Chris Kattan married model Sunshine Tutt in Yosemite Valley, Calif., on Saturday, PEOPLE has confirmed.
The former Saturday Night Live cast member, 37, started dating Tutt, 31, in the spring of 2005 after meeting her at a birthday party. He proposed on Christmas Eve 2006 at her grandparents' home in Gainsville, Texas.
"Originally I was going to do something very special," Kattan told PEOPLE about the engagement. "I tried to get Bono of U2 to serenade her. That didn't happen. Then I asked Justin Timberlake. No answer. After hundreds of phone calls and text messages, I finally ended up asking one of the members of the Hanson group. He didn't want to get involved."
THE spot for your favorite fan theories and the best Netflix recs. Learn more