05/31/2013 10:43 am ET Updated Jul 31, 2013

No Safe Bets in Mayoral Race

Now that the third ring of the circus is complete with the arrival of Anthony Weiner's high-wire act to the mayoral race, perhaps we can try to take a sober look at why this election really matters for our city's future.

What is the single most important thing a mayor does? You can all put your hands down now. Of course, it's public safety and there's little we've heard from the present field of leading Democratic contenders that offers comfort that New York will continue to be the safest city in America in the post-Bloomberg-Kelly era.

Let's rewind the tape two decades, to 1993, when a crusading prosecutor named Rudy Giuliani stepped into Gracie Mansion and installed an innovative police commissioner, Bill Bratton, to execute the "broken windows" theory of policing -- namely, that by cracking down on low-level crimes we could restore law and order to a city many called "ungovernable."

With a boost in the number of police on the beat from Mayor David Dinkins' and Speaker Peter Vallone's "Safe Streets" initiative, Giuliani and Bratton flooded high-crime areas through an innovative program called "CompStat." A city that had once seen more than six murders a day was on an improving trajectory for two decades.

Now, after 20 years of "assertive policing," a city of more than 8 million averages about one murder a day -- that's more than 1,600 lives saved each year from the "Wild West" of the early 1990s.

So, what does the current crop of leading Democratic mayoral candidates suggest we do? Let's neuter the police commissioner with an Inspector General and much tighter regulations. Let's send a message to criminals that it's safe once again to walk the streets carrying a gun.

The Republican candidates, John Catsimatidis and Joe Lhota, offer some hope on public safety, but they have to much more forcefully make this a defining issue in the upcoming campaign.

As a parent and someone who grew up in New York in the 1970s and 1980s -- and was mugged twice in broad daylight on the Upper West Side as a teen -- I am very fearful that our city is on the verge of giving up the public safety gains of the past two decades.

You can criticize Rudy Giuliani and Mike Bloomberg all you want -- and for different reasons both deserve some measure of opprobrium on issues like public education and growing inequality -- but they both kept our city safe.

This led to record numbers of families staying in the five boroughs to raise their kids. Record numbers of visitors coming to New York, which helped fuel part of our economy. Numerous large companies expanding or relocating to New York not just because it is a world-class city, but because it is one of the SAFEST world-class cities.

As you evaluate the numerous mayoral candidates in the coming three months, ask yourself this question first and foremost: who will keep in place the successful policing policies that has made New York safe from crime and terrorism? Who will pick a great police commissioner and give them the support they need? Who will figure out how to pay for more cops because our "thin blue line" is now stretched with only 35,000 uniformed police (compared to 41,000 a decade ago)?

Those are the important questions before us. Not whether Anthony Weiner's wife has forgiven him for his stupid actions, that Christine Quinn has overcome bulimia and alchoholism, that John Liu has not been able to keep his fundraising staff from committing misdeeds or that Bill DeBlasio's wife was once a lesbian.

What really matters is, who has the same strong spine Rudy Giuliani and Mike Bloomberg had to keep New York safe?

Tom Allon, president of City and State media, was a Liberal-party backed candidate for mayor in 2013 before he left the race to return to the private sector.