desktop open to the "checkout" page, usually of a sports clothing website, where he has graciously filled in all the fields but my credit card number. I don't always buy what he wants, but I cave in more than I'm happy to admit. That's January through November.
Then there is the religious distortion of Christmas. Good Christians out there who do this with dignity, I don't mean you. In most of the churches I've attended as an adult, Christmas is dressed up as a children's holiday. A play. Not really for grown ups, not really about us. Make no mistake, I've teared up at that re-enactment of the manger scene many times myself, especially when my own children were sheep. It does not begin to do justice to the message of God become human.
When I became a mother for the first time, I was studying at Yale Divinity School, learning vocabulary like "Christology" -- all the ways Christians have pondered the complex notion of Christ as both fully divine and fully human for the past two thousand years. So it was with incredulity and not a little annoyance that I found myself, in a state of severe sleep deprivation, singing "Away in a Manger" where "the little Lord Jesus no crying he makes." Please.
More recently, there is also the maddeningly superficial way we've thrown other holidays into the mix, subsuming them all into general cultural buzz. The December that the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal was full-blown, my daughter traipsed through the house playing with her imaginary friends and singing "Oh Monica! Oh Monica!" to the tune of "Oh Hanukkah!"
Here's what I take seriously. There is something audacious and mysterious and reality-affirming in the assertion that has stayed alive for two thousand years that God took on eyes and ears and hands and feet, hunger and tears and laughter and the flu, joy and pain and gratitude and our terrible, redemptive human need for each other. It's not provable, but it's profoundly humanizing and concretely and spiritually exacting. And it's no less rational -- no more crazy -- than economic and political myths to which we routinely deliver over our fates in this culture, to our individual and collective detriment.
So here's what I'm thinking about this Christmas. Recently I followed up on a promise I've been making myself for years: to wash and sort and give away all the good clothing my kids have outgrown as they've left childhood behind. It's embarrassing that I never took the time to do this all along. In the course of digging around for where to donate, I stumbled on the site of a charity that works with homeless teenagers. It turns out that they're not asking in the first instance for all these Levis and good-as-new, cool t-shirts. They're asking for donations of socks and coats. They're asking for newly purchased underwear, noting that most of us take for granted our ever-renewable supplies of clean underwear that fits.
I'm not going to buy any presents this year. We will go shopping as a family for these homeless teenagers, and I'll try to be honest about the equivalent I would spend on my own children on the commercial holy days if I believed in them. I report this in some hope of feeding a little rebellion I sense many of us are quietly tending. But I also make it public to be sure I follow through.
As I said, we need each other. And that impulse, surely, is deep in the original heart even of the most secular things like Santa Claus and surrounding your home with lights: examining what we are to each other and experiencing that, sometimes when we do this, something transcendent happens.