Barbecue Secrets From Carolina Pitmaster Ed Mitchell

He even goes to the trouble of serving his pork sandwiches on house-baked buns (crusty where the buttered side hit the griddle, but Charmin-soft in the center), with additional crunch supplied by a fried pork rind.
09/28/2015 03:10 pm ET Updated Dec 06, 2017

2015-09-25-1443191843-6909848-EdMitchell4630x407.jpg

Ed Mitchell has opened--and closed--some of the most celebrated barbecue joints in North Carolina. His latest venture was a slick neon and glass restaurant with a designer bar next to Bull Durham Stadium--about as different as his previous establishment--a cinderblock joint called The Pit.

But whatever the vicissitudes of the business, one taste of Mitchell's pulled pork--the meat moist, the smoke scent subtle but unmistakable, the vinegar sauce peppery-sharp enough to make you sit up and take notice, but not so fierce as to make you sweat--lets you know you're eating the real deal. In a state where depressingly few barbecue joints still burn hardwood, Ed not only uses hickory and oak logs, but soaks them in vinegar for extra flavor. He even goes to the trouble of serving his pork sandwiches on house-baked buns (crusty where the buttered side hit the griddle, but Charmin-soft in the center), with additional crunch supplied by a fried pork rind.

Mitchell was 67 years old when I did this interview and he looked the part of the Carolina pit master he cultivates, from his grizzled beard to his bib overalls. "I wanted to bring back the foods and flavors I remember as a kid," he says. That means smoking a whole 225-pound hog to make that pulled pork sandwich, "because you need meat from the shoulder, from the ham, and from the belly," Ed says. "I don't want people to misjudge the restaurant: just because it looked nice, doesn't mean we don't cook authentic." To make sure you knew that, he installed a closed circuit television, so you could watch Ed's ribs, brisket, and miraculous whole hogs come off the wood-burning stainless steel pit that Ed designed himself.

Special techniques?

I'm the odd bird out. Most guys cook low and slow. I cook hot and fast. I build a seriously hot fire and bank the coals around the hog. Then I close all the vents and let it cook overnight.

Temperature sweet spot?

500 degrees to start with. I gradually bring the temperature down to 250 degrees.

Favorite fuel?

I use charcoal briquettes as a base, adding 60 percent oak logs and 40 percent hickory logs for smoke flavor. I "season" the logs in a tub of water flavored with vinegar, onions, and garlic.

What's in your rub/barbecue sauce?

The usual: salt, black pepper, red pepper, and garlic and onion powder in the rub. Cider vinegar, crushed red pepper, salt, sugar and black pepper in the sauce. I'm not trying to reinvent the wheel.

SIGN UP for Steven Raichlen's UP IN SMOKE newsletter to learn more about barbecue!

--

Steven Raichlen is the author of the Barbecue! Bible cookbook series and the host of Project Smoke on public television. His web site is BarbecueBible.com.