Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Janet Kinosian

Janet Kinosian

Posted: November 9, 2010 12:41 PM

Is Someone Killing Your Next Pet?


2010-11-09-A821459b.jpgIf you're an animal lover, and by some counts there are over 100 million of us in the U.S., please take some time this week -- National Animal Shelter Reform Week -- to educate yourself about what really goes on at your local animal shelter.

Running alongside the Humane Society of America's National Animal Shelter Appreciation Week of Nov. 7 to 13, The No-Kill Advocacy Center -- a group which works to stop the systematic killing of animals inside our country's shelter system -- has launched the special week to focus attention on what's really going on inside our country's animal shelter system.

Some questions to ask your local shelter: Do you euthanize animals for space? What is your adoption rate and do you hold mobile, off-site adoptions? Do you have a fostering program? Are you a No-Kill facility and if not, ask to speak to the director and find out specific future plans to lower euthanasia rates. These are just a few beginning questions to ask.

Says Nathan Winograd, Director and Founder of the NKAC on why it's so important for the public to reform and take back their animal shelter systems:

Many people believe that if there were alternatives, shelters would not kill because they are staffed with benevolent animal lovers, laboring against overwhelming odds and offering a humane death only when necessary. Because we could not do it [kill healthy animals], we assume they do it because they have no choice. However the vast majority of [these shelters] have a paltry number of adoptions and staggeringly high rates of killing. The facts, tragically and frequently tell a very different story.

2010-11-09-A823613a.jpgSo the National Animal Shelter Week is about education -- teaching people who don't know about animal sheltering in the US what they should find out. It's also about action -- doing something no matter how big or small to push that line forward to the day that animal shelter killing in America is no longer an option.

Says Winograd:

Today, there are about 3,500 regressive shelter directors holding back the will of 100,000,000 pet-loving Americans. These shelters are being paid for by the citizens of our nation through their tax and philanthropic dollars. These shelters do not belong to their directors, to the staff, or to the board members. They belong to the people. In some communities, there is no doubt that animal lovers will face an uphill battle [to reform their shelter], so it is not going to be a slam dunk. But by persevering, they can win.

The week, he says, is also to celebrate those reformers who have stayed the course and won:

Every reformer who has succeeded in forcing reforms on their shelter has had periods of doubt. But they stuck to the principles and they prevailed. Each community that has achieved success was as regressive as those that continue killing. We now have no-kill communities all over the country: in California, New York, Utah, Virginia, Kansas, Colorado, Indiana, Kentucky, Nevada, and more. These are open admission animal control shelters saving all healthy and treatable animals. But rather than emulate those communities, rather than learn from them, most shelters turn a blind eye and continue doing what they have always done, by blaming the public for their own failures.

He notes that we already have the toughest hurdle jumped in any social reform fight, populace desire:

Unlike other social movements which had to win the hearts and minds of the people before they succeeded, we don't. We already have the people on our side because they love dogs, cats, and other companion animals. And those other social movements prevailed. So can we. In fact, despite all those things that separate us as Americans, people of all walks of life want to build a better world for the animals.

Here are two super easy things I am doing next week (I'm sure you can think of many).

2010-11-09-8989.jpgIn my e-mail signature line I'll include this: "What if the killing of animals inside U.S. shelters existed only in history books?" and share the link to the No-Kill Advocacy Center's website on my Facebook and Twitter pages.

Put out a simple flyer to a few hundred neighbor's mailboxes about the National Animal Shelter Reform week and why they should learn about what's happening at our local shelters, and provide names and contact numbers for them to call.

Let us know how you plan to celebrate National Animal Shelter Reform Week. We'll share the information so we all help give our companion animals the best chance at the great life they deserve. Is your shelter No-Kill? If not, why not? If they are, let us know where you live so others can celebrate their success.

We need to stop this madness. Now.

2010-11-09-dogbeinginjectedwithpoison.jpg


Please join the discussion at: www.facebook.com/nokilladvocacycenter.

Janet Kinosian is a veteran Los Angeles journalist and writes for The Los Angeles Times, Reader's Digest, People, Saturday Evening Post among many. She provides Media Consulting at www.janetkinosian.com.

 

Follow Janet Kinosian on Twitter: www.twitter.com/STWBYF4

If you're an animal lover, and by some counts there are over 100 million of us in the U.S., please take some time this week -- National Animal Shelter Reform Week -- to educate yourself about what rea...
If you're an animal lover, and by some counts there are over 100 million of us in the U.S., please take some time this week -- National Animal Shelter Reform Week -- to educate yourself about what rea...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 86
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jmcaninch68
Teacher, activist, animal rescuer.
05:43 PM on 11/20/2010
Please join the No Kill Advocacy Group: http://www.nokilladvocacycenter.org/index.html

And No Kill Nation: http://www.facebook.com/NOKILLNATION
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Simonsaid
11:06 AM on 11/18/2010
I wonder if a lot of these employees at the kill shelters with low adoption rates are in a mindset just to keep their jobs and the way their systems are run to keep it the way it is because it works for them.

There is no way I could work at a kill shelter.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pixie12
A wise man proportions his belief to the evidence
02:26 PM on 11/16/2010
There is no such this as a NO KILL shelter. They either take animals in until they are at capacity, and then turn them away when they are full. If all of the animals shelters are FULL (and they are) what happens to that animal that doesn't make it in? It's gets DUMPED, killed, left for dead, put in a sack and thrown in the garbage. Fat lot of good that NO KILL shelter did. Now it's still homeless and got to suffer to boot!

It's better to take them and humanely put them down than to see them dumped and suffer by all sorts of horrible ways. Wake up people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pixie12
A wise man proportions his belief to the evidence
02:19 PM on 11/16/2010
Apparently either this blogger gets to delete comments she doesn't like, or Huffpo edits because my post was deleted. I guess people can't handle the real truth that it's not totally the animal shelters, it's the people and the focus of this article is way way off. I'm in the animal rescue trenches and I spoke the truth, but nobody will hear what I have to say because it was deleted. Shame.
11:30 AM on 11/12/2010
Thank you Janet for always speaking up for the animals!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sporty1
being me
01:03 PM on 11/11/2010
It certainly is heart breaking I agree. I want a dog but must go thru so much fol de rol to get one that my options seem limited
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Janet Kinosian
07:02 PM on 11/10/2010
sorry, looks like the PDF won't work as a link. go to www.nokilladvocacycenter.org and type in animal control reform - the PDF and info pages should work.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Janet Kinosian
07:00 PM on 11/10/2010
here is a good link from the NKAC on Animal Reform: step by step http://www.nokilladvocacycenter.org/pdf/Reforming%20Animal%20Control.pdf
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
aligatorhardt
empty on purpose
05:53 PM on 11/10/2010
What are the solutions to unwanted pets? Obviously we should continue to neuter our pets, but many people do not. The authors offer no solutions.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Janet Kinosian
06:41 PM on 11/10/2010
I believe in mandatory spay/nueter laws. Los Angeles has them. Not sure how they're working so far...
12:54 PM on 11/16/2010
Mandatory spay/neuter in Los Angeles has led to a 30% increase in shelter intake and killing because people who cannot afford the cost of spay/neuter surgeries are having to surrender their animals to Animal Control. The ASPCA did a study on mandatory spay/neuter laws and concluded that such laws have never worked, anywhere:
http://www.aspca.org/about-us/policy-positions/mandatory-spay-neuter-laws.html

What works is the programs and policies of the No Kill Equation (low-cost and free spay/neuter, trap-neuter-and-release of cats, increased adoptions, foster program, marketing, etc.):
http://www.nokilladvocacycenter.org/nokillequation.html
11:20 PM on 11/11/2010
@aligatorhardt, see this link for the "no kill equation" - a group of programs that, when implemented together, have shown success in implementing no-kill. http://www.nokilladvocacycenter.org/nokillequation.html
02:30 PM on 11/10/2010
Remember folks, Winograd (No Kill Nation), is AGAINST mandatory spay/neuter. They do advocate low cost altering programs, which is great, but many people are still too lazy or ignorant to utilize this. I live in the South in a county of approximately 40,000 people. Our local Humane Society has been established for over 30 years. Had low cost S/N for a long time. Have off site adoptions. Pretty much anyone with the very small adoption fee can have an animal. No screening-instant gratification. Last year they decided to go 'No Kill' after a board member passed out 'Redemption' to all the board members to read. Now, a year later they are failing miserably. The S/N program has been ended due to lack of funds. The area they serve has been narrowed due to lack of funds. the funds, volunteers, fosters, adopters they expected because they were going 'No Kill', did not materialize. The waiting list for animals needing to get into the shelter is over 500 and that represents many, many months or longer. More animals are dumped, neglected, shot, etc. than ever and the small County animal control is over run and having to kill all those the HS can't fit in.
01:55 PM on 11/10/2010
So, we shouldn't blame the public for the killing? Do shelters breed or steal these animals in order to satify their 'love' of killing????? Um, Noooo! The animals come from the PUBLIC! Two kinds of people-those that don't care what happens to the animals and/or CHOOSE to remain ignorant of the fate of many animals that end up in shelters, or people who care, but find themselves in unexpected situations and must give up their pet. Of course, those people should have myriad options for rehoming their pet if they just put forth the effort, since according to Winograd, there is no overpopulation and plenty of homes waiting and looking for a pet. NKN wants the shelters to put forth more effort, so what about the public trying harder? Then the animals wouldn't be IN the shelter in the first place! So yeah, blaming the shelters seems pretty lame. I know there are bad shelters that need reform. I have seen plenty of 'No Kill' facilities that do too. There are many good shelters out there doing the best they can with what resources they have and still inundated with an endless supply of needy animals and still forced to euthanize to manage the problem in their community. Contrary to what Winograd would like us all to believe, there is NOT a great cache of money, space, fosters, volunteers, and adopters just waiting 'in the wings' in every community , to just swoop in and save the world.
photo
PatA
Pink is a 4 letter word
02:24 PM on 11/10/2010
Do you have a good plan to educate the American public about spay and neutering their pets? Before you can yell at the writer, you could make your commitment to your community to educate your neighbors.
12:58 PM on 11/16/2010
If No Kill can't work because the public is to blame, then how is Reno, NV, No Kill? And how is Charlottesville, VA? And how is Tompkins County, NY? There is a public in those places too, I can assure you.

We can blame the public all we want, and you're right, they are to blame. But that hasn't helped save animals and it never will. What will save animals is implementing the proven programs and policies of the No Kill Equation.
12:40 PM on 11/10/2010
So what happens when all the shelters are no kill shelters and get full and cant accept any more pets? People will just let them free to die in the streets or to reproduce. Im not saying these shelters have the best practices but exactly how many shelters are we goin to build? Are we going to do the same thing with these shelters that we do with our prisons? Overfill them and drain our public resources? I see their reasoning but they don't seem to consider anything else besides keeping animals alive in a cage for extended periods of time.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bcmom
Stop breeding puppies
08:19 PM on 11/10/2010
Most of the time they are taken to animal control for euthansia or people just dump them on the streets. That is the reality. You are right about keeping animals long term in cages. They do go stir crazy, especially some breeds. The bottom line is more animals are being killed than find homes. Many people are not going to s/n unless you show up with a mobile vet unit in their neighborhood because they do not care one way or the other whether the animal lives or dies to begin with. Also, to be fair there are people who are looking for low cost s/n but cannot find it. I live in a rural area. Economic times are very hard. Most of the dogs in shelters now are the small breeds puppymills predominantly breed. We always have tons of jacks, chis, doxies, etc. Yet, the mills continue to churn out puppies by the hundreds of thousands. There will never be a lack of puppies. I think someone was worried about that, don't!
12:59 PM on 11/16/2010
The No Kill sheltering system that Winograd talks about moves animals OUT of the shelter way faster than ordinary shelters. The average length of stay in Tompkins County New York was 8 days when Winograd was there. You do this through better customer service, increased marketing, and off-site adoptions 7 days a week at multiple locations. In other words, the shelter has to out-compete alternative sources for animals. It's not just about "keeping animals alive"; it is about getting them OUT of the shelter alive.
12:17 PM on 11/10/2010
My thanks for this excellent commentary. For starters, we need to replace our "throw-away-for-a-new-model" American value system in favor of nurturing lifelong responsibility for our pets. We need to ditch unrealistic temperament tests that demand an ideal of perfection that is inhumane by definition. And we need to stop using the term "euthanasia" or mercy killing when shelters kill animals because of an implied overflow of animals. Consider doing some reading at Nathan Winograd’s blog: http://www.nathanwinograd.com/?page_id=166
photo
PatA
Pink is a 4 letter word
02:26 PM on 11/10/2010
we NEED to do as Missouri did last week and make it harder for puppy mills to exist. Our states need to help with this. Texas, my state, has implemented laws concerning spectators at dogfights. It is a felony now. We're working on a law to not allow animal abusers to have another pet. We are also working on a state registry for animal abusers, just like sexual abusers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bcmom
Stop breeding puppies
08:11 PM on 11/10/2010
There is a push now by mill lobbyists to water down Prop B. If you want to sign a petition here is a link:

http://animals.change.org/petitions/view/dont_weaken_proposition_b
11:44 AM on 11/10/2010
I think no-kill shelters are great, and support them financially. But living in a big city, the shelters are almost always full, and will not take animals found. (I have lived in Chicago for 20 years, and the no-kill cat shelter has been at capacity/unable to take in cats for 2 decades!) They then suggest a shelter that kills dogs/cats after a certain period of time. Until we stop over-breeding dogs/cats/rabbits, this problem will not go away. 3 things need to happen: 1. Shut down the puppy mills, and 2. require licensing for all dogs and cats, and charge fixed dogs/cats next to nothing, charge huge fees for those who do not have their dogs/cats sterilized, and 3. boycott any store selling puppies and kittens. I look forward to the day when it is difficult to find a dog to adopt.
04:09 PM on 11/10/2010
I agree, I think every one who wants a pet should have to go to a controled pet center, and allowed to adopt only already spay or nutered pets. all pets should be registerd and the citys & or states will know where they are at all times who owns them etc. like regestering guns. No pet should even leave animal shelters until it is spayed or nutered. heck with this bring it back in 10 days BS if u want it spay it now! many leave on promise of spaying nutering and it never gets done! and i feel one county should touch base wtih counties around it placeing of over flow dogs into less used shelters also alowing for a bigger choce in types of pets available. from county to county.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Debbie338
What we manifest is before us
11:07 AM on 11/10/2010
Change IS possible. In our county, because of Nathan Winograd's books and No-Kill movement, we are moving toward a shelter system that is far more animal-friendly. Yes, people have to be more responsible with their pets, but we also have to abandon the traditional shelter paradigm where it's easier to kill animals than to help them.