More

Obama on NBC News: "Brian, You're Getting Too Many Memos From The Clinton Camp"

Huffington Post   First Posted: 03/28/08 03:45 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 01:25 PM ET

Obama Briwi

Last night on NBC Nightly News, anchor Brian Williams had a rather spicy interview with Barack Obama where he challenged the Illinois Senator on his health care plan, efforts to engage the Latino community and readiness for a general election.

Watch the abridged version (3:26) on last night's Nightly News below; full version (7:01) and full write-up below.





Williams started right out, citing a "senior Democrat" who had speculated that "if the Obama campaign had realized that health care was going to become as big a part of this election debate as it has, that perhaps you would have put out a more complete health care plan that had coverage for more people. Can you react to that?" Said Obama: "I reject that completely." Okay then. Obama maintained that he's always been for universal health care and that under his plan "everybody who wants health care will be able to get it," and then went on to criticize the Clinton plan (rather than address the main issue with his campaign, which is that allowing the young and healthy to opt out drives up costs, and that low-income Americans will take their chances and not sign up even if it is affordable. See Paul Krugman here.) Alas, Williams did not follow up on that point. Next Williams gave him an opportunity to respond to the tension between the campaigns, asking him if his opponents had done anything that had been "truly unfair" — Obama evaded, not answering either way but saying that he didn't want to "look backwards," and saying that anything had happened would "toughen him up" for when he eventually took on the Republicans. Other questions included asking if they had "mathematics" to back up the assertion that the Obama momentum would bring victory if only they'd had more time (Obama: Hard to tell but things are going great!) and wondering if this campaign was doing damage to the Democratic party and "dividing loyalties more than it need to" (odd question; it's a campaign, after all) — Obama predictably said nope, but did make the point that he thought he could get all of Clinton's supporters if he were the nominee, but it wouldn't be the same for Clinton because of his appeal to independents and Republicans.

Next, Williams raised the chatter that the Obama campaign had not paid due attention to Latinos, that he "perhaps didn't take the shot at it seriously enough?" It was here that Obama laughed: "Brian, you're getting too many memos from the Clinton camp." He said they're going after it, and the "gap is closing" between him and Clinton. Finally, Williams wondered if Obama was prepared to go up against the 'well-oiled Republican machine" and win in a general election; Obama said, hey, isn't that what they said about Clinton? "We keep on hearing all these reasons why we can't win," said Obama. "If we get through this nomination, we will certainly be battle-tested because I don't think my opponent in the Democratic party has been going out of their way to take it easy on me."

NB: The questions asked on air were the ones relating to mathematics and more time, the Latino vote, and readiness for the general election. Williams said that there had been plans (and "great efforts") to interview Clinton as well, but the schedules were incompatible.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST MEDIA

Last night on NBC Nightly News, anchor Brian Williams had a rather spicy interview with Barack Obama where he challenged the Illinois Senator on his health care plan, efforts to engage the Latino comm...
Last night on NBC Nightly News, anchor Brian Williams had a rather spicy interview with Barack Obama where he challenged the Illinois Senator on his health care plan, efforts to engage the Latino comm...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 492
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
photo
Bushwhacked
REGISTER! VOTE! OBAMA/BIDEN 2012!
01:45 AM on 02/09/2008
Hillary as the Democratic nominee will motivate the Republican base to vote for McCain/Huckabee because they are so hateful of her. Deserved or not (and it's not), conservatives have a very strong distaster for her - more so than for the lying, awful president we now have. Young people want change, many want someone new and Obama would fit that bill. More Republicans and Independents will vote for him than would for Hillary. If the goal is to get a Democrat in the White House, he is the right choice. It may not be fair, but if she and we can put our country and party before her political ambitions, legitimate though they be, then she will eventually accept this - and hopefully also a post in Obama's administration. If Hillary snags the nomination, he better be on the ticket and they better present a solid, united Democratic ticket.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hu.man
transformation through communication
03:37 PM on 02/08/2008
Notice how Brian Williams was lost when Obama turned the question around about him running against the "well-oiled machine". BW started blinking fast and moved his lips as if he was going to answer Obama's rhetorical question but nothing came out of that good-looking empty shell.

Also notice how BW has stolen a commonly used Tim Russert phrase: "How do you react to that?" Mr. TR wanna-be is really out of his league. Why can't we have the likes of Chris Mathews or Wolf Blitzer doing the evening news? Why do we have to put up with the fraud called Brian Williams?
11:28 PM on 02/07/2008
Odd question: Are conclusions optional on news articles? Are these even considered news articles?

Ok, a couple of odd questions.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gebby
artist gebhardtart advocate for a better world
02:25 PM on 02/07/2008
the writer of this post totally misrepresented obamas positions. for example young people opting out. he allows young people to be part of parents plan until age 25. he has thought through many problems. trust in his good thinking.
08:56 AM on 02/07/2008
It's so sad that men in general, just can't get over the facts that a women is qualified to be president. And some women feel the same way, how pathetic. LOOK! The reason the cable networks are catering to Obama, is the same reason they catered to Kerry and Gore. The know when it come's down to the wire, the republican machine will win against him. And the uneducated liberals still don't get it, and for that matter the educated one's also. All those prdominately white states that voted for Obama in the primary, won't vote for him in the general election. Liberals,keep doing the same thing and wishing for different results. If Obama win the primary, get ready for 8 more years of Republican rule.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AvgPseudoIntellectual
08:47 PM on 02/06/2008
How silly that this is billed as a tense interview. I think Obama did a stellar job, answering to the point and keeping a sense of humor.

Here's what's going on: so many folks have been tremendously interested in Obama, but were afraid to allow themselves to be inspired... until now. It's understandable that people would be afraid to shed their cynicism after so many years of horrible governance, but if there has ever, EVER been one person who could move us in an about-face toward a recognition of the inherent dignity of shared sacrifice & reward, it is Barack Obama.

I do not have any serious problems with Hillary, but she could never be the kind of leader Obama will be, gender aside. I am a feminist, and I know she has sometimes been unfairly attacked, but it is too hard to separate out the *unfair* fire she has taken from the many *deserved* criticisms.

I laugh at those with big frowns on their faces, talking about Hope and Change like that's a bad thing to believe in. Come on in, the water is warm!

OBAMA '08!!
12:53 PM on 02/06/2008
Everyone keeps talking of Hillary having more experience, that is what makes me shrug away from her, she and Bill have showed that they will be of the status quo. There needs to be a change in America, not the same old experienced politics. I hear what Obama is saying and I don't know. Definately the Clintons have shown it will be the same old same.
06:34 AM on 02/06/2008
transendentist, you are full of crap. you want everyone to post links to prove this or that, and when they do post the links you just conveniently ignore it. what an ass.
01:10 AM on 02/06/2008
Hillary is our most qualified candidate.

She is most qualified to help our economy.

McCain and Obama are not qualified to help
our economy.

I am so proud of her.
11:35 PM on 02/05/2008
What a cute, empty slogen " change! change!".
What change? Loose change?

If you want change, CHANGE YOUR OWN damn DIAPERS!
Then go vote for somebody who has proven she can deliver. HILLARY.

The boys have flunked out. They don't rule, they ruin. It's time to change to a woman for President.
09:50 PM on 02/05/2008
If you think Hillary's plan lacks specifics, take a gander at the Paul Krugman piece. If you think Obama's plan provides a detailed thumbnail sketch; read the Paul Krugman piece. I think Brian should have asked why the subcommittee he chairs has had not had any hearings, and why no fact finding trips. Does not NATO play a significant role in our "war on terror"? Seriously folks, JFK spoke of hope and change after traveling Eastern and Western Europe right before Hitler declared war on England; thus his book ..."Why England Slept" He was able to lend a keen ear to the whispers echoing in the Court of St. James, and years later, he joined up. So if that’s the best our wunderkind can come up w/on the uptake; we Dems are in deep trouble. And with respect to Iraq, there is no fifth corner.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BrooklynLager
07:01 PM on 02/05/2008
In all seriousness, I like Brian Williams. I think he's responding to criticism from Hillary supporters that Obama's coverage has been too positive by providing a "tough" interview.

But his questions are idiotic. "Do you wish you had courted Latinos more vigourously?" What does that have to do with anything?

They were all horserace questions. I dunno, maybe he's on a deadline.
07:00 PM on 02/05/2008
I found this link hysterical on Hannity and Colmes - Obama supporters asked at a Frank Luntz focus group asked about why they are supporting Obama.


http://www.taylormarsh.com/archives_view.php?id=26949
06:59 PM on 02/05/2008
Little whiner can't take the heat.I'm shocked, shocked that Brian would dare ask him questions!!!
06:51 PM on 02/05/2008
Do people watch Williams???? I thought Charlie Gibson was #1, now I know why!!!!