afghanistan, Afghanistan study, Afghanistan War, al-qaida, pakistan, United Nations, warwire
afghanistan, Afghanistan study, Afghanistan War, al-qaida, pakistan, United Nations, warwire

Study: Afghanistan Could Turn Into A Failed State

ANNE FLAHERTY | January 29, 2008 09:03 PM EST | AP

Compare other versions »

stumbleupon :Study: Afghanistan Could Turn Into A Failed State   digg: Study: Afghanistan Could Turn Into A Failed State   reddit: Study: Afghanistan Could Turn Into A Failed State   del.icio.us: Study: Afghanistan Could Turn Into A Failed State

WASHINGTON — Afghanistan risks sliding into a failed state and becoming the "forgotten war" because of deteriorating international support and a growing violent insurgency, according to an independent study.

The assessment, co-chaired by retired Marine Corps Gen. James Jones and former U.N. Ambassador Thomas Pickering, serves as a warning to the Bush administration at a time military and congressional officials are debating how best to juggle stretched warfighting resources.

The administration wants to re-energize anti-terrorism efforts in Afghanistan and Pakistan, where al-Qaida is regenerating. But the U.S. still remains heavily invested in Iraq, and officials are sending strong signals that troop reductions there will slow or stop altogether this summer.

"Afghanistan stands at a crossroads," concludes the study, an advance copy of which was obtained by The Associated Press. "The progress achieved after six years of international engagement is under serious threat from resurgent violence, weakening international resolve, mounting regional challenges and a growing lack of confidence on the part of the Afghan people about the future direction of their country."

A major issue has been trying to win the war with "too few military forces and insufficient economic aid," the study adds.

Among the group's nearly three dozen recommendations: increase NATO force levels and military equipment sent to Afghanistan, decouple U.S. management of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, establish a special envoy to coordinate all U.S. policy on Afghanistan, and champion a unified strategy among partner nations to stabilize the country in five years.

Defense Secretary Robert Gates said he was not familiar with the study's findings, but he struck a more optimistic tone on Afghanistan's future.

"I would say that the security situation is good," Gates told The Associated Press. "We want to make sure it gets better, and I think there's still a need to coordinate civil reconstruction, the economic development side of it."

Gates said more troops are needed in Afghanistan, but "certainly not ours." When asked how many more NATO troops might be needed, he said that number should be determined by ground commanders.

Sen. John Kerry said it was "past time for wakeup calls" and that a "comprehensive, thoughtful approach" in Afghanistan was urgently needed.

"The same extremist group which plotted the attacks of 9/11 are reconstituting themselves on the Afghan border and grow more organized by the day, making the stakes higher and higher," said Kerry, D-Mass., a senior member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee.

The Jones-Pickering assessment, slated for public release on Wednesday, says the U.S. should rethink its military and economic strategy in Afghanistan in large part because of deteriorating support among voters in NATO countries.

If international forces are pulled, the fragile Afghan government would "likely fall apart," the report warns.

The study was a voluntary effort coordinated by the Center for the Study of the Presidency, a nonpartisan organization in Washington, as a follow-on to the Iraq Study Group. That study group was a congressionally mandated blue-ribbon panel hailed as the first major bipartisan assessment on the Iraq war since the 2003 invasion.

While the Afghanistan study has not created the same buzz as the Iraq assessment, the center's latest findings still are likely to wield political clout because of those involved.

Last year, Jones led a high-profile study on Iraq security forces, which was used by lawmakers to challenge President Bush's own assessments. Most recently, the retired Marine Corps general, known for his outspoken independence, was tapped to advise Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice on security aspects of the new Israeli-Palestinian peace talks.

Pickering was a longtime U.S. ambassador and a former undersecretary of state.

Panel members include Charles Robb, a former Democratic senator who served on the Iraq Study Group, and David Abshire, who helped organize the Iraq study. Abshire is president of the Center for the Study of the Presidency.

According to the report, the center decided to initiate the study after ISG discussions made clear that Afghanistan was at risk of becoming "the forgotten war."

"Participants and witnesses pointed to the danger of losing the war in Afghanistan unless a reassessment took place of the effort being undertaken in that country by the United States, NATO and the international community," the study states.

Similar problems were identified in two other assessments also due for release Wednesday, including one by the Atlantic Council in Washington, which Jones chairs. A separate study, led by Harlan Ullman, an adviser at the Center for Strategic and International Studies and the National Defense University, included specific proposals to rejuvenate Afghanistan's agricultural sector.

The Senate Foreign Relations Committee was expected to be briefed Wednesday on Afghanistan by intelligence officials. On Thursday, the panel will convene an open hearing, featuring testimony from Jones and Pickering. Also testifying Thursday will be Richard Boucher, assistant secretary of state for South and Central Asia.

Comments for this post are now closed


 
Comments
81
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)
- MTGradwell I'm a Fan of MTGradwell 4 fans permalink

In other news: There is a danger that bears will sh*t in the woods. There's a possibility of the Pope becoming a Catholic. Next week might have a Tuesday in it somewhere. George W. Bush might be a failed president. Taxes are a very real possibility. Liquid water might be wet...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:59 PM on 01/31/2008
- bookish I'm a Fan of bookish 4 fans permalink

Gollly. Ya think?

We are living in surreal world.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:32 PM on 01/31/2008

correction: it IS a failed state...for example, record opium exports...a real testimony to stability

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:29 PM on 01/31/2008
- azphil I'm a Fan of azphil 2 fans permalink

Afghanistan has never been a nation state in the commonly accepted meaning of that term. It as rarely had a central authority who's writ ran much beyond Kabul. Most of its people are loyal to their tribe or clan. Terms that have a tangible meaning to them, rather than some concept of a nation state. This area has been, and will continue to be, a hotpotch of tribes constantly warring with each other. Believing we can change this is the height of delusion as far as we westerners are concerned.
As went the Brits and the Soviets, so shall we Yanks.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:12 PM on 01/31/2008

Since Afganistan is a failed state the headline would be more accurate if it read...Afganistan could become a successful state.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:48 AM on 01/31/2008
- jubo I'm a Fan of jubo 8 fans permalink
photo

If a country cannot exploit its own resources, it is doomed.

Afghanistan could be more important to America's oil supply than even Saudi Arabia. In 1997 the BBC reported that the American Oil company UNOCAL tried to construct a pipeline from The Caspian Sea.

The Caspian Sea is a California-size body of salt water -- the world's largest landlocked body of water -- that may sit on as much as 200 billion barrels of oil, which would be 16 percent of the Earth's potential oil reserves. With today's prices, that could add up to $9 trillion in oil.

Not to mention natural gas.

Of course we consume so much of it all we must have it.

You do not have much of a military without them and you know what that means.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:51 AM on 01/31/2008
- loki I'm a Fan of loki 134 fans permalink
photo

We knew that was coming when Bush said he was spreading American style democracy there. The only reason I think we've survived over these past 100 years or so, is because we were a great country pre-Capitalist revolution and take over of the our government. Without an already great country built up for them to suck dry, we would surly have been a failed state a long time ago.
Afghanistan wasnt built up like our country was first, so they went straight from 3rd word, to hell after our wonderful capitalistic authoritarian that cloaked by the word , democracy took shape there. Im sure Hamad Karsi , who was the pipeline negotiator between US oil companies and Afghanistan pre-invasion and his presidency, has made millions or even billions of dollars off of the US and Afghan people. Same as Bush, Caryle group, US oil, Haliburton and other US capitalist groups have.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:00 PM on 01/30/2008
- S1m0n I'm a Fan of S1m0n 101 fans permalink
photo

Afghanistan has been a failed state since the seventies, before the soviet invasion; the only brief respite from collapse was--ironically or no--the Taliban era.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:32 PM on 01/30/2008
- sebocd I'm a Fan of sebocd 3 fans permalink

I beg your pardon. I never promised you a poppie garden. Geoge W. Bush ... The State of Dysunion 2008.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:29 PM on 01/30/2008

Could?

E Pleb Neesta
GODISNOWHERE
Blessed are the cheese makers.
It's Bush's war. Not the War in Iraq, or the War on Terror. It's Bush's. Give credit where credit is due.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:07 PM on 01/30/2008
- dr4Will I'm a Fan of dr4Will 10 fans permalink
photo

not true the great decider and McCan't would say--war mongers continue with McBush in the gop lead--a pathetic old man!!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:24 PM on 01/30/2008
- jubo I'm a Fan of jubo 8 fans permalink
photo

The Afghani Senate has just confirmed the sentence of a 23 year-old student of Balkh university, Sayed Parwez Kaambaksh, guilty of 'blasphemy' for publishing (he is also a journalist with a local paper, Jahan-e Naw) an Internet article in which the author deemed men and women should be equals in Islam. In addition the article wondered why men could have as many as four women whereas Islam condemns polygamy.

The sentence is death.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:29 PM on 01/30/2008

When did Afghanistan become a state? Reminds me of people talking about "reuniting" Korea. Never was united.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:04 PM on 01/30/2008
- realpolitic I'm a Fan of realpolitic 160 fans permalink

The U.S requested 7,000 additional troops from NATO and were denied. It shows the reluctance Europeans have to help us after how unnecessary, unilateral invasion of Iraq and Bushian "my way or the highway" diplomacy. Both of our military efforts may fail. Afghanistam may likely again become a failed state, in addition to the narco-state it is now. Northwest Pakistan, or the area known as Waziristan, is another failed state and launching pad for al Qaeda attacks. General Musharraf looks the other way.

Afghanistan is a failed state and Bush is a failed leader.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:29 PM on 01/30/2008
- Mavin1620 I'm a Fan of Mavin1620 13 fans permalink
photo

Flag waving is fine. I support the troops, and want to bring them home alive, not in body bags. Iraq is a civil war, always was. Afghanistan is where we should have focused and hunted down the terrorists. Now we are six years too late for that effort.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:21 PM on 01/30/2008
Page: 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect